Pinehurst No2 - to Caddie or not to Caddie

BSprinkBSprink Members Posts: 168 ✭✭
Hello All,



A few buddies and myself are playing No.2 this weekend and I'm trying to decide on whether or not to use their Caddie services.



I'm leaning towards "yes" just to get the full experience.



Caddie Options are as follows...



Single Caddie: $82

Caddie carrying two bags: $56 per player

Forecaddie: $26 per player


"Our recommended caddie gratuity is $30 and up per bag for a walking caddie, and $20 per bag and up for a forecaddie."





Anyone have any experience with any of these services...? Thoughts? Suggestions..?
«1

Comments

  • PhreddyPhreddy Members Posts: 613 ✭✭
    First time playing #2? Yes. Get a caddie. It not only enhances the experience but it will help you immeasurably with shots into very diabolical greens. Playing #2 is an experience, make the most of it.



    Phred
    If you need a grinder to make your weld look good, you are a grinder not a welder.
  • BSprinkBSprink Members Posts: 168 ✭✭
    Phreddy wrote:


    First time playing #2? Yes. Get a caddie. It not only enhances the experience but it will help you immeasurably with shots into very diabolical greens. Playing #2 is an experience, make the most of it.



    Phred




    Yes... First time there.



    I'm having a hard time picturing being out there with a caddie carrying two bags. With that said.. I'm leaning towards the single caddie myself.
  • TKD24TKD24 Members Posts: 1,093 ✭✭
    BSprink wrote:

    Phreddy wrote:


    First time playing #2? Yes. Get a caddie. It not only enhances the experience but it will help you immeasurably with shots into very diabolical greens. Playing #2 is an experience, make the most of it.



    Phred




    Yes... First time there.



    I'm having a hard time picturing being out there with a caddie carrying two bags. With that said.. I'm leaning towards the single caddie myself.




    These guys double bag it all the time. I wouldn't worry about it, unless you really want a single.



    And just a heads up, I'd pay the double as if he carried two (as long as he did a great job) singles.
    Titleist 915D3 9.5°, 915F 15°, 915H 18°<br />Mizuno MP-H4, 4i-PW<br />Vokey SM6 52°,56°,60º<br />Scotty Cameron X5
  • BMCBMC Members Posts: 3,557 ✭✭
    Yes, use a caddie. Double bag is fine, bring you're lighter travel bag. The caddie experience will make you feel like a boss.

    They're friendly and very helpful.
    PING Rapture V1 Driver 9*
    Cobra Baffler Pro 18* & 23* hybrids
    Titleist 755 irons
    Vokey Wedges 46/54/58
    Odyssey #1WS
  • leoh923leoh923 Members Posts: 1,243
    Take a caddie, the course is cart path only, and it is a real pain in the butt to play it out of a cart. The caddie will be a huge help on shots into the greens, and reading your putts. No worries about a caddie carrying double, I've split a caddie with a friend several times, and it's always been a great experience, well worth the extra $90 - $100. Nothing like walking up 18 with a caddie.
    Cobra Fly-Z driver
    Cobra Speed LD 3 wood
    Adams LS 3 hybrid
    TM Rocketbladez 4 - AW
    Ping Tour 56
    TM ATV 60
    Scotty Cameron Newport 2
  • BMCBMC Members Posts: 3,557 ✭✭
    leoh923 wrote:


    Take a caddie, the course is cart path only, and it is a real pain in the butt to play it out of a cart. The caddie will be a huge help on shots into the greens, and reading your putts. No worries about a caddie carrying double, I've split a caddie with a friend several times, and it's always been a great experience, well worth the extra $90 - $100. Nothing like walking up 18 with a caddie.




    I hit into a greenside bunker on 18 and then thinned one onto the veranda full of drinking golfers. It rattled around and bounced out into the grass. I got it up and down amidst some heckling.
    PING Rapture V1 Driver 9*
    Cobra Baffler Pro 18* & 23* hybrids
    Titleist 755 irons
    Vokey Wedges 46/54/58
    Odyssey #1WS
  • fairways4lifefairways4life Members Posts: 1,553 ✭✭
    edited Mar 15, 2016 #8
    I caddied on #2 for almost 5 years. So obviously I'm a bit biased but here's my take on it.



    -- It's cart path only all the time on #2. And the carts paths are not exactly close to the fairways. Most people who ride end up actually doing more walking because of all the back and forth to the fairway and back. Not only are you walking just as much (if not more), but you're also missing the golf course. How can you enjoy it and take it all in when you're buried in a cart in the tree line? To get the full experience of the course, you have to walk the fairways. There's also no yardage markers on the cart paths or 150-yard sticks in the fairways. From the cart, you really have no idea how far you have to the green. How many clubs do you feel like lugging all the way to your ball and back (plus your rangefinder)? And if you miss a fairway and end up in the wiregrass, you don't know how much of a shot you will have and therefore won't know what you will need. With a caddie, everything you have is right there with you.



    -- Don't worry about your caddie carrying two bags. We did it every day. It's the norm. And as long as you don't get a rookie without much experience, you really won't spend much time standing around waiting for your clubs. There's a method to the madness and a good caddie will be at your ball before you are.



    -- A good caddie WILL save you a few shots. There's a ton of breaks on those greens that only the caddies know. Your eyes will deceive you. It's more than just the greens though. How much room is between that bunker and the green? What's behind the green? Is there fairway over there or is that all waste area? You can't always see what's up ahead and the caddie will let you know where to miss and where not to. Especially helpful when escaping the waste areas and you can't attack the green because of the lie so you have to try to dump a shot into a safe area and get it up and down for par.



    -- You're already spending a small fortune to play there, may as well pay the little extra to complete the experience. How often do you get to play with a caddie? For most people, only a handful of times ever. May as well do it when you can. If anything is worth doing, it's worth doing right.



    Have fun and good luck. It's one **** of a test of golf.
    Post edited by Unknown User on
  • BMCBMC Members Posts: 3,557 ✭✭


    I caddied on #2 for almost 5 years. So obviously I'm a bit biased but here's my take on it.



    -- It's cart path only all the time on #2. And the carts paths are not exactly close to the fairways. Most people who ride end up actually doing more walking because of all the back and forth to the fairway and back. Not only are you walking just as much (if not more), but you're also missing the golf course. How can you enjoy it and take it all in when you're buried in a cart in the tree line? To get the full experience of the course, you have to walk the fairways. There's also no yardage markers on the cart paths or 150-yard sticks in the fairways. From the cart, you really have no idea how far you have to the green. How many clubs do you feel like lugging all the way to your ball and back (plus your rangefinder)? And if you miss a fairway and end up in the wiregrass, you don't know how much of a shot you will have and therefore won't know what you will need. With a caddie, everything you have is right there with you.



    -- Don't worry about your caddie carrying two bags. We did it every day. It's the norm. And as long as you don't get a rookie without much experience, you really won't spend much time standing around waiting for your clubs. There's a method to the madness and a good caddie will be at your ball before you are.



    -- A good caddie WILL save you a few shots. There's a ton of breaks on those greens that only the caddies know. Your eyes will deceive you.



    -- You're already spending a small fortune to play there, may as well pay the little extra to complete the experience. How often do you get to play with a caddie? For most people, only a handful of times ever. May as well do it when you can. If anything is worth doing, it's worth doing right.



    Have fun and good luck. It's one **** of a test of golf.




    Nice post. That was exactly my experience. Worth every dollar - at least once.
    PING Rapture V1 Driver 9*
    Cobra Baffler Pro 18* & 23* hybrids
    Titleist 755 irons
    Vokey Wedges 46/54/58
    Odyssey #1WS
  • crazy8golfercrazy8golfer Unregistered Posts: 1,292
    Single Caddie !
  • Golfing_LeftyGolfing_Lefty Members Posts: 89 ✭✭
    If it is your first time definitely...... They will make it very much more enjoyable plus they will share the history of the course with you as you play..... It will be a truly memorable experience!
    Taylormade M3 9.5 w/ Aldila ADX Tour Green 65 Stiff Flex
    Taylormade M3 3W w/ Hazardous Black Stiff Flex
    Taylormade M3 Hybrid w/ Graphite Design ADDI Stiff Flex
    Titleist 718 AP2 / Project X LZ Stiff
    Titleist SM7 52, 56 and 60 Degree Wedges
    Scotty Cameron Select Prototype Newport 2 / 35"
  • rkristopherandersonrkristopheranderson Members Posts: 435 ✭✭
    Caddy. No brainer.
    Ping G25 @ 9degrees/TFC 189D stiff
    Callaway XHot2 pro/13.5 degrees/Aldila TG stiff
    Titleist 913H/19 degrees/Aldila TG stiff
    Ping s55/4-W/KBS Tour R+ [ .5 long]
    Glide 50 w. Wrx grind
    Vokey SM5 54-10/S grind
    Vokey SM4 60-04
    Scotty Cameron California Monterrey
  • mileslongmileslong Members Posts: 201 ✭✭
    Caddie is a must on 2, if you take a cart you'll miss out much of the beauty that is #2
    Ping G400 10 LST Kuro Kage DC 60TX
    Ping G410 LST 3 wood Evenflow 6.0
    Ping G410 3h Evenflow 6.0
    Ping i500s 4-U PX LZ 6.0
    Ping Glide 2 Stealth 54 and 58 PX Lz 6.0
    Ping Fetch
    Snell Red soon to be X
  • BSprinkBSprink Members Posts: 168 ✭✭


    I caddied on #2 for almost 5 years. So obviously I'm a bit biased but here's my take on it.



    -- It's cart path only all the time on #2. And the carts paths are not exactly close to the fairways. Most people who ride end up actually doing more walking because of all the back and forth to the fairway and back. Not only are you walking just as much (if not more), but you're also missing the golf course. How can you enjoy it and take it all in when you're buried in a cart in the tree line? To get the full experience of the course, you have to walk the fairways. There's also no yardage markers on the cart paths or 150-yard sticks in the fairways. From the cart, you really have no idea how far you have to the green. How many clubs do you feel like lugging all the way to your ball and back (plus your rangefinder)? And if you miss a fairway and end up in the wiregrass, you don't know how much of a shot you will have and therefore won't know what you will need. With a caddie, everything you have is right there with you.



    -- Don't worry about your caddie carrying two bags. We did it every day. It's the norm. And as long as you don't get a rookie without much experience, you really won't spend much time standing around waiting for your clubs. There's a method to the madness and a good caddie will be at your ball before you are.



    -- A good caddie WILL save you a few shots. There's a ton of breaks on those greens that only the caddies know. Your eyes will deceive you. It's more than just the greens though. How much room is between that bunker and the green? What's behind the green? Is there fairway over there or is that all waste area? You can't always see what's up ahead and the caddie will let you know where to miss and where not to. Especially helpful when escaping the waste areas and you can't attack the green because of the lie so you have to try to dump a shot into a safe area and get it up and down for par.



    -- You're already spending a small fortune to play there, may as well pay the little extra to complete the experience. How often do you get to play with a caddie? For most people, only a handful of times ever. May as well do it when you can. If anything is worth doing, it's worth doing right.



    Have fun and good luck. It's one **** of a test of golf.




    I was leaning towards single caddie and this post helped me make up my mind. image/smile.png' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':)' /> Great info.. Thanks!
  • fairways4lifefairways4life Members Posts: 1,553 ✭✭
    edited Mar 16, 2016 #15
    BSprink wrote:



    I caddied on #2 for almost 5 years. So obviously I'm a bit biased but here's my take on it.



    -- It's cart path only all the time on #2. And the carts paths are not exactly close to the fairways. Most people who ride end up actually doing more walking because of all the back and forth to the fairway and back. Not only are you walking just as much (if not more), but you're also missing the golf course. How can you enjoy it and take it all in when you're buried in a cart in the tree line? To get the full experience of the course, you have to walk the fairways. There's also no yardage markers on the cart paths or 150-yard sticks in the fairways. From the cart, you really have no idea how far you have to the green. How many clubs do you feel like lugging all the way to your ball and back (plus your rangefinder)? And if you miss a fairway and end up in the wiregrass, you don't know how much of a shot you will have and therefore won't know what you will need. With a caddie, everything you have is right there with you.



    -- Don't worry about your caddie carrying two bags. We did it every day. It's the norm. And as long as you don't get a rookie without much experience, you really won't spend much time standing around waiting for your clubs. There's a method to the madness and a good caddie will be at your ball before you are.



    -- A good caddie WILL save you a few shots. There's a ton of breaks on those greens that only the caddies know. Your eyes will deceive you. It's more than just the greens though. How much room is between that bunker and the green? What's behind the green? Is there fairway over there or is that all waste area? You can't always see what's up ahead and the caddie will let you know where to miss and where not to. Especially helpful when escaping the waste areas and you can't attack the green because of the lie so you have to try to dump a shot into a safe area and get it up and down for par.



    -- You're already spending a small fortune to play there, may as well pay the little extra to complete the experience. How often do you get to play with a caddie? For most people, only a handful of times ever. May as well do it when you can. If anything is worth doing, it's worth doing right.



    Have fun and good luck. It's one **** of a test of golf.




    I was leaning towards single caddie and this post helped me make up my mind. image/smile.png' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':)' /> Great info.. Thanks!




    The single caddie actually ends up costing you more so you can save money by splitting. I can see how it can be nice having your own caddie but then you aren't as engaged with your buddy and his round. When you and a friend split a caddie, you're more in tune with what your buddy is doing and have a chance to walk alongside him more because players have the tendency to walk alongside their caddy. When everyone in the group has singles, I find that they tend to sort of just stick to themselves and their own caddie and their own round and become less engaged with the others in the group. Just my observation from doing hundreds of loops on the Deuce. It also makes betting more fun with doubles because you'll have one team sharing one caddie and another team sharing another caddie so you become a three-man team trying to win (and the caddies will get in on the action too, which just makes it all the more fun).
  • SheriffBoothSheriffBooth Marshals, BST Volunteer Mods Posts: 4,440 mod
    Definitely take a caddie. Getting to walk the course, whether the caddie helps or not, is worth the money.



    Also, I'd say $30 is the minimum tip, and that's if the guy does nothing for you at all. If you enjoy the experience, and he helps you make a few putts or keeps you out of trouble, don't hesitate to throw another $20 or more on top of that. It's how many of those guys make a living.
    Taylormade M6, 9.0*, Hzrdus Smoke 60 S
    Taylormade M5, 15*, Hzrdus Smoke 70 S
    Callaway Apex 3H, Kuro Kage S
    Taylormade P-790, 4-PW, Recoil 110 F4 +1"
    Taylormade MG 50, 56, 60 Recoil 110 F4 +1"
    Cameron Futura 5.5M, 36"
  • fairways4lifefairways4life Members Posts: 1,553 ✭✭
    I'll add one more thing I forgot to mention in regards to single bag caddie vs. double bag caddie. Kind of a dirty little secret....



    When players request a single bag caddie, they tend to be given a less experienced caddie. Typically, when your new you're going to be given a lot of singles so that the caddie can ease his way into it. Once they gain some experience carrying singles, the caddie master will start to give them some doubles. You don't typically start carrying doubles right away. So if you want a good, experienced caddie that knows what they're doing and knows the course, go for a double. It's one way to ensure you'll get a more experienced looper and not someone fresh out of the training program.
  • BSprinkBSprink Members Posts: 168 ✭✭


    I'll add one more thing I forgot to mention in regards to single bag caddie vs. double bag caddie. Kind of a dirty little secret....



    When players request a single bag caddie, they tend to be given a less experienced caddie. Typically, when your new you're going to be given a lot of singles so that the caddie can ease his way into it. Once they gain some experience carrying singles, the caddie master will start to give them some doubles. You don't typically start carrying doubles right away. So if you want a good, experienced caddie that knows what they're doing and knows the course, go for a double. It's one way to ensure you'll get a more experienced looper and not someone fresh out of the training program.




    Thanks!
  • cristphotocristphoto Members Posts: 3,315 ✭✭
    Get a caddy. At #2 it's worth it. Just standing on the first tee all you see is sand. My caddy watched me warm up in the range and quickly sized up my distances. Very helpful. Plus some of the greens are nasty. I would read a l-r break and the caddy would read r-l. He was right every time. Plus the jokes and stories they tell are amazing. I gave a $50 tip and that seemed to be the norm (2 years ago).
  • Carl Spackler3Carl Spackler3 Members Posts: 924 ✭✭
    The times I've used caddies I've shot low on unfamiliar tracks , enjoy the help no question
    Titleist 915 D2
    Ping G 3 W
    Ping G 5W
    Ping G25 Hybrid
    Mizuno JPX 900 hot metal 5-GW
    Vokey 52-08 sm4
    Vokey 56-14 sm6
    Odyssey White Hot RX2 ( but it better be careful)
  • bmr4242bmr4242 Members Posts: 361 ✭✭
    Like many have said takes a caddy. Played last year and did the double - honestly never could tell he had 2 bags. Was always where I needed him.



    Make you bag as light as possible. You won't need more than 3 balls. Empty everything else you don't need to help them with the weight and enjoy!
  • Argonne69Argonne69 Members Posts: 20,401 ✭✭
    Caddie? Yes, and single for me every time. I've had a double twice (Erin Hills), and it was a p*ss poor experience each time. Never again. Nothing like standing around in the right rough waiting for your caddie to find your partner's ball in the left rough.



    Yes, in theory a double can handle two golfers, but the planets have to align. If not, it can be a train wreck. Why chance it? If you want to stroll along with your partner, there's nothing stopping you if you have your own caddie.
  • dhc1dhc1 NYCMembers Posts: 877 ✭✭
    Argonne69 wrote:


    Caddie? Yes, and single for me every time. I've had a double twice (Erin Hills), and it was a p*ss poor experience each time. Never again. Nothing like standing around in the right rough waiting for your caddie to find your partner's ball in the left rough.



    Yes, in theory a double can handle two golfers, but the planets have to align. If not, it can be a train wreck. Why chance it? If you want to stroll along with your partner, there's nothing stopping you if you have your own caddie.




    Fair enough, but as mentioned above, the best caddies will always go out as double as they'll make a lot more. If you get a single, the best hope is that it's an older experienced guy who simply can't carry two bags anymore.
  • dhc1dhc1 NYCMembers Posts: 877 ✭✭

    BSprink wrote:



    I caddied on #2 for almost 5 years. So obviously I'm a bit biased but here's my take on it.



    -- It's cart path only all the time on #2. And the carts paths are not exactly close to the fairways. Most people who ride end up actually doing more walking because of all the back and forth to the fairway and back. Not only are you walking just as much (if not more), but you're also missing the golf course. How can you enjoy it and take it all in when you're buried in a cart in the tree line? To get the full experience of the course, you have to walk the fairways. There's also no yardage markers on the cart paths or 150-yard sticks in the fairways. From the cart, you really have no idea how far you have to the green. How many clubs do you feel like lugging all the way to your ball and back (plus your rangefinder)? And if you miss a fairway and end up in the wiregrass, you don't know how much of a shot you will have and therefore won't know what you will need. With a caddie, everything you have is right there with you.



    -- Don't worry about your caddie carrying two bags. We did it every day. It's the norm. And as long as you don't get a rookie without much experience, you really won't spend much time standing around waiting for your clubs. There's a method to the madness and a good caddie will be at your ball before you are.



    -- A good caddie WILL save you a few shots. There's a ton of breaks on those greens that only the caddies know. Your eyes will deceive you. It's more than just the greens though. How much room is between that bunker and the green? What's behind the green? Is there fairway over there or is that all waste area? You can't always see what's up ahead and the caddie will let you know where to miss and where not to. Especially helpful when escaping the waste areas and you can't attack the green because of the lie so you have to try to dump a shot into a safe area and get it up and down for par.



    -- You're already spending a small fortune to play there, may as well pay the little extra to complete the experience. How often do you get to play with a caddie? For most people, only a handful of times ever. May as well do it when you can. If anything is worth doing, it's worth doing right.



    Have fun and good luck. It's one **** of a test of golf.




    I was leaning towards single caddie and this post helped me make up my mind. image/smile.png' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':)' /> Great info.. Thanks!




    The single caddie actually ends up costing you more so you can save money by splitting. I can see how it can be nice having your own caddie but then you aren't as engaged with your buddy and his round. When you and a friend split a caddie, you're more in tune with what your buddy is doing and have a chance to walk alongside him more because players have the tendency to walk alongside their caddy. When everyone in the group has singles, I find that they tend to sort of just stick to themselves and their own caddie and their own round and become less engaged with the others in the group. Just my observation from doing hundreds of loops on the Deuce. It also makes betting more fun with doubles because you'll have one team sharing one caddie and another team sharing another caddie so you become a three-man team trying to win (and the caddies will get in on the action too, which just makes it all the more fun).




    How much of the caddy fee (not tip) does the caddy get vs. the resort? Thanks



    Single Caddie: $82

    Caddie carrying two bags: $56 per player

    Forecaddie: $26 per player
  • fairways4lifefairways4life Members Posts: 1,553 ✭✭
    edited Mar 16, 2016 #25
    dhc1 wrote:


    BSprink wrote:



    I caddied on #2 for almost 5 years. So obviously I'm a bit biased but here's my take on it.



    -- It's cart path only all the time on #2. And the carts paths are not exactly close to the fairways. Most people who ride end up actually doing more walking because of all the back and forth to the fairway and back. Not only are you walking just as much (if not more), but you're also missing the golf course. How can you enjoy it and take it all in when you're buried in a cart in the tree line? To get the full experience of the course, you have to walk the fairways. There's also no yardage markers on the cart paths or 150-yard sticks in the fairways. From the cart, you really have no idea how far you have to the green. How many clubs do you feel like lugging all the way to your ball and back (plus your rangefinder)? And if you miss a fairway and end up in the wiregrass, you don't know how much of a shot you will have and therefore won't know what you will need. With a caddie, everything you have is right there with you.



    -- Don't worry about your caddie carrying two bags. We did it every day. It's the norm. And as long as you don't get a rookie without much experience, you really won't spend much time standing around waiting for your clubs. There's a method to the madness and a good caddie will be at your ball before you are.



    -- A good caddie WILL save you a few shots. There's a ton of breaks on those greens that only the caddies know. Your eyes will deceive you. It's more than just the greens though. How much room is between that bunker and the green? What's behind the green? Is there fairway over there or is that all waste area? You can't always see what's up ahead and the caddie will let you know where to miss and where not to. Especially helpful when escaping the waste areas and you can't attack the green because of the lie so you have to try to dump a shot into a safe area and get it up and down for par.



    -- You're already spending a small fortune to play there, may as well pay the little extra to complete the experience. How often do you get to play with a caddie? For most people, only a handful of times ever. May as well do it when you can. If anything is worth doing, it's worth doing right.



    Have fun and good luck. It's one **** of a test of golf.




    I was leaning towards single caddie and this post helped me make up my mind. image/smile.png' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':)' /> Great info.. Thanks!




    The single caddie actually ends up costing you more so you can save money by splitting. I can see how it can be nice having your own caddie but then you aren't as engaged with your buddy and his round. When you and a friend split a caddie, you're more in tune with what your buddy is doing and have a chance to walk alongside him more because players have the tendency to walk alongside their caddy. When everyone in the group has singles, I find that they tend to sort of just stick to themselves and their own caddie and their own round and become less engaged with the others in the group. Just my observation from doing hundreds of loops on the Deuce. It also makes betting more fun with doubles because you'll have one team sharing one caddie and another team sharing another caddie so you become a three-man team trying to win (and the caddies will get in on the action too, which just makes it all the more fun).




    How much of the caddy fee (not tip) does the caddy get vs. the resort? Thanks



    Single Caddie: $82

    Caddie carrying two bags: $56 per player

    Forecaddie: $26 per player





    Roughly 50%. Little more for a forecaddie, little less for double bag carry.



    But don't base your tip on that. Base your tip on the level of service performed by the caddie. $30-40 for minimum service. $50 and up if they do a really great job and you would take them again or recommend them to a friend.



    (**Sadly, Pinehurst caddies actually make quite a bit less per round than caddies at other major courses and resorts, despite having one of the more regimented hiring/training programs)
  • BSprinkBSprink Members Posts: 168 ✭✭




    Roughly 50%. Little more for a forecaddie, little less for double bag carry.



    But don't base your tip on that. Base your tip on the level of service performed by the caddie. $30-40 for minimum service. $50 and up if they do a really great job and you would take them again or recommend them to a friend.



    (**Sadly, Pinehurst caddies actually make quite a bit less per round than caddies at other major courses and resorts, despite having one of the more regimented hiring/training programs)




    As a caddie, would you prefer two bags...?



    I assumed the tipped amount would be $50-$100.. 25-30% of the cost of the round.
  • fairways4lifefairways4life Members Posts: 1,553 ✭✭
    edited Mar 16, 2016 #27
    BSprink wrote:



    Roughly 50%. Little more for a forecaddie, little less for double bag carry.



    But don't base your tip on that. Base your tip on the level of service performed by the caddie. $30-40 for minimum service. $50 and up if they do a really great job and you would take them again or recommend them to a friend.



    (**Sadly, Pinehurst caddies actually make quite a bit less per round than caddies at other major courses and resorts, despite having one of the more regimented hiring/training programs)




    As a caddie, would you prefer two bags...?



    I assumed the tipped amount would be $50-$100.. 25-30% of the cost of the round.




    Absolutely prefer two bags. Every time. Just do the math.



    Single bag pays around $35 on your paycheck plus typically $40-50 on a tip for a total of typically less than $100.



    Double bag pays around $55 on your paycheck plus $40-50 from each player for a total of around $150.



    So it comes down to collecting one bag fee and one tip vs. collecting two bag fees and two tips.



    Doing a double is a bit more work than a single but you're making considerably more money in the same amount of time.
  • dhc1dhc1 NYCMembers Posts: 877 ✭✭
    Thanks, fairway4life. I'd be interested in hearing where the consensus best courses to caddy are, irrespective of public/private (both in summer and winter)?
  • fairways4lifefairways4life Members Posts: 1,553 ✭✭
    dhc1 wrote:


    Thanks, fairway4life. I'd be interested in hearing where the consensus best courses to caddy are, irrespective of public/private (both in summer and winter)?




    Pinehurst is the only place I ever caddied so I can only really speak for there. We were pretty fortunate in that we always stayed fairly busy for about 9 months out of the year (the winter time is practically all just member play and the members rarely take caddies as they are allowed to carry their own bags). Summer time is slow but reasonably steady. Spring and fall are the busy seasons.



    Courses up north obviously have a much shorter season. Down south (like Florida) they are busy in the winter time but slow down a bit in the heat of the summer.



    Basically, the caddie money follows the resort players. People tend to take golf trips to the south in the winter and go north in the summer time.



    Pinehurst is part of CaddieMaster, which is a caddie company that includes a few dozen courses (including Augusta). So if you work for CaddieMaster, you can move around to the different courses within the network throughout the year. So a lot of guys stay at Pinehurst for the spring rush, then go somewhere up north for the summer rush up there, then back to Pinehurst in the fall for our fall busy season and then to Florida for the winter season. That way, they are always working during a busy season.



    Like I said, I never traveled when I did it so I can't speak for other courses. I did play Torrey Pines once with a caddie and I would have to imagine that view of the ocean never gets old. Same goes for caddying at Pebble I'm sure. Although Augusta is part of the network, it's not easy getting a spot down there. Obviously that would be awesome (no double bags at Augusta though; only singles).



    I know a handful of guys that used to go to Whistling Straits in the summer time to catch the busy season up there. They made good money but they all said that course is an absolute brute to walk and the rounds are super long because you're looking for lost balls all day.



    I guess that's another thing that was good about Pinehurst --- it's an easy walk and it's tough to lose a ball out there.



    I know of a couple guys that go to Liberty National or a place in the Hamptons in the summer time and they absolutely kill it for a few months caddying for hedge fund managers and what not every day.



    But the best part by far about caddying is the playing and practice privileges. Only got to play #2 once a year in our caddie tournament but the other courses (there's 9 total) were up for grabs anytime there was an open tee time. Plus all the range balls you could ever hit. Putting greens, chipping greens. We were definitely spoiled in that regard and that was a big reason that I ended up doing it for almost 5 years when I originally thought it would just be a one-summer thing haha.
  • dlygrissedlygrisse Members Posts: 13,130 ✭✭
    Main thing about #2 ( I have played 3 rounds) is reading the greens. I read greens pretty good but those things are a mystery unless you have played them a few times. You can literally putt the ball off the green and it will go down a slope 20 yards from the green if you aren't careful on some holes. A caddy is invaluable around the greens.



    I remember one time on #17 I was above the hole about 15 feet straight down hill. I said it breaks about 2 feet left to right, correct? he looked and said no, right edge putt, just tap it.. I hit it right where he told me and drained it dead center. Probably saved me 5 or 6 strokes the first round.



    Double bagging would be fine, even selecting clubs is not that difficult, but get a caddy and make sure they read putts for you, every single putt the first round. You will be happy you did.

    Ping G400
    Callaway Rogue 3w, HW
    Ping G 4 hybrid
    Ping G 4-U
    Ping Glide 2.0 Stealth 54* SS
    Vokey 58 M grind
    Odyssey Pro #1 black
    Jones Utility
    ECCO Biom Hybrid 3
  • fairways4lifefairways4life Members Posts: 1,553 ✭✭
    edited Mar 16, 2016 #31
    dlygrisse wrote:


    Main thing about #2 ( I have played 3 rounds) is reading the greens. I read greens pretty good but those things are a mystery unless you have played them a few times. You can literally putt the ball off the green and it will go down a slope 20 yards from the green if you aren't careful on some holes. A caddy is invaluable around the greens.



    I remember one time on #17 I was above the hole about 15 feet straight down hill. I said it breaks about 2 feet left to right, correct? he looked and said no, right edge putt, just tap it.. I hit it right where he told me and drained it dead center. Probably saved me 5 or 6 strokes the first round.



    Double bagging would be fine, even selecting clubs is not that difficult, but get a caddy and make sure they read putts for you, every single putt the first round. You will be happy you did.




    Glad you got a good read! (I'm guessing the pin was front-left that day and you were putting from the back-left image/wink.png' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=';)' />



    We always say: "The putts don't change, only the people hitting them."
Sign In or Register to comment.