Travel Cases: Hard Case vs Soft Case

MCGolfTMMCGolfTM Members Posts: 586 ✭✭
Looking at travel cases and wondering what everyone has done with soft cases vs hard cases?



SKB cases are too small in diameter for my TaylorMade bag it seems. The handle is too large and won’t fit them. SKB says all the cases are the same at the top and only get larger at the bottom. I didn’t want to load the case upside down if I didn’t have to.



Looking at the TaylorMade Performance Travel Cover and have seen good things, just worried about the soft cases. Anyone have good experiences with this case?
TM M3 460 9.5* Fujikura Pro73
TM '16 M2 3HL Fujikura Pro73
TM P790 UDI 17* PX HZRDUS Black 85
TM P790 4-9 DG 105
TM P770 PW KBS FLT 
TM Milled Grind 50/54 KBS 610
TM Spider Tour Black
TM TP5x
«1

Comments

  • MtlJeffMtlJeff MontrealMembers Posts: 28,489 ✭✭
    A lot of people will support soft cases. I have traveled once with a soft case and it was OK, though i stole roughly 25 towels from the hotel and stuffed it like a mummy. I don't find they support the clubheads enough so you have to pack some extra padding in there.



    I am a bit supporter of hardshell cases if you can tolerate the annoyance of lugging them around. They are heavy, they don't fit in every car, they are basically the worst thing you can bring into an airport. But you can attack them with a knife and they are fine. I had a datrek hard shell case and that thing would've survived the Apocalypse
    Cobra F8+ 9.5 w/Matrix Black Tie 80
    Callaway Epic Subzero 14* w/Matrix Black Tie 80
    Callaway Apex 20h w/Diamana D+ 95
    Callaway 2016 Apex Pro 4-PW w/S300
    Callaway MD Forged 52,56 w/S300
    Callaway MD 2.0 60 PM grind w/s300
    Odyssey O-works Red Tank #7
  • Sean2Sean2 #TheWRX (Callaway Trip) Members Posts: 30,826 ✭✭
    I prefer hard cases. Yes, you can take the head off you driver, and some woods, or use a stiff arm or both, but that seems to be a lot of bother, and you still aren't guaranteed that no damage will occur.
    [font=helvetica, arial, sans-serif]Callaway Rogue[/font]
    [font=helvetica, arial, sans-serif]Callaway GBB Epic 16º/20º/24º[/font]
    [font=helvetica, arial, sans-serif]Callaway Steelhead XR 25º[/font]
    [font=helvetica, arial, sans-serif]Callaway Apex CF16 6-AW [/font]
    [font=helvetica, arial, sans-serif]Callaway MD3/MD-PM 54º/58º[/font]
    [font=helvetica, arial, sans-serif]Callaway "O" Works #7[/font]
  • grochol17grochol17 Members Posts: 1,284 ✭✭
    I've got a Club Glove Last Bag travel cover, with the stiff arm, that I use on my Ping Hoofer bag. I've flown 4-5 times with it and never had any problems. Most of the trips were non-stops between Baltimore and Orlando on Southwest. One was a trip on US Air and I had to change planes once. I use my golf towel to wrap around the irons so they can't bang into each other during the trip and I've started taking the heads off of my woods, just in case. I can also fit two pairs of size 12 shoes in the shoe pockets.
    Ping G400 LST, 8.5*, HZRDUS Yellow 75 6.0
    Titleist 915 F, 14.25*, Speeder VC 8.2 Tour Spec X
    Mizuno MP H5, 1&3 iron, C Taper Lite X
    Mizuno MP 25, 4&5 iron, DG X100 SSx1
    Mizuno MP 5, 6-PW, DG X100 SSx1
    Titleist Vokey Spin Milled CC, 53* & 58* (DG S300)
    Piretti Potenza II Rev 2.0, 375g, 34"
    Srixon Z Star / Z Star XV 5
  • WAxORxDCxSCWAxORxDCxSC Members Posts: 110 ✭✭
    Depending on your home storage situation, you might want to consider one that folds down to take up less space. I really love my Ping Folding Travel Cover. It folds in half and takes up very little space in my closet. Used it on many flights and never had any damaged clubs. Fantastic.



    https://www.ping.com/gear/detail.aspx?id=15385

    TaylorMade M3 Driver 9.5* (Mitsubishi Tensei Pro Orange 70tx)
    TaylorMade M1 (2016) 3 Wood 15* (Mitsubishi Tensei Pro Blue 80tx)
    TaylorMade M2 Hybrid 19* (or) Mizuno MP-18 Fli-Hi 3 iron (Project X 6.5)
    Mizuno MP-18 Fli-Hi 4,5 iron (Project X 6.5)
    Mizuno MP5 6-PW (KBS C-Taper Lite 115x)
    Titleist Vokey SM6 50* 54*
    Taylormade Hi-Toe 60*
    Scotty Cameron Newport 2 Notchback 33"

    Bag 2 (Nostalgia Edition)
    Taylormade M1 (2017) 9.5* (Project X Hzrdus T1100 6.5 75g)
    TaylorMade M2 (2017) 3 wood
    Mizuno JPX 900 Tour 3-PW
    Cleveland 588 52*, 56*, 60*
    Spalding T.P. Mills "Computer Milled" Putter
  • bigred90gtbigred90gt Lefty Boomers Posts: 4,351 ✭✭
    I have a hard case. After having used it probably 10 times, and having 2-3 cracks in it from the idiots at the airport doing whatever it is they do with stuff that they didnt pay for, I will never use a soft case.
  • MCGolfTMMCGolfTM Members Posts: 586 ✭✭
    edited Nov 13, 2017 #7
    bigred90gt wrote:
    I have a hard case. After having used it probably 10 times, and having 2-3 cracks in it from the idiots at the airport doing whatever it is they do with stuff that they didnt pay for, I will never use a soft case.




    You’d never use a soft case cause of how badly they handled your hard case you mean?



    What brand Hard Case?
    TM M3 460 9.5* Fujikura Pro73
    TM '16 M2 3HL Fujikura Pro73
    TM P790 UDI 17* PX HZRDUS Black 85
    TM P790 4-9 DG 105
    TM P770 PW KBS FLT 
    TM Milled Grind 50/54 KBS 610
    TM Spider Tour Black
    TM TP5x
  • llamontllamont Members Posts: 1,823 ✭✭
    My Club Glove is approaching 20 years old and it still works like a charm. I did purchase a stiff arm attachment for added protection. I fold it in half and store it in a closet when not in use.
    I love golf
  • bigred90gtbigred90gt Lefty Boomers Posts: 4,351 ✭✭
    MCGolfTM wrote:

    bigred90gt wrote:
    I have a hard case. After having used it probably 10 times, and having 2-3 cracks in it from the idiots at the airport doing whatever it is they do with stuff that they didnt pay for, I will never use a soft case.




    You’d never use a soft case cause of how badly they handled your hard case you mean?



    What brand Hard Case?
    Yes that's what I mean. I have a hard case (it's possible it didnt make sense the way I said it the first time). I've used it probably 10 times. In that time, they have mishandled it to the point it now has 2-3 cracks in it. I can only imagine what would have happened to my clubs had they been in a soft case. If they threw it or dropped it or dropped something on it hard enough to crack it, I very well imagine it would have broken something had it been in a soft case.



    It is Golfmate. I bought it at a local sporting goods store back in 2010 or 2011 when I flew to Hilton Head for the Golfweek Am Tour nationals.





    https://www.tgw.com/golf-travel-bags-the-guardian-hard-travel-case?SITE_ID=A2004&CID=PLA&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIsL3czvO81wIVlCWBCh11YQGAEAQYASABEgL4j_D_BwE
  • mowakebummowakebum Mowakebum Members Posts: 52 ✭✭
    I’ve flown cross country a ton during the last three years and take my clubs with me every trip. I’ve used the club glove last bag and never had any issues at all. I have a sun mountain C-130. Use the telescoping rod and never had one issue. Highly recommended.
  • MCGolfTMMCGolfTM Members Posts: 586 ✭✭
    bigred90gt wrote:
    MCGolfTM wrote:

    bigred90gt wrote:
    I have a hard case. After having used it probably 10 times, and having 2-3 cracks in it from the idiots at the airport doing whatever it is they do with stuff that they didnt pay for, I will never use a soft case.




    You’d never use a soft case cause of how badly they handled your hard case you mean?



    What brand Hard Case?
    Yes that's what I mean. I have a hard case (it's possible it didnt make sense the way I said it the first time). I've used it probably 10 times. In that time, they have mishandled it to the point it now has 2-3 cracks in it. I can only imagine what would have happened to my clubs had they been in a soft case. If they threw it or dropped it or dropped something on it hard enough to crack it, I very well imagine it would have broken something had it been in a soft case.



    It is Golfmate. I bought it at a local sporting goods store back in 2010 or 2011 when I flew to Hilton Head for the Golfweek Am Tour nationals.





    https://www.tgw.com/golf-travel-bags-the-guardian-hard-travel-case?SITE_ID=A2004&CID=PLA&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIsL3czvO81wIVlCWBCh11YQGAEAQYASABEgL4j_D_BwE




    I was thinking of doing a Stiff Arm with a soft case if I went that route. I’m shocked that the SKB cases don’t fit some standard Stand bags. If I went with the deluxe version I would have to put the clubs in upside down and roll it which I’m not sure I’d be thrilled with either.
    TM M3 460 9.5* Fujikura Pro73
    TM '16 M2 3HL Fujikura Pro73
    TM P790 UDI 17* PX HZRDUS Black 85
    TM P790 4-9 DG 105
    TM P770 PW KBS FLT 
    TM Milled Grind 50/54 KBS 610
    TM Spider Tour Black
    TM TP5x
  • TaylorGreen  TaylorGreen Members Posts: 378 ✭✭
    My Club Glove Last Bag is still going strong after about 20 years. I don't use it a ton (probably only 18-20 times) but it looks brand new (which is incredible in itself given how the airlines handle baggage. I've used staff bags as well as stand bags and never had issues with any clubs being broken. That being said, I use a Stiff Arm and plenty of golf towels/beach towels along with shoes to help cushion any hard impacts. Honestly, the way this bag is designed, I couldn't ever go back to the days of the hard shell case. I hope I didn't just jinx myself.....
    [font=verdana,geneva,sans-serif]PXG 0811 LX w/RIP Phenom or EvenFlow Blue 55[/font]
    PXG 0341 15° w/EvenFlow Blue 55
    [font=verdana, geneva, sans-serif]PXG 0341 18° w/EvenFlow Blue 55[/font]
    PXG 0317 22° w/Accra 80i
    PXG 0311XF (5-W) w/ Recoil 95
    PXG 0311 50°/56°/60° w/Steelfiber 95
    [font="verdana, geneva, sans-serif"]Odyssey Mini Jailbird S[/font]
    [font=verdana, geneva, sans-serif]Titleist Pro V1x/Taylormade TP5x[/font]
  • MCGolfTMMCGolfTM Members Posts: 586 ✭✭
    My Club Glove Last Bag is still going strong after about 20 years. I don't use it a ton (probably only 18-20 times) but it looks brand new (which is incredible in itself given how the airlines handle baggage. I've used staff bags as well as stand bags and never had issues with any clubs being broken. That being said, I use a Stiff Arm and plenty of golf towels/beach towels along with shoes to help cushion any hard impacts. Honestly, the way this bag is designed, I couldn't ever go back to the days of the hard shell case. I hope I didn't just jinx myself.....




    Thanks for the input. I’m thinking of doing a similar set up.
    TM M3 460 9.5* Fujikura Pro73
    TM '16 M2 3HL Fujikura Pro73
    TM P790 UDI 17* PX HZRDUS Black 85
    TM P790 4-9 DG 105
    TM P770 PW KBS FLT 
    TM Milled Grind 50/54 KBS 610
    TM Spider Tour Black
    TM TP5x
  • cristphotocristphoto Members Posts: 3,351 ✭✭
    I have the Club Glove Last Bag along with the Stiff Arm. Its only about three years old but I've used it several times with no mishaps. I always stuff a couple towels in the clubhead area just for added protection. Works great and looking at the way its built its properly named - should last a lifetime.
  • kejoal11kejoal11 IYAOYAS!!! Yokosuka, JapanMembers Posts: 1,118 ✭✭
    I have traveled quite a bit this year and am using the sun mountain tour glider bag with a stiff arm. Very easy to transport and have had no issues with it the only regret I have is getting it in white.



    https://shop.sunmountain.com/clubglider-tour-series-17735-detail.html
    In My Bag
    PING G400 Max 9* PX Hazardous T1100 6.5 75g
    TM SLDR TP 3W Fujikura Motore Speeder TSX 8.3
    TM SLDR TP 2H Matrix Black Tie 95HX
    TM P790 3-PW Modus 120X
    Vokey SM6 58*, 50*
    Evnroll ER5
    Snell MTB Black/MTB-X
    #insideTMAG 2013
  • MCGolfTMMCGolfTM Members Posts: 586 ✭✭
    I usually only travel twice a year so I am thinking of going with the soft case and stiff arm over the hard travel case. I have traveled in the past with a soft case that had insertable plastic panels to make it a hard case with no stiff arm and it made it to and from Hawaii. You could tell it was dropped on the head tho cause the panels all shifted. The other time I traveled with clubs we had shipped them down in a box but couldn't get them shipped back easily so we ended up putting on the plane and just tapped the clubs together so they didn't slide out. Was a stressful flight home hoping that just he clubs in a stand bag made it ok, but all was good.
    TM M3 460 9.5* Fujikura Pro73
    TM '16 M2 3HL Fujikura Pro73
    TM P790 UDI 17* PX HZRDUS Black 85
    TM P790 4-9 DG 105
    TM P770 PW KBS FLT 
    TM Milled Grind 50/54 KBS 610
    TM Spider Tour Black
    TM TP5x
  • oldsticksnewsticksoldsticksnewsticks Members Posts: 120
    Another Club Glove Last Bag and Stiff Arm user here. Bunches of trips over the years and no damage to clubs or the case itself. I honestly can't see anything other than a freak accident damaging my clubs once packaged. I don't use any towels. Just headcovers on the woods as usual and cinching the straps tight around the bag. I also like being able to store 1 or 2 pairs of shoes in it (there are two shoe pockets that each hold a pair).
  • EagleCityEagleCity Members Posts: 185 ✭✭
    edited Nov 14, 2017 #18
    Soft. Go with Club Glove or Sun Mountain.



    Me- I use a Club Glove Burst Proof with a Stiff Arm and plenty of towels for padding, etc...
  • xjohnxxjohnx Members Posts: 2,005 ✭✭
    edited Nov 16, 2017 #19
    One very important thing that most never mention and I worry that most don't even know. All of the major airlines will cover damage caused to your golf clubs ONLY if they were in a hard travel case. So if you don't like to take chances and don't want to be on the hook, this is your only good option. As stated, many people have good luck with clubs packed correctly in soft cases but, we've also all heard and seen the horror stories from members and even tour players about broken clubs. So if you want an service from the airlines other than an "oops, sorry" you should consider the hard case for this reason.



    But, since we should mention the cons along with the pros, like others have eluded to already, these cased are an incredible pain the butt to travel with. They don't collapse and are too big for most rental car trunks. So you need to evaluate your travel arrangement and who you're with. If you're traveling with golf buddies, you'll likely need more than one car to get you and your clubs to the hotel/course. Or if you're bringing your clubs on a family trip, make sure your wife and kids are prepared for riding with your clubs on their laps in the back seat on the way to the hotel. If you are traveling alone for business and want to sneak in a round or two, you should be ok.
  • Lou04380Lou04380 Members Posts: 157 ✭✭
    edited Nov 16, 2017 #20
    I have both a club glove last bag and skb hard case, I mainly use the club glove with the stiff arm because the hard case can be a pain with rental cars. I haven't had any damaged clubs from using the soft case, but I did have my clubs dumped out by TSA and thrown back in, they dinged up my new irons in the process. I have a friend who had his driver shaft snap in a hard case on the way to a tournament, so it can happen in either.
  • SocratesSocrates How can it be so *&#% hard to make a shoulder turn? WinnipegClubWRX Posts: 9,319 ClubWRX
    Club Glove user. In over 50 flights to all sorts of destinations, not a single problem. Sure the bag shows some battle scars, but no damage to anything inside. One thing about hard-sided cases is that they are inflexible. Over the years I've stuffed dirty clothes, shoes, sandals, snorkel gear, fins, large woven rugs, all manner of destination trinkets (someone stop my wife - please) and a full set of golf clubs too. And most of the time it folds up and slides under the hotel bed once we've gotten there.
    Ping G400 9º TFC 419 Stiff at 45"
    Cobra F8 5-6 Fwy at 18.5° Stiff
    Ping i20 3 Hyb 707H Stiff
    X2 Hot 4_-PW Recoil 660 F3 +1/2"
    Ping Forged 52°, ES 56º and ES 60º
    Ping Sigma2 Valor at 34.5"
    MCC Align Midsize
    Moving to the bench:
    Jazz Bear Cat 3 wd Aerotech Stiff
    Vokey SM2 52º cc
    Scotty X7M Dual 38"
  • VNutzVNutz Members Posts: 6,179 ✭✭
    Hard case. I've only flown a handful of times with it over the past 10 years, but I like the peace of mind it gives me knowing everything is safe and secure. If I flew my clubs more frequently I'd likely consider a soft case simply for the easy of use. My case is big, but fortunately it breaks down into 3 pieces that can be stored inside itself for easier use with a rental car.
  • jmckjmck Members Posts: 4,277 ✭✭
    Another hard case vote. Also, FWIW, last time I flew with clubs the boarding agent made me take out all the towels I had stuffed in there. She said TSA wanted the bag and clubs only, nothing else besides the bag and clubs in the case. Who knows how accurate that is--it's totally up to the individual agent's discretion these days--but I was glad to have the hard case that day.
  • TheShaunTheShaun Members Posts: 1,136 ✭✭
    Another vote for the Club Glove Last and a Stiff Arm combo. Got a new Club Glove Last on the cheap from ebay.
  • jmudojmudo Members Posts: 93 ✭✭
    I have a bag boy with the swivel handle and use the stiff arm. Used it for Maybe 10 trips and have no complaints. I prefer the soft side cases because the hard cases don't fit in a lot of trunks.
  • SilverBulletsSilverBullets BMW Members Posts: 5,899 ✭✭
    I have a soft travel bag and it has worked great for me. I fly with my clubs 5 or so times a year. I have a callaway travel bag and it has held up great. The bag is padded really well. What I like about this bag over another one I owned is that it's much slimmer than the other bag (it has about an inch of padding around the whole bag but the bag itself fits my small stand bag, a dozen or so balls and a pair of shoes.. and that's about it. So the clubs are really tightly packed in there and there isn't much slack in the material. The last bag I had was huge and my clubs were swimming in the bag. I didn't like that as I found the clubs moved around a lot more in it.



    I generally take 2-3 extra golf towels (I have players towels) and interweave them through the iron heads. On the slimmer bag, everything stays perfectly in place whereas with the bigger bag the towels would come unraveled as the clubs moved around more. My M2 3w is a glued head so I don't even bother with taking the club heads off now. No issues whatsoever.



    I have flown with clubs in a soft case probably 25 times... 20 round trips in the last 4 years when I started traveling more and haven't had a single issue.
    Taylormade M6 10.5* - HZRDUS Smoke Black 6.5
    Taylormade '16 M2 15*
    Titleist 816h 21*
    Callaway Apex 4i thru PW - Nippon Modus 125 Tour X
    Vokey SM6 50*, 54*, 58*
    Scotty Cameron Circa 62 No. 2 - Scotty Custom Shop
  • MCGolfTMMCGolfTM Members Posts: 586 ✭✭
    Based on all I read here I finally went and got a bag. Being the TaylorMade guy I am, I went and got one on eBay. Found a brand new TaylorMade Performance Travel Case. Few years old but this thing is great. Fits like a glove and I’m gonna get the stiff arm to go with it. Should be perfect after that!67dc28ce0a2cd1a678c04dfb68a03dce.jpg9f0b6a8c5eab0a2e8b1228df0fb8f9f3.jpg
    TM M3 460 9.5* Fujikura Pro73
    TM '16 M2 3HL Fujikura Pro73
    TM P790 UDI 17* PX HZRDUS Black 85
    TM P790 4-9 DG 105
    TM P770 PW KBS FLT 
    TM Milled Grind 50/54 KBS 610
    TM Spider Tour Black
    TM TP5x
  • bellsy13bellsy13 Members Posts: 90 ✭✭
    With those club glove travel bags, how much "other stuff" such as clothes can you fit in it? I've read there isn't much room and I'm wondering if I can take a carry-on and this for a 3 wk getaway back home to Ontario.
    M1 12* Speeder 757x3W R9 with Matrix Ozik HD8 Proto Tipped 1.5"
    3I 712u S3004H R9 Supermax with Matrix Ozik HD8
    Titleist 716CB 5-pw S200Cleveland 50/54/58 with Nippon WV115Scotty Cameron Newport 2.7
  • danmurphdanmurph Members Posts: 62
    Indifferent for me
  • Ty_WebbTy_Webb New YorkMembers Posts: 2,985 ✭✭
    I have both. The hard case is good for feeling like your clubs are protected. Getting it in a hire car is a serious challenge though. Back seat is the only thing that has ever worked for me. I got a soft cover because I travel with my family sometimes which means two car seats and a wife in the front seat. Hard case is impossible. I have never had an issue with damage with the soft cover. I got a sun mountain one with wheels on a lever that pops out from the base. It’s so easy to move around the airport I can push a trolley with the suitcases on it at the same time as moving around the golf clubs. I love it.
    Ping G400 LST 9° Diamana white 63x
    Ping G410 LST 3 wood Diamana Thump
    Taylor Made UDI 2 iron Diamana Tensei white 90TX
    Titleist 714CB 3, 4
    Titleist 714MB 5-PW
    Ping Glide 2.0 Stealth 52 and 56 WS
    Scotty Cameron Newport 2
  • grochol17grochol17 Members Posts: 1,284 ✭✭
    bellsy13 wrote:


    With those club glove travel bags, how much "other stuff" such as clothes can you fit in it? I've read there isn't much room and I'm wondering if I can take a carry-on and this for a 3 wk getaway back home to Ontario.




    I've got a hoofer with the club glove that is sized for that bag. You could probably fit a few days worth of clothes, but I doubt three weeks unless you do some creative packing.
    Ping G400 LST, 8.5*, HZRDUS Yellow 75 6.0
    Titleist 915 F, 14.25*, Speeder VC 8.2 Tour Spec X
    Mizuno MP H5, 1&3 iron, C Taper Lite X
    Mizuno MP 25, 4&5 iron, DG X100 SSx1
    Mizuno MP 5, 6-PW, DG X100 SSx1
    Titleist Vokey Spin Milled CC, 53* & 58* (DG S300)
    Piretti Potenza II Rev 2.0, 375g, 34"
    Srixon Z Star / Z Star XV 5
Sign In or Register to comment.