Ban Green-Reading Books?

clublenderclublender Sponsors Posts: 53
Bryson DeChambeau ran into some trouble recently using a compass on the course. Then Golfweek recently broke the story that beginning January 1, 2019, green-reading books may be outlawed on tour. What should pros be allowed to use to assist their game and what should be banned? Green-reading books? Pin-placement maps? Rangefinders? Carts? Compasses? What's integral to the game and what is just a tool, like a sand wedge, a golf bag and a caddy? Can a golfer use a computer to calculate the best path to sink a putt?
«13

Comments

  • Darth PutterDarth Putter Members Posts: 5,169 ✭✭
    edited Jul 26, 2018 #2
    You get a 150 yard bush that may or may not actually be 150 yards from the center of the green and that's it!
    swing is irrelevant, score is everything

    just say NO.... to practice swings
  • wcbjrwcbjr Members Posts: 2,810 ✭✭
    It'll be tough to execute that. Do they allow hand-written notes? What's to stop the players and caddies from hand-copying existing books?
  • sticknerstickner Members Posts: 378 ✭✭
    This is an idiotic decision to ban these books.



    What kind of **** idiots decide to do this?



    Idiots I tell ya, IDIOTS!
  • ThinkingPlusThinkingPlus South TexasClubWRX Posts: 1,659 ClubWRX
    Actually banning having the books on course during competition is interesting, but will not really impact things much. My guess is that most pros can memorize each green pretty well just studying the books ahead of time. Overlay the pin position and study away. The USGA and R&A will feel better though.
    Driver: Callaway GBB Epic 9° w/Project X HZRDUS T800 65 gm 6.0 flex
    3W: Callaway Rogue w/Project X Evenflow 5.5 Graphite R-flex
    Hybrids: Callaway Apex 3h, 4h w/MR Kuro Kage 80HY S-flex
    Irons: Maltby TS-1 5i-GW w/KBS Tour R-flex
    Sand Wedge: Titleist Vokey SM7 54/08 M Grind w/KBS Tour R-Flex
    Lob Wedge: Titleist Vokey SM6 58/04 L Grind w/TT Wedge Flex
    Putter: Scotty Cameron Futura X w/Super Stroke Claw 1.0
    Ball: Titleist AVX (wind) or ProV1X (tournaments) in yellow
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,801 ✭✭
    And yet winning scores just don't go down. But the USGA needs to find a solution to a problem that doesn't exist.
  • IVMIVM Members Posts: 454 ✭✭
    Just ban the books and make them read the greens like everyone did before them .
  • lookylookitzadamlookylookitzadam Members Posts: 486 ✭✭
    Let them have the book if they want for planning approach shots but once their ball is on the green that book goes away. Maybe it becomes a 1-stroke penalty if it is out while on the green or something.
  • clublenderclublender Sponsors Posts: 53
    wcbjr wrote:


    It'll be tough to execute that. Do they allow hand-written notes? What's to stop the players and caddies from hand-copying existing books?
    I guess that will change the caddy mantra from "show up, keep up and shut up," to "show up, keep up, shut up...and take a whole lot of notes."
  • clublenderclublender Sponsors Posts: 53
    stickner wrote:


    This is an idiotic decision to ban these books.



    What kind of **** idiots decide to do this?



    Idiots I tell ya, IDIOTS!
    Stickner, with your image from Tin Cup, just wondering if Roy McAvoy would ever, ever, ever use a green-reading book? Probably never even knew what one was.
  • cfunk11cfunk11 Members Posts: 265 ✭✭
    edited Jul 27, 2018 #12
    I a have been playing the same course for 8 years and I still don't know how to read the greens. These guys play a different course every week so I don't have an issue with them using the books. But it shouldn't take more than 30 seconds to get all the nesasary info to strike a putt.
  • wildcatdenwildcatden China Cat Sunflower Members Posts: 918 ✭✭
    The books get banned. Instead, each player must carry a reproduction of the idol that Greg Brady found on The Brady Bunch. Before each putt, they are allowed to pray to the idol in hopes that the putt goes in.
  • bigchucksrbigchucksr Members Posts: 313 ✭✭
    This is an interesting discussion, after watching the Open last week and seeing the profusion of both yardage books and green charts being used, a question came to mind--"what is the difference between these books and a gps system?"

    I'd much prefer a "natural" game where the golfer and caddie make the decisions based on what they know and see before them--tee to green--every shot, every putt.

    It would be interesting to see who then emerged from the pack as the "best reader" of the green or the "best reader" of the course as a whole--adding a new (once old) dimension to the professional game.

    I for one am a bit tired of the routine of a player and caddie intently studying some illustrated book before every shot/putt during the round.

    I say turn 'em loose and let's see who can conquer a golf course naturally without outside assistance.
  • A.PrinceyA.Princey Major Hacker Members Posts: 2,231 ✭✭
    edited Jul 28, 2018 #15
    Yes, ban them, they make mediocre putters look competent. There's something to be said about "knowing" green slopes and hidden breaks by memory that should endure like in days of old. A simple book with several arrows, created by the caddie should be admissible, but these topography maps with slope readings(per hole location) are certainly against the principles the game was founded upon.



    Can you imagine Faxon or Crenshaw having these at their disposal??? Or maybe, just maybe, they were better at reading greens in the first place!
    '16 M2 10.5*, Diamana Ltd. 70 S+ 43.5"
    Ping G SFT 16*, DIamana Ltd. 70 S+ 41.5"
    Ping Rapture 3i, AWT-R
    Ping G25 4-G, DG-R400
    Vokey 56(57*), 60(63*) DG-R400
    Byron DH89 Longneck 33" (or any of 10 4 other putters...)
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,801 ✭✭
    bigchucksr wrote:


    This is an interesting discussion, after watching the Open last week and seeing the profusion of both yardage books and green charts being used, a question came to mind--"what is the difference between these books and a gps system?"

    I'd much prefer a "natural" game where the golfer and caddie make the decisions based on what they know and see before them--tee to green--every shot, every putt.

    It would be interesting to see who then emerged from the pack as the "best reader" of the green or the "best reader" of the course as a whole--adding a new (once old) dimension to the professional game.

    I for one am a bit tired of the routine of a player and caddie intently studying some illustrated book before every shot/putt during the round.

    I say turn 'em loose and let's see who can conquer a golf course naturally without outside assistance.




    And ban caddies so they don't get any outside assistance?
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,801 ✭✭
    I don't know how many of you have actually used a green map. My experience is that they are of very little value. The ones I have tried to use don't tell you which way your putt breaks. They just show the contours and you have to estimate where your ball lies on those little maps and where the pin is located.
  • hell_is_chromehell_is_chrome Members Posts: 986 ✭✭
    IVM wrote:


    Just ban the books and make them read the greens like everyone did before them .




    Just ban the books and make them eyeball yardages like everyone did before the early 1960's.
  • new2g0lfnew2g0lf Members Posts: 3,435 ✭✭
    edited Jul 28, 2018 #19
    Another case of the R&A and USGA looking for problems where they don't exist, I guess they need to justify their existence and huge bank accounts somehow. It's really a joke, all this talk about distance and green books ruining the game and yet scoring is has been reduced just .004 strokes per year, .004, is this really the best use of their time?



    Seems they won't be happy until we're just playing hickory clubs and gutties again.
    Driver - Home Ping G410 + 9.5*   Away Ping G400 Max 10*
    Woods - XXIO 10 3W
    Hybrids - XXIO 10 3H, 4H, 5H
    Irons - Home - PXG Gen 2 0311P 5-SW   Away - Callaway Apex CF-19 5-SW
    Wedge - PXG 58* 
    Putter - Seemore Nashville mFGP2 SS Mallet Black
    Ball - KSig, TM TP5X, Snell MTB
  • Jc0Jc0 ChicagoMembers Posts: 1,900 ✭✭


    I don't know how many of you have actually used a green map. My experience is that they are of very little value. The ones I have tried to use don't tell you which way your putt breaks. They just show the contours and you have to estimate where your ball lies on those little maps and where the pin is located.




    The ones the pros have are far more detailed. They basically cover every square foot of the green and give slope value at each point.
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,801 ✭✭
    Jc0 wrote:



    I don't know how many of you have actually used a green map. My experience is that they are of very little value. The ones I have tried to use don't tell you which way your putt breaks. They just show the contours and you have to estimate where your ball lies on those little maps and where the pin is located.




    The ones the pros have are far more detailed. They basically cover every square foot of the green and give slope value at each point.




    You still have to guess where the pin and your ball are located.



    Anybody have a picture of the "Pro green books" mentioned above? I would like to see how different they are from these;



    https://progreenbook.com/
  • Night trainNight train Members Posts: 2,842 ✭✭
    Ban them..........they simply slow down play and these guys spend too much time the way it is. Reading a green is part of the talent it takes to play the game.
  • Jc0Jc0 ChicagoMembers Posts: 1,900 ✭✭

    Jc0 wrote:



    I don't know how many of you have actually used a green map. My experience is that they are of very little value. The ones I have tried to use don't tell you which way your putt breaks. They just show the contours and you have to estimate where your ball lies on those little maps and where the pin is located.




    The ones the pros have are far more detailed. They basically cover every square foot of the green and give slope value at each point.




    You still have to guess where the pin and your ball are located.



    Anybody have a picture of the "Pro green books" mentioned above? I would like to see how different they are from these;



    https://progreenbook.com/




    Go to the tour page to see how detailed the tour books are.



    https://www.greenbookusa.com/tour/tournament-green-books
  • bladehunterbladehunter Today was a good day... south carolinaMembers Posts: 27,156 ✭✭
    edited Jul 28, 2018 #24
    new2g0lf wrote:


    Another case of the R&A and USGA looking for problems where they don't exist, I guess they need to justify their existence and huge bank accounts somehow. It's really a joke, all this talk about distance and green books ruining the game and yet scoring is has been reduced just .004 strokes per year, .004, is this really the best use of their time?



    Seems they won't be happy until we're just playing hickory clubs and gutties again.




    Great point. How many in favor of throwing away green maps will also be in favor of a ball rollback and Driver head reduction ?



    Very curious to me how we pick and choose our rallies against tech.
    TM Tour M6 11.2 * KK Tini XTS 70X
    Ping G410 15.5* Graphite Design ADDI 8x
    Ping G410 21* ADDI 105x 
    Ping Blueprint  3-PW   Modus 130X 
    Ping Glide Forged   54 60 S400
    Cameron GSS 009 1.5 tungsten sole weights, sound slot


  • new2g0lfnew2g0lf Members Posts: 3,435 ✭✭

    new2g0lf wrote:


    Another case of the R&A and USGA looking for problems where they don't exist, I guess they need to justify their existence and huge bank accounts somehow. It's really a joke, all this talk about distance and green books ruining the game and yet scoring is has been reduced just .004 strokes per year, .004, is this really the best use of their time?



    Seems they won't be happy until we're just playing hickory clubs and gutties again.




    Great point. How many in favor of throwing away green maps will also be in favor of a ball rollback and Driver head reduction ?



    Very curious to me how we pick and choose our rallies against tech.




    I tried an app that provides similar data to the green books and it's didn't change the number of putts I had because you still have to pick the right line and hit it at the right speed for that days current green conditions. I get that golf is a game rich in tradition and that many people are afraid of technology but how about we prove technology is really having an impact on scoring (scoring is the only thing that matters) before we go an make any more rules changes.



    Just about every recent decision the USGA and R&A have made about equipment and the golf stroke have blown up in their face as both the anchored putting stroke rule and the wedge rule were complete jokes and a waste of everyones time and money.
    Driver - Home Ping G410 + 9.5*   Away Ping G400 Max 10*
    Woods - XXIO 10 3W
    Hybrids - XXIO 10 3H, 4H, 5H
    Irons - Home - PXG Gen 2 0311P 5-SW   Away - Callaway Apex CF-19 5-SW
    Wedge - PXG 58* 
    Putter - Seemore Nashville mFGP2 SS Mallet Black
    Ball - KSig, TM TP5X, Snell MTB
  • Edaw68Edaw68 Members Posts: 1,499 ✭✭
    I wouldn't worry about the books, rangefinders, whatever other devices they come up with. I'd just ruthlessly enforce a shot clock. If they haven't put their ball in motion in the allotted time because they took too long figuring out their green reading book or whatever other random fidgeting half these guys do, then add a stroke. No excuses. The pros would rapidly learn what is actually needed and what isn't.
  • Night trainNight train Members Posts: 2,842 ✭✭
    edited Jul 28, 2018 #27
    Reading a green is like judging the wind or trying to decide how much an upslope or downslope affects your yardage. It's part of the skill required to be good at the game. If the books didn't offer an advantage, no one would be using them.
  • Aaronwilson_95Aaronwilson_95 Members Posts: 865 ✭✭


    Reading a green is like judging the wind or trying to decide how much an upslope or downslope affects your yardage. It's part of the skill required to be good at the game. If the books didn't offer an advantage, no one would be using them.


    Just like they don’t use a laser during practice rounds with slope...
  • rawdograwdog Cleveland, OHMembers Posts: 3,023 ✭✭
    So what publicly-available information can be documented and referenced, and what can't?



    I'm trying to figure out where to draw the line. No one has helped me draw it.
    Cobra LTD Driver
    Aldila Rogue Black, 9.5* @44.5"
    In1Zone Single Length Fairway Woods

    Graffaloy ProLaunch Axis Blue @41.5" 5W = 19*
    Graffaloy ProLaunch Axis Blue @41.5" 7W = 23*
    Cobra F7 One Length Irons
    Nippon Modus 105 Stiff @ 36.5"
    6I = 24* 7I = 29* 8I = 34* 9I = 39* PW = 44* GW = 49* SW = 54* LW = 59*
    Odyssey #9 HT Metal X Milled @33.5"
    Maxfli SoftFli
  • rangersgoalierangersgoalie Members Posts: 1,822 ✭✭
    edited Jul 28, 2018 #30
    The tour Sherpa green books by mark long are incredible.



    When you learn to locate yourself on the green, the hole locations provided lately on tour give a very reliable read.



    Nothing is perfect, but especially on flattish greens or putts , the books are invaluable data.
    Post edited by Unknown User on
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,801 ✭✭
    Jc0 wrote:


    Jc0 wrote:



    I don't know how many of you have actually used a green map. My experience is that they are of very little value. The ones I have tried to use don't tell you which way your putt breaks. They just show the contours and you have to estimate where your ball lies on those little maps and where the pin is located.




    The ones the pros have are far more detailed. They basically cover every square foot of the green and give slope value at each point.




    You still have to guess where the pin and your ball are located.



    Anybody have a picture of the "Pro green books" mentioned above? I would like to see how different they are from these;



    https://progreenbook.com/




    Go to the tour page to see how detailed the tour books are.



    https://www.greenboo...ent-green-books




    That's the same site I posted. You still have to guess where the pin and ball are located.
Sign In or Register to comment.