Nicklaus golf courses (only if you like his work)

245

Comments

  • duffer987duffer987 Don't feed the Choo. Canadian in CaliforniaMembers Posts: 9,015 ✭✭
    edited Nov 5, 2018 #32
    • Diablo Grande - Legends (now closed)
    • Par 3 5th at Pebble Beach


    I'm sure some of his more well regarded resort stuff is neat (+ MV/Sebonack obviously), but I've largely been exposed to his company's paint-by-numbers outlet mall stuff.
    Post edited by Unknown User on
  • DoubleorQuitsDoubleorQuits Members Posts: 376 ✭✭
    Top 5



    MVGC

    May River

    Shoal Creek

    Sebonack

    Great Waters
  • Matt JMatt J Members Posts: 8,717 ✭✭
    duffer987 wrote:

    • Diablo Grande - Legends (now closed)
    • Par 3 5th at Pebble Beach


    I'm sure some of his more well regarded resort stuff is neat (+ MV/Sebonack obviously), but I've largely been exposed to his company's paint-by-numbers outlet mall stuff.




    I know this thread isn't about criticism, but I'm with Duf. I can appreciate some of his work but have 0 respect for his design firm. I remember reading an interview where he admits they were willing to mail it in if the budget was too small. Seems greedy and unethical to me.
  • Argonne69Argonne69 Members Posts: 20,348 ✭✭
    I don't think I've disliked any of Jack's courses that I've played, but at the same time I've never been totally blow away. 'Love his greens for the most part. I find his fairway bunkers to be rather penal, with many making it difficult to reach the green in regulation due to high faces. I've played:



    - Dismal River White

    - The Bull

    - PGA West (Nicklaus)

    - Harbor Shores

    - Hammock Beach (Ocean)

    - Dove Mountain

    - Harbour Town

    - Old Corkscrew

    - Coyote Springs

    - Grand Bear

    - Golf Club of Estrella

    - Grand Geneva (Highlands)

    - Bay Pointe (Nicklaus)

    - Turtle Point

    - Grand Cypress New

    - Grand Cypress

    - Reunion (Nicklaus)

    - Bear's Best
  • ceejay81ceejay81 Love that chicken from Popeyes! Washington, DCMembers Posts: 1,706 ✭✭
    Someone mentioned it before, but Potomac Shores in Northern VA is really good. They just switched over to Bermuda this summer.
    Hive Tour Titles: 2
  • az2auaz2au Members Posts: 1,795 ✭✭

    az2au wrote:


    Desert Mountain Outlaw is by far the best Nicklaus course I’ve played. Many of the others roadking lists are somewhere in the “next tier”. I agree with Raynorfan1 pretty much 100%. The only thing I would add is that Nicklaus often gets too much credit for “nice” or money courses. I also think that’s why he gets a lot of the pushback you see. Lots of sizzle without substance.




    Do they get dm outlaw firm & fast? That’s my issue with we ko pa saguaro. The design calls for links like shots but the grass is too soft


    Only when they don’t overseed. It looks more linksy than it plays most of the time but it is still very good.
  • me05501me05501 Members Posts: 412
    edited Nov 5, 2018 #38
    Years ago the state of TN made a deal with Nicklaus Design to create the Bear Trace courses in several state parks. They were clearly hoping to copy the success of the RTJ Golf Trail in Alabama. I suspect that the majority of the work was done by Jack's team. Maybe it was more important to have Jack's name on the courses than to have his hands on them.



    We have a course here, the Bear Trace at Harrison Bay. It's a scenic and enjoyable course with quite a lot of variety among the holes. The fairways are wide, but it is often a big advantage to favor one side or the other. It's probably the best public course in the area. Play can be somewhat slow there. I assume that many are playing it for the first time.



    I've also played the Bear Trace at Tim's Ford, which is similar in many ways. Rather remote, scenic, near the water but not often in view of it. It finishes on a short par three which is somewhat anticlimactic.



    When those two courses opened they featured shaggy fringes planted around the greens that were designed to prevent or deter a rolling approach. The story I heard was that the local construction firms cautioned against this because the fine-bladed grass the Nicklaus people specified was very likely to burn up, but the Nicklaus people insisted. I don't know whether this was something they considered a signature feature, or maybe if they'd given in on the desire for wider fairways but felt the need to protect the greens, or what.



    So the fringes went in, and as predicted, they died every summer. So you'd have green fairways and greens with these dead, shaggy brown fescue rings around them. For the first several seasons the supers did everything they could to survive those grasses. But players hated them, and eventually the decision was made to resod those areas with bermuda to match the fairways.



    Finally, there's the Bear Trace at Cumberland Mountain, which is about 75 minutes from here near Crossville, TN. It's quite different from the other two, definitely more difficult, with more forced carries and places you just really don't want your ball to find. I'd like to go back there now that I can manage my game a bit better, but my recollection from several rounds years back is that it is on the wrong side of "challenging" and into penal. There are at least three other courses near there I'd prefer to play ahead of that one.
    Post edited by Unknown User on
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,298 ✭✭
    az2au wrote:


    I should have mentioned Monte Rei. Awesome course and it doesn't seem like most other Nicklaus courses I've played (not a good or bad thing, just what I thought).




    Yes, I played it in May this year. Quite difficult and requires a lot of strategic thinking. Most tee shots need to be played to the side of the fairway that enables a good approach.
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,298 ✭✭
    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    Nicklaus courses are usually underwhelming to say the least, however, the newly renovated Ocean Course at Hammock Beach Resort is outstanding.




    Examples?
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,298 ✭✭

    az2au wrote:


    Desert Mountain Outlaw is by far the best Nicklaus course I've played. Many of the others roadking lists are somewhere in the "next tier". I agree with Raynorfan1 pretty much 100%. The only thing I would add is that Nicklaus often gets too much credit for "nice" or money courses. I also think that's why he gets a lot of the pushback you see. Lots of sizzle without substance.




    Do they get dm outlaw firm & fast? That's my issue with we ko pa saguaro. The design calls for links like shots but the grass is too soft




    All of the DM courses are firm and fast when I have played them. They post the Stimp by the first tee and it's usually 11.5.
  • augustgolfaugustgolf Golf with dignity Coastal NCMembers Posts: 3,898 ✭✭
    jmtbkr wrote:


    I've played these locally:



    Champions course at PGA

    Bear Lakes

    Ibis CC

    Loxahatchee Club




    If you get the chance, play Mayacoo Lakes. Built surrounding Breakers West.
    Pings from the beginning

    OGA member 1415
    or is it 1514...
    I don't remember exactly
  • raynorfan1raynorfan1 Members Posts: 3,538 ✭✭
    edited Nov 5, 2018 #43

    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    Nicklaus courses are usually underwhelming to say the least, however, the newly renovated Ocean Course at Hammock Beach Resort is outstanding.




    Examples?




    Both the Nicklaus designs in Massachusetts - at Pinehills and Ocean Edge - are pretty average. Better than the local muni's, but nothing that I'd go out of my way to play.



    In fairness, in both cases I think the firm delivered exactly what the client asked for / wanted, so in some ways it's difficult to fault them for building the right things for their clients. They're just not very good golf courses.
  • ceejay81ceejay81 Love that chicken from Popeyes! Washington, DCMembers Posts: 1,706 ✭✭
    Haven't been able to get on it yet, but Creighton Farms in VA is super nice from what I hear.
    Hive Tour Titles: 2
  • smashdnsmashdn Let's cut them trees down. Members Posts: 1,000 ✭✭
    me05501 wrote:


    ...state of TN...




    Reminds me that there was a Nicklaus Design course just down the road from me in White House, TN. It was a residential deal that was dreamed up during the latter half of the 1990's golf boom. It went so far as to have some of the holes grassed and grown in. I was working in Springfield, TN at the time the course was constructed and eventually the plan collapsed in the recession. Intrigue got the better of me and I took a stroll on the property one afternoon. What I found was a property with tons of containment mounding and almost bowling alley-esque fairways that were cut down into the hills and then the sides built and rolled up. Those few holes I walked were very bizarre. IIRC there was a tunnel cart path as well.



    https://eu.tennessean.com/story/news/local/robertson/2016/02/19/white-house-development-expands-golf-course-nixed/80614908/

    Routing map here > https://realnex.com/listings/125899/bear-creek-at-burrus-ridge
  • jwhite86jwhite86 ClubWRX Posts: 469 ClubWRX
    I've only played The Bull... but it's my favorite course in my regular rotation. I try to play it 7-10 times a year
    WITB
    Driver: TS3 9.5 - 757
    3 Wood: 915 F 16.5 - Blueboard
    5 Wood: 909 F2 18.5 - Blueboard
    Hybrids: 816 H1 21 & 25 - Blueboard
    Irons 6-PW: 765 - PX LZ
    Wedges: 54º, 60º PXG 0311 - KBS
    Putter: Newport Mil-Spec


    http://www.golfwrx.com/forums/topic/1651462-jwhite86-witb/
  • exgolfproexgolfpro Members Posts: 767 ✭✭
    I guess I've played 4. Ranked in order are...



    1) The Bull at Pinehurst Farms-in my top 10 off all the courses I've every played.

    2) Winghaven CC-fun course. Probably as difficult as The Bull. Has a tunnel cart path as part of the course is across a road.

    3) Dalhousie GC--good course, but a few forgettable holes. Conditioning is usually great.

    4) Stonewolf GC (Illinois)-Always been a weird course to me. Has several really good memorable holes and about 10 forgettable ones.
  • SMcGavin1SMcGavin1 Members Posts: 118 ✭✭

    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    Nicklaus courses are usually underwhelming to say the least, however, the newly renovated Ocean Course at Hammock Beach Resort is outstanding.




    Examples?




    Muirfield Village - Too many trees, too much rough, too many forgettable



    Glen Abbey - Boring, stale, not much thought went into it



    Reunion Resort - Boring again, way too much development around the course
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,298 ✭✭
    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    Nicklaus courses are usually underwhelming to say the least, however, the newly renovated Ocean Course at Hammock Beach Resort is outstanding.




    Examples?




    Muirfield Village - Too many trees, too much rough, too many forgettable



    Glen Abbey - Boring, stale, not much thought went into it



    Reunion Resort - Boring again, way too much development around the course




    Muirfield Village is one of the most spectacular courses in the world. But, everyone is entitled to their opinion.
  • raynorfan1raynorfan1 Members Posts: 3,538 ✭✭

    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    Nicklaus courses are usually underwhelming to say the least, however, the newly renovated Ocean Course at Hammock Beach Resort is outstanding.




    Examples?




    Muirfield Village - Too many trees, too much rough, too many forgettable



    Glen Abbey - Boring, stale, not much thought went into it



    Reunion Resort - Boring again, way too much development around the course




    Muirfield Village is one of the most spectacular courses in the world. But, everyone is entitled to their opinion.




    And yet it didn’t even make your original top ten!?!?
  • FairwayFredFairwayFred Sponsors Posts: 4,017 ✭✭
    raynorfan1 wrote:


    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    Nicklaus courses are usually underwhelming to say the least, however, the newly renovated Ocean Course at Hammock Beach Resort is outstanding.




    Examples?




    Muirfield Village - Too many trees, too much rough, too many forgettable



    Glen Abbey - Boring, stale, not much thought went into it



    Reunion Resort - Boring again, way too much development around the course




    Muirfield Village is one of the most spectacular courses in the world. But, everyone is entitled to their opinion.




    And yet it didn’t even make your original top ten!?!?




    I don't believe RK has played Muirfield Village (based on his posts) though not playing a course has never stopped him from having a strong opinion on it.
    FREE AGENT CLUB HO NO MO!
    Ari Techner
    National Custom Works nationalcustomworks.com
    [email protected]
    IG: @nationalcustom
    Twitter: @WorksNational
    (still a huge club HO)
  • raynorfan1raynorfan1 Members Posts: 3,538 ✭✭

    raynorfan1 wrote:



    Muirfield Village is one of the most spectacular courses in the world. But, everyone is entitled to their opinion.




    And yet it didn't even make your original top ten!?!?




    I don't believe RK has played Muirfield Village (based on his posts) though not playing a course has never stopped him from having a strong opinion on it.




    So, everybody is actually entitled to somebody else's opinion as well...
  • duffer987duffer987 Don't feed the Choo. Canadian in CaliforniaMembers Posts: 9,015 ✭✭
    I'm happy to believe MV could be a really enjoyable course, but I've never heard a parkland course running through a housing estate being called spectacular.



    Not spectacular:

  • raynorfan1raynorfan1 Members Posts: 3,538 ✭✭
    duffer987 wrote:


    I'm happy to believe MV could be a really enjoyable course, but I've never heard a parkland course running through a housing estate being called spectacular.



    Not spectacular:





    It's not a golf course without an adjacent caravan park!
  • duffer987duffer987 Don't feed the Choo. Canadian in CaliforniaMembers Posts: 9,015 ✭✭
    edited Nov 6, 2018 #55
    raynorfan1 wrote:

    duffer987 wrote:


    I'm happy to believe MV could be a really enjoyable course, but I've never heard a parkland course running through a housing estate being called spectacular.



    Not spectacular:





    It's not a golf course without an adjacent caravan park!


    LOL! Darn straight. No classic Irish links can consider itself a spectacular world top whatever course without a caravan park image/smile.png' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':)' />



    With the exception of Portmarnock and The Island (due to it's proximity to the city) I don't think any of Ireland's top links are missing one.
  • SMcGavin1SMcGavin1 Members Posts: 118 ✭✭

    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    Nicklaus courses are usually underwhelming to say the least, however, the newly renovated Ocean Course at Hammock Beach Resort is outstanding.




    Examples?




    Muirfield Village - Too many trees, too much rough, too many forgettable



    Glen Abbey - Boring, stale, not much thought went into it



    Reunion Resort - Boring again, way too much development around the course




    Muirfield Village is one of the most spectacular courses in the world. But, everyone is entitled to their opinion.




    Not even close. It is overrated where it is. If not for Nicklaus's name and the Memorial being there, it wouldn't crack the top 100. 4, 6, 8 all boring. Not to even mention how hard of a walk it is. I will say that the conditioning is superb and I enjoyed the par 5's. Just not a course I would go out of my way to play again.
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,298 ✭✭
    raynorfan1 wrote:


    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    SMcGavin1 wrote:


    Nicklaus courses are usually underwhelming to say the least, however, the newly renovated Ocean Course at Hammock Beach Resort is outstanding.




    Examples?




    Muirfield Village - Too many trees, too much rough, too many forgettable



    Glen Abbey - Boring, stale, not much thought went into it



    Reunion Resort - Boring again, way too much development around the course




    Muirfield Village is one of the most spectacular courses in the world. But, everyone is entitled to their opinion.




    And yet it didn't even make your original top ten!?!?




    Because I haven't played it. My top ten are courses I have played.



    Muirfield looks spectacular on TV and most people rate it very high. Golf Digest has it #15 in the USA. You don't need to play it to appreciate it.
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,298 ✭✭


    I don't believe RK has played Muirfield Village (based on his posts) though not playing a course has never stopped him from having a strong opinion on it.




    This is true. I've never played Pine Valley either but have seen enough to agree it's a very special place.



    Sorry if you can't form an opinion of a course without playing it. Most of us can.



    I knew the Taj Mahal was spectacular before I went to see it.



    This isn't a strange concept. Lots can be learned from pictures, videos and reading other people's observations.
  • TinkerGolfManTinkerGolfMan Tinker Golf Man Members Posts: 1,214 ✭✭
    Only one i've played is Angeles National, but I would love to play more.
    TaylorMade 2019 M1 9°, Aldila Rogue 110, Golf Pride MCC Plus 4 Align Midsize
    Bomb Tech 3 Wood Fairway 15°, Oban Devotion, Golf Pride MCC Plus 4
    Nike Golf Vapor Speed 5 Wood Fairway 19°, Fujikura 73 Tour Spec, Golf Pride MCC Plus 4
    Mizuno JPX 919/ 4-6 Forged Irons /7-PW Tour Irons, KBS C-Taper, Golf Pride MCC Plus 4
    Artisan Golf ★ custom 50°, 54°, 58°, Nippon Modus 120 Wedge, Golf Pride MCC Plus 4
    Titleist Scotty Cameron 2016 Select Newport 2, SC Custom Shop work: Black Refinish, High-Buff shaft band, Yellow School Bus SC Matador, Face/Weight Stamps.
  • Roadking2003Roadking2003 AustinMembers Posts: 5,298 ✭✭
    duffer987 wrote:


    I'm happy to believe MV could be a really enjoyable course, but I've never heard a parkland course running through a housing estate being called spectacular.




    Like Pebble Beach?



    Spectacular is in the eye of the beholder.
  • FairwayFredFairwayFred Sponsors Posts: 4,017 ✭✭
    edited Nov 7, 2018 #61



    I don't believe RK has played Muirfield Village (based on his posts) though not playing a course has never stopped him from having a strong opinion on it.




    This is true. I've never played Pine Valley either but have seen enough to agree it's a very special place.



    Sorry if you can't form an opinion of a course without playing it. Most of us can.



    I knew the Taj Mahal was spectacular before I went to see it.



    This isn't a strange concept. Lots can be learned from pictures, videos and reading other people's observations.




    Sorry your just kidding yourself if you think you can have an informed opinion about a golf course that you have never seen. You can have an opinion, it just doesn't really count for much until you have actually seen the course. There's so much that is missed in pics and on TV (there's so much subtlety to a great golf course none of which can be seen without actually being on the grounds) but I'm sure you know that if we're truly being honest.



    duffer987 wrote:


    I'm happy to believe MV could be a really enjoyable course, but I've never heard a parkland course running through a housing estate being called spectacular.




    Like Pebble Beach?



    Spectacular is in the eye of the beholder.




    It sure helps when that beholders eye has actually seen the course they are talking about.
    Post edited by Unknown User on
    FREE AGENT CLUB HO NO MO!
    Ari Techner
    National Custom Works nationalcustomworks.com
    [email protected]
    IG: @nationalcustom
    Twitter: @WorksNational
    (still a huge club HO)
Sign In or Register to comment.