College coaches recruiting international vs US players

2»

Comments

  • Pinewood GolferPinewood Golfer Members Posts: 129 ✭✭
    CTgolf wrote:


    CTgolf wrote:




    LOL!!!!!



    Fencing is the sport? How many high schools in the states have fencing? I would say that fencing is more of a North Eastern US club sport than anything else. There are only 46 Colleges in the entire country that offer Fencing. 4.5 scholarships for an 18 person roster for men's D1. USA doesn't even place in Fencing in the Olympics do they? Seriously, it ranks up there with Curling.




    Yup, considered a "niche" sport...just like golf. Swimming/diving, volleyball and squash too - heard higher and higher % of international recruits.



    Very low number of participants (denominator) in many of those, and more scholarship/roster spots (numerator). In terms of getting a kid into school or scholarship $ those are where it's at. Golf...not so much.




    Golf isn’t a niche sport. People actually play it.




    It’s an afterthought for 98% of high school athletes, and one of the sports kids can “participate” in when they can’t make other teams as it doesn’t require specific physical attributes like size, speed or strength



    It is “niche” to the general public not reading this forum and website




    You can find gambling odds on PGA golf at any sports book. You can’t for swimming, fencing or whatever else y’all were talking about. Golf doesn’t have the reach of the big 3 but it’s far from niche
  • heavy_hitterheavy_hitter Members Posts: 3,066 ✭✭
    CTgolf wrote:

    CTgolf wrote:




    LOL!!!!!



    Fencing is the sport? How many high schools in the states have fencing? I would say that fencing is more of a North Eastern US club sport than anything else. There are only 46 Colleges in the entire country that offer Fencing. 4.5 scholarships for an 18 person roster for men's D1. USA doesn't even place in Fencing in the Olympics do they? Seriously, it ranks up there with Curling.




    Yup, considered a "niche" sport...just like golf. Swimming/diving, volleyball and squash too - heard higher and higher % of international recruits.



    Very low number of participants (denominator) in many of those, and more scholarship/roster spots (numerator). In terms of getting a kid into school or scholarship $ those are where it's at. Golf...not so much.




    Golf isn’t a niche sport. People actually play it.




    It’s an afterthought for 98% of high school athletes, and one of the sports kids can “participate” in when they can’t make other teams as it doesn’t require specific physical attributes like size, speed or strength



    It is “niche” to the general public not reading this forum and website




    There are 19,000 athletes playing golf collegiately. There are 1400 athletes fencing collegiately. I wouldn’t consider 19,000 athletes a “niche” sport.
  • golowgolow I Gots Issues Members Posts: 897 ✭✭
    edited Jan 18, 2019 8:35pm #34
    UTC.



    Current roster looks similar, only 4 from the states.

    Leon Bader R-Fr. Starnberg, Germany / Starnberg Secondary Etienne Brault Sr. Mercier, Quebec / Chateauguay Alex Cobb Fr. Brentwood, Tenn. / Brentwood Academy Lake Johnson Sr. Chattanooga, Tenn. / Chattanooga Christian Dominic Jones R-Fr. Espoo, Finland / Mlinne Senior Moritz Lammel Fr. Ismaning, Germany / Werner-Heisenberg A.J. Lintunen So. Espoo, Finland / Baylor Connor Nolan So. Corona, Calif. / Centennial Will Porter Jr. Arbroath, Scotland / Glenalmond Oliver Simonsen R-So. Ooltewah, Tenn. / Baylor




    UTC's two best players are American and they are currently ranked 116 (Sagarin). Just a quick glance.



    Take home message .... buy American !!



    image/victory.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':victory:' />
  • AUSweeperAUSweeper Members Posts: 35 ✭✭
    golow wrote:

    UTC.



    Current roster looks similar, only 4 from the states.

    [url="https://gomocs.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=6435&path=mglf"]Leon Bader[/url] R-Fr. Starnberg, Germany / Starnberg Secondary [url="https://gomocs.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=6436&path=mglf"]Etienne Brault[/url] Sr. Mercier, Quebec / Chateauguay [url="https://gomocs.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=6443&path=mglf"]Alex Cobb[/url] Fr. Brentwood, Tenn. / Brentwood Academy [url="https://gomocs.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=6437&path=mglf"]Lake Johnson[/url] Sr. Chattanooga, Tenn. / Chattanooga Christian [url="https://gomocs.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=6438&path=mglf"]Dominic Jones[/url] R-Fr. Espoo, Finland / Mlinne Senior [url="https://gomocs.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=6444&path=mglf"]Moritz Lammel[/url] Fr. Ismaning, Germany / Werner-Heisenberg [url="https://gomocs.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=6439&path=mglf"]A.J. Lintunen[/url] So. Espoo, Finland / Baylor [url="https://gomocs.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=6440&path=mglf"]Connor Nolan[/url] So. Corona, Calif. / Centennial [url="https://gomocs.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=6441&path=mglf"]Will Porter[/url] Jr. Arbroath, Scotland / Glenalmond [url="https://gomocs.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=6442&path=mglf"]Oliver Simonsen[/url] R-So. Ooltewah, Tenn. / Baylor




    UTC's two best players are American and they are currently ranked 116 (Sagarin). Just a quick glance.



    Take home message .... buy American !!



    image/victory.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':victory:' />




    UTC gets a break with the Baylor School being in town. Maybe best HS program in the nation. Brings in some international students themselves.
  • CTgolfCTgolf Members Posts: 420 ✭✭

    CTgolf wrote:

    CTgolf wrote:




    LOL!!!!!



    Fencing is the sport? How many high schools in the states have fencing? I would say that fencing is more of a North Eastern US club sport than anything else. There are only 46 Colleges in the entire country that offer Fencing. 4.5 scholarships for an 18 person roster for men's D1. USA doesn't even place in Fencing in the Olympics do they? Seriously, it ranks up there with Curling.




    Yup, considered a "niche" sport...just like golf. Swimming/diving, volleyball and squash too - heard higher and higher % of international recruits.



    Very low number of participants (denominator) in many of those, and more scholarship/roster spots (numerator). In terms of getting a kid into school or scholarship $ those are where it's at. Golf...not so much.




    Golf isn’t a niche sport. People actually play it.




    It’s an afterthought for 98% of high school athletes, and one of the sports kids can “participate” in when they can’t make other teams as it doesn’t require specific physical attributes like size, speed or strength



    It is “niche” to the general public not reading this forum and website




    There are 19,000 athletes playing golf collegiately. There are 1400 athletes fencing collegiately. I wouldn’t consider 19,000 athletes a “niche” sport.




    There aren’t 19k golfers as you stated.



    http://www.scholarshipstats.com/varsityodds.html



    Also, no one is saying fencing isn’t niche - just that golf is. When you half the number of collegiate golfers as you do volleyball players, swimmers, lacrosse players and cross country runners that is niche by any REASONABLE person’s standard.
  • heavy_hitterheavy_hitter Members Posts: 3,066 ✭✭
    edited Jan 19, 2019 12:54pm #37
    CTgolf wrote:






    There aren’t 19k golfers as you stated.



    http://www.scholarshipstats.com/varsityodds.html



    Also, no one is saying fencing isn’t niche - just that golf is. When you half the number of collegiate golfers as you do volleyball players, swimmers, lacrosse players and cross country runners that is niche by any REASONABLE person’s standard.




    Hey Genius.... you left out the women!!!



    [URL] http://www.scholarshipstats.com/golf.htm [/URL]





    Your statement is opinion. Golf is not a niche sport.





    Fencing

    Rowing

    Gymnastics

    Hockey

    Rifle

    Skiing

    Triathlon

    Water Polo

    Wrestling

    Bowling

    Triathlon



    Are all niche sports.
  • alfridayalfriday Members Posts: 471 ✭✭

    CTgolf wrote:


    There aren’t 19k golfers as you stated.



    http://www.scholarsh...arsityodds.html



    Also, no one is saying fencing isn’t niche - just that golf is. When you half the number of collegiate golfers as you do volleyball players, swimmers, lacrosse players and cross country runners that is niche by any REASONABLE person’s standard.




    Hey Genius.... you left out the women!!!



    http://www.scholarshipstats.com/golf.htm





    Your statement is opinion. Golf is not a niche sport.





    Fencing

    Rowing

    Gymnastics

    Hockey

    Rifle

    Skiing

    Triathlon

    Water Polo

    Wrestling

    Bowling

    Triathlon



    Are all niche sports.






    Oh, the irony.
  • heavy_hitterheavy_hitter Members Posts: 3,066 ✭✭
    edited Jan 21, 2019 9:24am #39
    alfriday wrote:

    CTgolf wrote:


    There arenâ€â„¢t 19k golfers as you stated.



    http://www.scholarsh...arsityodds.html



    Also, no one is saying fencing isnâ€â„¢t niche - just that golf is. When you half the number of collegiate golfers as you do volleyball players, swimmers, lacrosse players and cross country runners that is niche by any REASONABLE personâ€â„¢s standard.




    Hey Genius.... you left out the women!!!



    http://www.scholarsh...ts.com/golf.htm





    Your statement is opinion. Golf is not a niche sport.





    Fencing

    Rowing

    Gymnastics

    Hockey

    Rifle

    Skiing

    Triathlon

    Water Polo

    Wrestling

    Bowling

    Triathlon



    Are all niche sports.






    Oh, the irony.




    You are correct.



    Golf is mainstream and played on TV every day of the week. Tell me how that makes it a niche sport.
    Post edited by Unknown User on
  • GolfSRQGolfSRQ Members Posts: 45 ✭✭

    alfriday wrote:

    CTgolf wrote:


    There aren’t 19k golfers as you stated.



    [url="http://www.scholarshipstats.com/varsityodds.html"]http://www.scholarsh...arsityodds.html[/url]



    Also, no one is saying fencing isn’t niche - just that golf is. When you half the number of collegiate golfers as you do volleyball players, swimmers, lacrosse players and cross country runners that is niche by any REASONABLE person’s standard.




    Hey Genius.... you left out the women!!!



    [url="http://www.scholarshipstats.com/golf.htm"]http://www.scholarshipstats.com/golf.htm[/url]





    Your statement is opinion. Golf is not a niche sport.





    Fencing

    Rowing

    Gymnastics

    Hockey

    Rifle

    Skiing

    Triathlon

    Water Polo

    Wrestling

    Bowling

    Triathlon



    Are all niche sports.






    Oh, the irony.




    You are correct.



    Golf is mainstream and played on TV every day of the week. Tell how that makes it a “niche” sport.




    Hockey is not a niche sport
  • Pinewood GolferPinewood Golfer Members Posts: 129 ✭✭




    If a sport has its own station it’s not niche. Baseball, football, basketball, hockey, golf, soccer and tennis.



    I consider this argument resolved.
  • CTgolfCTgolf Members Posts: 420 ✭✭

    CTgolf wrote:






    There aren’t 19k golfers as you stated.



    http://www.scholarshipstats.com/varsityodds.html



    Also, no one is saying fencing isn’t niche - just that golf is. When you half the number of collegiate golfers as you do volleyball players, swimmers, lacrosse players and cross country runners that is niche by any REASONABLE person’s standard.




    Hey Genius.... you left out the women!!!



    [URL] http://www.scholarshipstats.com/golf.htm [/URL]





    Your statement is opinion. Golf is not a niche sport.





    Fencing

    Rowing

    Gymnastics

    Hockey

    Rifle

    Skiing

    Triathlon

    Water Polo

    Wrestling

    Bowling

    Triathlon



    Are all niche sports.




    10678 men + 5665 women = 16343



    You definitely add value to this forum, but you are probably the most overrated contributor considering how often you are wrong



    And I think TM was right - you definitely are a bully
  • Pinewood GolferPinewood Golfer Members Posts: 129 ✭✭
    CTgolf wrote:


    CTgolf wrote:






    There aren’t 19k golfers as you stated.



    http://www.scholarshipstats.com/varsityodds.html



    Also, no one is saying fencing isn’t niche - just that golf is. When you half the number of collegiate golfers as you do volleyball players, swimmers, lacrosse players and cross country runners that is niche by any REASONABLE person’s standard.




    Hey Genius.... you left out the women!!!



    [URL] http://www.scholarshipstats.com/golf.htm [/URL]





    Your statement is opinion. Golf is not a niche sport.





    Fencing

    Rowing

    Gymnastics

    Hockey

    Rifle

    Skiing

    Triathlon

    Water Polo

    Wrestling

    Bowling

    Triathlon



    Are all niche sports.




    10678 men + 5665 women = 16343



    You definitely add value to this forum, but you are probably the most overrated contributor considering how often you are wrong



    And I think TM was right - you definitely are a bully




    His specifics may be wrong but your opinion is very wrong. I settled this 2 posts ago. So stop.
  • heavy_hitterheavy_hitter Members Posts: 3,066 ✭✭
    edited Jan 19, 2019 9:24pm #44
    CTgolf wrote:

    CTgolf wrote:






    There arenâ€â„¢t 19k golfers as you stated.



    http://www.scholarshipstats.com/varsityodds.html



    Also, no one is saying fencing isnâ€â„¢t niche - just that golf is. When you half the number of collegiate golfers as you do volleyball players, swimmers, lacrosse players and cross country runners that is niche by any REASONABLE personâ€â„¢s standard.




    Hey Genius.... you left out the women!!!



    [URL] http://www.scholarshipstats.com/golf.htm [/URL]





    Your statement is opinion. Golf is not a niche sport.





    Fencing

    Rowing

    Gymnastics

    Hockey

    Rifle

    Skiing

    Triathlon

    Water Polo

    Wrestling

    Bowling

    Triathlon



    Are all niche sports.




    10678 men + 5665 women = 16343



    You definitely add value to this forum, but you are probably the most overrated contributor considering how often you are wrong



    And I think TM was right - you definitely are a bully




    Wrong???



    Last time I checked 12,199 men plus 7,132 women is 19,000+. Maybe I am missing something.



    Still trying to figure out how an opinion can be wrong.



    Bully??? øŸ˜‚ I say what I have to say. Whatever.



    Go skiing lately?
    Post edited by Unknown User on
  • heavy_hitterheavy_hitter Members Posts: 3,066 ✭✭
    CTgolf wrote:

    CTgolf wrote:






    There aren’t 19k golfers as you stated.



    http://www.scholarshipstats.com/varsityodds.html



    Also, no one is saying fencing isn’t niche - just that golf is. When you half the number of collegiate golfers as you do volleyball players, swimmers, lacrosse players and cross country runners that is niche by any REASONABLE person’s standard.




    Hey Genius.... you left out the women!!!



    [URL] http://www.scholarshipstats.com/golf.htm [/URL]





    Your statement is opinion. Golf is not a niche sport.





    Fencing

    Rowing

    Gymnastics

    Hockey

    Rifle

    Skiing

    Triathlon

    Water Polo

    Wrestling

    Bowling

    Triathlon



    Are all niche sports.




    10678 men + 5665 women = 16343



    You definitely add value to this forum, but you are probably the most overrated contributor considering how often you are wrong



    And I think TM was right - you definitely are a bully




    You are pulling your numbers from the wrong place. You are not including international students. So first you didn’t include women and now you aren’t including international students.
  • darter79darter79 Members Posts: 698 ✭✭
    CTgolf wrote:


    CTgolf wrote:


    There aren’t 19k golfers as you stated.



    http://www.scholarsh...arsityodds.html



    Also, no one is saying fencing isn’t niche - just that golf is. When you half the number of collegiate golfers as you do volleyball players, swimmers, lacrosse players and cross country runners that is niche by any REASONABLE person’s standard.




    Hey Genius.... you left out the women!!!



    http://www.scholarshipstats.com/golf.htm





    Your statement is opinion. Golf is not a niche sport.





    Fencing

    Rowing

    Gymnastics

    Hockey

    Rifle

    Skiing

    Triathlon

    Water Polo

    Wrestling

    Bowling

    Triathlon



    Are all niche sports.




    10678 men + 5665 women = 16343



    You definitely add value to this forum, but you are probably the most overrated contributor considering how often you are wrong



    And I think TM was right - you definitely are a bully




    Bully? Really. People don't even know the true meaning of a bully. You disagree with him and he a bully but yet you are only providing data that's one sided to your argument. Golf is a expensive sport but not a [background=rgb(247, 247, 247)]niche sport.[/background]
  • ncgolfer1234ncgolfer1234 Members Posts: 9 ✭✭
    Some schools recruit largely international players because they can het higher quality players that way. This has been true at schools in the eastern part of the country over the past 20 years. See Kent State, ETSU, UTC, Augusta State, and now James Madison. Not exactly schools American kids grow up dreaming of going to.



    Also, coaches do definitely have their biases that preclude them from recruiting certain types of kids. For example, I played at a high school that was well known for producing college players every year, dominating our state, multiple AJGA All-Americans. That being said, the flagship school in our state refused to recruit anybody from out school because the players who had played their had partied too hard and typically did not last long in the team. Meanwhile they would sign kids from the state who might have played 3 or 4 on our team.
  • RangerVRangerV My ProV’s are frozen Members Posts: 173 ✭✭
    Junior topics always get so heated and entertaining on here.
    TM M3 w/ Diamana Whiteboard 73X
    TM M2 Tour 3HL w/ Diamana Blueboard 83X
    Mizuno Mp FliHi Cut Muscle w/ GD Tour AD 95X
    Mizuno Mp59 w/ TI DG X100
    Titleist Vokey SM7 Brushed Steel 50/55/60 w/ TI DG S400
    Ping Vault 2.0 Stealth Anser
  • ChipNRunChipNRun Members Posts: 1,227 ✭✭
    The secondary sport for all college golfers is varsity time management.



    I am a college professor in the St. Louis area. My stops in academia include all four sports settings: NCAA D-1, D-2 and D-3, and NAIA.



    For golf, D-1 of course is the toughest; although better D-2 schools are quite respectable, scholarships for the most part are partial.



    NAIA schools tend to offer the smallest partial scholarships for golf, and D-3 schools by rules offer no-athletics specific scholarships: all D-3 students can apply for normal grant-in-aid and overall scholarships.



    Fall golf is largely small outings and team building while spring golf is the big time: heavy league play and big-name tournaments and, for the top schools, their divisional NCAA tournament.



    Golfers on the spring travel squad must coordinate carefully with their instructors to make up classes missed, and keep up with assignments. Sometimes the team will be gone for a week for some bigger tournaments. That is why the secondary sport for all collegiate golfers is time management.



    A cautionary tale: many D-3 or NAIA schools have players who started out in the big time. But, these often very good golfers crashed and burned academically because they wouldn't manage their life properly.
    What's In The Bag *...

    Driver: Calla XR16 Pro 10.5° (set open) / Fuji Evolution II TS Speeder 665 R-flex 63 gr.
    FWs: Tour Edge XRail 4W + 7W / GraphiteDesign G60 R-flex 60 gr.
    or Calla Alpha 815, set 16° + 20° / Fuji Motore Speeder 665 R-flex 62 gr.
    Hybrid: Cobra FlyZ 3H 19° + 4H 22° / Matrix VLCT Altus Lite flex 73 gr.
    Irons: Tour Edge CB Pro Tungsten 4i - PW** / KBS Tour 90 R-flex 101 gr. (As of 21 Nov 2018)
    Wedge: Calla MD3 48°/8.SS + 54°/12.WS +
    MD.PM 60°/10  | KBS Tour R-flex 110 gr. |
    Putter: Slotline Inertial SL-583F / 34" w. SuperStroke 2.0 MidSlim grip
    Bag: Sun Mountain Three 5 stand bag
    Ball: Calla SuperSoft
    * Either 7W or 3H left out, depending on course.
    ** Wedges: 46°and 48°are competing for bag space.
  • heavy_hitterheavy_hitter Members Posts: 3,066 ✭✭
    edited Jan 22, 2019 9:06am #50
    ChipNRun wrote:


    The secondary sport for all college golfers is varsity time management.



    I am a college professor in the St. Louis area. My stops in academia include all four sports settings: NCAA D-1, D-2 and D-3, and NAIA.



    For golf, D-1 of course is the toughest; although better D-2 schools are quite respectable, scholarships for the most part are partial.



    NAIA schools tend to offer the smallest partial scholarships for golf, and D-3 schools by rules offer no-athletics specific scholarships: all D-3 students can apply for normal grant-in-aid and overall scholarships.



    Fall golf is largely small outings and team building while spring golf is the big time: heavy league play and big-name tournaments and, for the top schools, their divisional NCAA tournament.



    Golfers on the spring travel squad must coordinate carefully with their instructors to make up classes missed, and keep up with assignments. Sometimes the team will be gone for a week for some bigger tournaments. That is why the secondary sport for all collegiate golfers is time management.



    A cautionary tale: many D-3 or NAIA schools have players who started out in the big time. But, these often very good golfers crashed and burned academically because they wouldn't manage their life properly.




    Yep. My daughter had class from 8-12 one day last week and was at Practice/workouts from 12:30 to 8:30. Walked in the door at 9. Went to bed at 9:30 and got up the next morning at 4:30 am to study.
    Post edited by Unknown User on
  • jjgsgolfjjgsgolf ClubWRX Posts: 166 ✭✭
    My coach in school always liked to go for the international players. He called them "raw" talent players, meaning that he could shape them better than he could the American kids. International kids were more eager to play well in some instances and perform better, because of this opportunity given to them.
  • SmpearSmpear Members Posts: 201 ✭✭
    While my son went through the recruiting process this year, I also noticed the large amount of international players on the division 2 teams we were looking at. I wonder how that even comes about, most d2 schools don’t have many funds for official visits much less flying a player from overseas. So if the recruit visits on his own dime, he must really want to play college golf in the US.



    I guess I answered my own question. Coaches know they are serious. Although as a coach I would worry about them getting homesick and baling after year 1.
  • tiger1873tiger1873 Members Posts: 1,043 ✭✭
    Been thinking about this some more and I think another big reason is a lot US kids don't stay 4 years. Some get homesick, want more playing time or just think the grass is greener somewhere else and transfer. The one is the better kids all decide that they can travel and turn pro and often do too soon.



    All of these things cause problems
  • heavy_hitterheavy_hitter Members Posts: 3,066 ✭✭
    tiger1873 wrote:
    Been thinking about this some more and I think another big reason is a lot US kids don't stay 4 years. Some get homesick, want more playing time or just think the grass is greener somewhere else and transfer. The one is the better kids all decide that they can travel and turn pro and often do too soon.



    All of these things cause problems




    This isn’t true at all.
  • wildcatdenwildcatden China Cat Sunflower Members Posts: 873 ✭✭
    tiger1873 wrote:


    Been thinking about this some more and I think another big reason is a lot US kids don't stay 4 years. Some get homesick, want more playing time or just think the grass is greener somewhere else and transfer. The one is the better kids all decide that they can travel and turn pro and often do too soon.



    All of these things cause problems




    This is for D1 schools. Looks pretty steady.



    http://www.ncaa.org/about/resources/research/transfer-rate-averages-and-trends
  • MalvernMalvern Members Posts: 431 ✭✭
    Smpear wrote:


    While my son went through the recruiting process this year, I also noticed the large amount of international players on the division 2 teams we were looking at. I wonder how that even comes about, most d2 schools don’t have many funds for official visits much less flying a player from overseas. So if the recruit visits on his own dime, he must really want to play college golf in the US.



    I guess I answered my own question. Coaches know they are serious. Although as a coach I would worry about them getting homesick and baling after year 1.




    Clubs sign soccer players from youtube videos, I'm not sure how many of the kids from my club actually set foot in the states prior to getting their scholarship and arriving at college.



    If you come from here (as well as Sth Africa and NZ), we travel, its likely that the person going to college has a sibling/friends working in Asia/London/Europe (it would be quite common that up to 50% of Australians have worked abroad at some stage) and even the US now the visa requirements have lessened. As a generalisation they aint getting homesick to the point of throwing in their opportunity.



    One of the boys was home for Xmas, he's in a college somewhere near Chicago (unsure which one), hates the weather given it never goes below 50F here. But he isn't quitting.
Sign In or Register to comment.