Graphite iron shaft recommendations (coming from x100s, golfers elbow)

 Jlopicco23 ·  
Jlopicco23Jlopicco23 New Jersey 350WRX Points: 61Members Posts: 350
Joined:  in WRX Club Techs #1

Have heard the MMT's are awesme and will give them a shot but was looking for maybe 1 or 2 other options to compare against. I don't know much about graphite shaft options but i want something that plays similar weight and stiffness to my x100s. Came from C tapers 130x before that and loved them but my elbows didnt. Swing it pretty fast with an aggressive tempo. Just looking for something to take some pressure off my joints.

What other options should i compare against?

Posted:
Ping G410 LST, 9.5 degrees, Tensei CK Pro Orange 70 TX
Taylormade p790 UDI 2 iron, KBS $-Taper
Mizuno MP 18 MB 4-PW, x100s
Mizuno T7 - 50, 56, 60
Artistan 0119 S
1

Comments

  • ChristopherMcDonaldChristopherMcDonald  2459WRX Points: 126Members Posts: 2,459
    Joined:  #2

    KBS TGI, Steelfiber, Recoil, Accra to name a few. Lots of great STIFF graphite out there these days!

    Posted:
    Cobra King LTD UST Elements Chrome
    Taylormade '07 Burner 3 Wood Miyazaki B.Asha
    Taylormade '07 Burner 5 Wood Miyazaki B.Asha
    Taylormade '07 Burner 7 Wood Matrix Ozik 6Q3
    Adams XTD Tour 5-GW True Temper Dynamic Gold AMT
    Scratch Tour Issue 1018 56* True Temper Dynamic Gold
    Scratch Tour Issue 1018 60* True Temper Dynamic Gold
    Odyssey White Hot Pro V-Line
    Taylormade Project (a)
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • chisagchisag Chicago Suburbs 3144WRX Points: 466Handicap: +0.3Members Posts: 3,144
    Joined:  #3

    ... I have played Recoil 95/110, Recoil 95 Prototypes, NV Tour 130/Pro 105, VS Proto 100s and Steelfiber 95's all in stiff flex. I have a smooth transition so I am the opposite of the OP. The Steelfiber S Flex were much too firm/stout for a smooth swing and I think they are ideal for an aggressive hitter. Ariya Jutanugarn is as aggressive as it gets and she plays Steelfiber in her irons. Fwiw, I just picked up some Steelfiber 95 in R flex to try in some new P790's as Aerotech recommended dropping a flex for a smooth swing. While all the graphite shafts I have played have a dampened feel that personally I like, they are unlike steel and take a little getting used to, the Steelfibers were much closer to steel in feel than all other graphite iron shafts I have played. I think that explains Steelfiber success on the PGA, LPGA and Champions Tour where players have hit thousands if not millions of shots with steel shafts and do not want a radically different feel.

    Posted:
    Cobra F9 Tour Length ... Tensei Orange 65s
    Cobra F9 15.5* ... Atmos Blue TS 75s
    Cobra F8 18.5* ... Even Flow Blue 75s
    TaylorMade GAPR Mid ... KBS 80Hys
    TaylorMade UDi 18* TP 2 iron... Kuro Kage Black 90Hys
    4-pw TaylorMade P790/760 ... Steelfiber 95's/Recoil Prototype 95's
    SM6 52* F Grind /SM7 D Grind 58* ... Recoil 110s
    Bobby Grace 6330 ... 33.5"
  • BirdieBobBirdieBob Member of the 400 yard Club!  4384WRX Points: 381Members Posts: 4,384
    Joined:  edited Jan 15, 2020 6:37pm #4

    Recoil Protos 125 or 110 F5....been there done it!

    Also try the AMT x100

    Posted:

    TITLEIST TS4 Driver, 9.5*, JDM Limited Edition 2016 Basileus AAA 60X.
    CALLAWAY Epic Flash SubZero TI, 14.6*, Diamana ZF, 70TX
    CALLAWAY Super Hybrid, 16*, Tensei Pro Orange HY 80X
    CALLAWAY Super Hybrid, 19*, Tensei Pro White HY 100TX
    TAYLORMADE P790 UDI, #2, 18*, Nippon Modus GOST Hybrid, 102X
    PXG 0311ST MILLED, 3 - PW, DG TI AMT x100 LE ONYX...Summer Set
    TAYLORMADE '19 P790, 4 - AW, DG AMT WHITE x100...Winter Set
    COMBO IRON SET, TM P790, 2, 4; PXG ST, 5 - PW
    PXG 0311T 54* MILLED Sugar Daddy Xtreme Dark Wedge, DG TI s400 ONYX
    PXG 0311T 60* MILLED Darkness Wedge, DG TI s400 ONYX
    SCOTTY Cameron Custom "Murdered Out" Select Newport M2 Putter, w/SC Black CircleT HC
    SUN MOUNTAIN `20 Tour Series Bag, Black
    STEWART Golf X9 FOLLOW Electric Cart, Black

  • SUPERGSUPERG  336WRX Points: 199Members Posts: 336
    Joined:  #5

    C taper guy myself but have been playing with a set of AMT white (srixon z forged) and have felt a ton of relief on some of those iron swings. Graphite for me is also a tad intimidating seeing as there are so many options, and not many suited to a stronger player.

    Posted:

    2020 WITB

    TM M5 10.5* - Diamana DF 70TX

    TM Jetspeed 17* - Tour Green 95TX

    TM 19' P790 UDI - Tensei PW 100TX

    Mizuno MP18 SC - C Taper 130X

    TM MG2 52* 56* MG Hi Toe 62*

    TM Vault Berwick

  • ephmenephmen  284WRX Points: 99Members Posts: 284
    Joined:  #6

    I have played and loved Recoil Protos, but switch to MRC OTI which are hands down better for me. Both are great shafts.

    Posted:
  • PreppySlapCutPreppySlapCut This is just babytown frolics...  6555WRX Points: 240Members Posts: 6,555
    Joined:  #7

    I find the Aldila RIP 115 to be the closest match to CTapers. The Accras are excellent, but they'll be a little lighter than what you're currently playing. MMTs will probably be your best bet.

    Posted:
    Ping G410+ 9* w/ Graphite Design Tour AD GP-6 (X)
    Ping G 14.5* & 19.5* w/ Tour 80 (X)
    Ping G30 22* w/ Accra Kuchar Proto 85 (X)
    Ping i210 5-PW w/ Aldila RIP 115 (S)
    Ping Glide 2.0 50*, 55*, 60* w/ Aldila RIP 115 (S)
    Scotty Cameron Toolbox
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • JoeFrigoJoeFrigo  265WRX Points: 123Handicap: 6.4Members Posts: 265
    Joined:  #8

    Steelfiber 125x or Recoil Prototype 125 f5..... Steelfiber will be lower launching and more similar to Ctaper's. I found the recoils to be a little loose for me with higher ball flight.

    Posted:

    Callaway Mavrik SZ 10.5* Ventus Black 60x....... TM M5 9* LA Golf Ozik Black Tie 60tx
    Callaway Super Hybrid 17* Tensei Pro Orange 80tx
    TM P790 UDI Tensei Pro Orange 90tx.... Callaways Epic Flash 20* Tensei Pro Orange 80tx
    Mizuno MP 20 MMC 4 - P Aerotech Steelfiber FC 115 F5
    Mizuno T20 52,56,60 Aerotech Steelfiber 110 F5
    Bettinardi 2019 Queen B#6

  • jt2gtjt2gt  658WRX Points: 151Members Posts: 658
    Joined:  edited Jan 15, 2020 7:23pm #9

    FYI...played both Recoil and Steelfiber last season for first time and my wrist, elbow and fingers never felt better. My knuckles would ache with overuse before, but never had an issue last season on graphite and played even more. I liked the Recoil a bit better, but I am not a high SS player. Steelfibers were good too but I had to really be on form and swinging great or would lose my irons right and short. In other words, steelfibers were distance and consistency winners on the driving range but Recoils won out on course.

    Posted:
  • ValtielValtiel Konica-Minolta Bizhub  2926WRX Points: 1,016Handicap: 1.7Members Posts: 2,926
    Joined:  #10

    The first thing I would zero in on is weight since that is usually the thing that trips people up when making the switch. Recoil 125, Steelfiber i125, and the MMT 125 if you can get it, that is where I would start personally.

    Posted:
    Mizuno ST190 9.5* Diamana X'17 70XX ||  Taylormade M1 430 8.5* Tensei Pro Orange V2 70TX
    Titleist 915FD 15* Aldila Rogue 125 MSI 80TX || Taylormade RSI UDI 16* Fujikura Motore Speeder HB 8.8 Tour-Spec X
    Titleist 915FD 18* Aldila Rogue 125 MSI 80TX || Srixon Z U65 Utility 18* Fujikura Motore Speeder HB 9.8 Tour-Spec X
    Callaway X-Forged UT 21* UST IS-990X Prototype || Srixon Z 585 21* Project X PXi 7.0
    Bridgestone J40 DPC 4i-5i Brunswick Precision Rifle FCM 7.0
    Bridgestone J40 CB 5i-PW 27*- 48* Brunswick Precision Rifle FCM 7.0
    Vokey Mild Raw 8620 54* Brunswick Precision Rifle FCM 7.0
    Vokey SM6 58* Oil Can Low Bounce K-Grind Brunswick Precision FCM 7.3 SSx1
    Vokey Special 62* Black Oxide V-Grind Brunswick Precision FCM 7.3 SSx2
    Scotty Cameron Santa Fe Bullseye shaft

    WITB Thread
  • ChristopherMcDonaldChristopherMcDonald  2459WRX Points: 126Members Posts: 2,459
    Joined:  #11

    Matrix Program 130's might fit the bill as well as far as the weight range goes (swingweighting is difficult due to balance point from what I've read though).

    Posted:
    Cobra King LTD UST Elements Chrome
    Taylormade '07 Burner 3 Wood Miyazaki B.Asha
    Taylormade '07 Burner 5 Wood Miyazaki B.Asha
    Taylormade '07 Burner 7 Wood Matrix Ozik 6Q3
    Adams XTD Tour 5-GW True Temper Dynamic Gold AMT
    Scratch Tour Issue 1018 56* True Temper Dynamic Gold
    Scratch Tour Issue 1018 60* True Temper Dynamic Gold
    Odyssey White Hot Pro V-Line
    Taylormade Project (a)
  • C6 SnowboarderC6 Snowboarder  26WRX Points: 28Handicap: 6.6Members Posts: 26
    Joined:  #12

    I love the Recoil 95s in my Mizuno MP-20MB my 2 cents worth of opinion.

    Posted:
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • jblack06jblack06  20WRX Points: 66Members Posts: 20
    Joined:  #13

    I currently play the Aldila Tour 115 Stiff graphite iron shafts in my Taylormade MCs. I like them quite a bit. They play stiff and launch low, seen play very similar to a x100.

    Posted:
  • 2Down2Down  218WRX Points: 102Handicap: 4.2Members Posts: 218
    Joined:  #14

    You might try some softer grips on the shaft you have.

    Posted:
    Ping G410+ tensi orange s
    Cobra F8+ 3-4 15°  Aldila NV 2KXV 75 Green w/Cobra smart grip
    Adams 9031 18° Mitsubishi diamana
    Adams 9031 23° Mitsubishi diamana 
    Mizuno MP5 5-W KBS tour 120 S
    Vokey sm7 50° 12° b
    Mizuno T7 54° 12°b
    Ping glide 2 58°. ES
    Ping anser f titanium pixel
    Pro V1

  • PepperturboPepperturbo Midwest and Southwest 16295WRX Points: 685Handicap: Low-Mid SDMembers Posts: 16,295
    Joined:  #15

    My swing is a tad different from others... I am a hitter of the ball with a faster than normal transition and tempo. I won't go into the all the shafts I tested before switching from PX 6.0. Just share the two best of the lot; MMT which is an outstanding shaft and my final choice Steelfiber i95cw "S" in 2iron, i110cw "S" in 3-6 620CBs, and i125cw "S" in 7-SW 620MBs...talk about a blended set. 😉 Mid-high bend, Low-mid trajectory benefits of graphite and low dispersion stiff tips of steel and no vibration. Yet, I can still tell at impact were the ball is going without looking up.

    It's a tough decision. Good luck.

    Posted:
    Titleist TS2 9.5, Project X HZRDUS Red 62 6.0
    Titleist TS2 16.5*, Project X HZRDUS Red 75 6.0
    Titleist 718 T-MB 17* 2 iron, Steelfiber i95cw "S"
    Titleist 620 CB/MB 3i-PW, Steelfiber i110cw & i125cw "S"
    SM6 F-52*, Steelfiber i125cw "S"
    SM6 M-58*, DG-S200
    SC California Monterey
    ProV1 or ProV1X




  • rxk9fanrxk9fan Midwest 885WRX Points: 215Handicap: 6.9Members Posts: 885
    Joined:  #16

    Graphite has saved my elbows!! I was close to giving golf up 18 months ago, getting shots in my elbows, and finding no relief. Graphite saved golf for me.

    IMO Steelfiber S flex will stand up to the strongest of swings. I have never loved the feel but their performance is stout with lower launch than any Recoil with my swing.

    The Recoil Proto's will launch and play stiffer IMO than the non-proto. I played them for 6 months.

    The everyday Recoil 110 F4 is my personal favorite. It fits a wide range of swings. My assistant pro and I got on Trackman a few weeks ago and he plays the Srixon Z945 shafted with Recoil 110 F4 shafts. His driver SS averaged 108 and his readings showed almost optimal results on all of his iron shots. He is 25 years old.

    I am 61 and play the Z785 shafted with the same Recoil 110 F4 shafts. My driver SS averaged 98.6. My iron readings were not as close to optimal but the fitter said he would be hard pressed to fit either of us in a different iron shaft.

    Good luck with your choice and your elbows!

    Posted:
    TaylorMade M6 driver with Tensei Orange
    Taylormade M4 tour 3 wood with Oban Kiyoshi Tour Limited stiff
    Taylormade M4 tour 5 wood with Tensei Blue stiff
    Taylormade M6 Rescue 19 degree with Atmos orange stiff
    Srixon z785 with Recoil 110 F4 shafts
    Vokey 50 F, 54 S, 58 K
    Odyssey O-Works 7s



  • ShallowbutDeadlyShallowbutDeadly  60WRX Points: 36Members Posts: 60
    Joined:  #17

    I have suffered major elbow issues this past year and I'm making the switch as well. My suggest is book a fitting, I have tried all the shafts listed above and the results were all over the map, steelfiber and accra the best so far so I'm going to for a full fitting next week.

    Posted:
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • RedWings1RedWings1 Dunham Hills,Moose Ridge,Huntmoore & Kensington GC's, Michigan 346WRX Points: 65Members Posts: 346
    Joined:  #18

    Any WRXers using KBS TGI or Fuji Pro graphite in their irons? I'm looking to make the switch for this year to save my elbows. Steelfiber seems to be the leader in golf. I'll be moving from DG Pro S300, Driver swing speed is a smooth 112-115 avg. 6I upper 90's. I'm not sure I really like the Recoil in my Srixon Zu85 20* 3i - seems kinda whip y if I get after it on a swing.

    Posted:

    TaylorMade M4, 9.5 - Fuji Pro TS 63s
    TaylorMade M1 4w, 17.5 - Fuji Pro TS 83s
    Srixon Zu85 3i - Recoil 95s
    Bridgestone J15cb 4-pw - DG Pro S300
    Honma TW -50,54,58 - NS Pro Modus3 125s
    09 Odyssey Black Series 1 (milled, Nickel Plated)
    TaylorMade Spider X
    Srixon Z Star XV Tour

  • Cruisin1966Cruisin1966 Calgary, AB 949WRX Points: 206Handicap: WIPClubWRX Posts: 949
    Joined:  #19

    Just received my Miura CB57's (4-PW) with the Fujikura Pro 115s shafts. Just a quick simulator league 9 hole outing, but so far so good. Elbow and wrist issues here as well. I need to hit the outdoor heated range this weekend for a full session before I'm prepared to give my thoughts.

    Posted:

    No more golf until Spring.

  • StonewalledStonewalled  1638WRX Points: 167Members Posts: 1,638
    Joined:  edited Jan 16, 2020 6:21am #20

    I have some Winn Dritac's on some Steelfiber i95 stiff's, pretty smooth combination. I have a set of irons with PX LZ 6.5's that I love the feel of but like other's I have body part issues. I will try putting on some mid sized Dritac's on the Px's before I switch out the shafts to graphite. My favourite at the moment are the Matrix Ozik Program F15 120's.

    Posted:
  • Stuart_GStuart_G New Hampshire 24419WRX Points: 1,225Members Posts: 24,419
    Joined:  edited Jan 16, 2020 11:35am #21


    Just don't let the name confuse anyone. The Program 130's were not 130 gms Only 121-125gm depending on the flex.


    But it's still a heck of a lot better than people trying to recommend 95 and 110 gm shafts for someone who specifically asked for shaft weight similar to a 130 gm shaft.

    Posted:
  • YuckYuck Fore!  2558WRX Points: 219Members Posts: 2,558
    Joined:  #22

    Steelfibers. If you can make the weight transition, the i95cw in the correct flex for you is not a “loose” shaft. Trajectory and spin very similar to dg. I went with the 125’s in the wedges, but the 95’s were ok in my other irons. Was an x100 player until about 10 years ago. More recently I was in PX 6.0. My joints have thanked me for making the change.

    Posted:
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • ChristopherMcDonaldChristopherMcDonald  2459WRX Points: 126Members Posts: 2,459
    Joined:  #23

    Great point Stuart, forgot those come in a little bit light.

    Posted:
    Cobra King LTD UST Elements Chrome
    Taylormade '07 Burner 3 Wood Miyazaki B.Asha
    Taylormade '07 Burner 5 Wood Miyazaki B.Asha
    Taylormade '07 Burner 7 Wood Matrix Ozik 6Q3
    Adams XTD Tour 5-GW True Temper Dynamic Gold AMT
    Scratch Tour Issue 1018 56* True Temper Dynamic Gold
    Scratch Tour Issue 1018 60* True Temper Dynamic Gold
    Odyssey White Hot Pro V-Line
    Taylormade Project (a)

Leave a Comment

Rich Text Editor. To edit a paragraph's style, hit tab to get to the paragraph menu. From there you will be able to pick one style. Nothing defaults to paragraph. An inline formatting menu will show up when you select text. Hit tab to get into that menu. Some elements, such as rich link embeds, images, loading indicators, and error messages may get inserted into the editor. You may navigate to these using the arrow keys inside of the editor and delete them with the delete or backspace key.