I really like my Cottonwood II. The wider flange in the CW2 suits my eye and the black onyx finish is great because it's a carbon steel putter but is basically maintenance-free. The feel is interesting. It's not buttery soft like a fit face Bettinardi and isn't even as soft as a 303 Cameron. However, it's got a very nice, pleasant click. I'm assuming that's because Pirettis have 2.5 degrees of loft rather than the standard 3 degrees. Aesthetically, it looks great. With some wear, the black starts to look a bit like a gunmetal finish. I've gamed lots of putter in the past few years but it'll be hard to knock the Piretti out of my bag.