Mostly sums up my findings as well. I ordered 3 dozen mint. I have quite a few players markings on mine, probably a dozen or more. Those don’t necessarily bother me and they are still in mint condition so nothing major for me. No noticeable scuffs dings or scratches on mine but Maybe a half dozen or so I’d say less than mint based on coloring etc. Will be good for practice/fun rounds but certainly not in the condition that lost golf balls had. Makes me wish I would have REALLY stocked up on those haha! I think the first 4-5 dozen I got for less than $25/dozen if I remember correctly, and they were new.