For reference, I'm 6'2" 230. I don't tuck my shirts in as I play with the more laid back crowd at not that nice courses.
Prices include shipping and are firm.
1) Vineyard Vines performance. XL. This fits true to size a little baggy for my untucked taste. Worn once. $30
2) Galvin Green XXL. NWT. This fits me well however it's a little too long for me untucked. It would be just fine tucked in. $40
3) J Lindberg. XL. Definitely not an XL this fits more like a slim fit L. I bought it perviously worn but never wore it because it doesnt fit me at all. No rips tear