Jump to content

Why swinging over the top is good and how is shallows the swing.


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 160
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

[quote name='lv_2_hack' timestamp='1423774288' post='10940623']
[quote name='Jonnybagadonuts' timestamp='1423772701' post='10940407']
[quote name='lv_2_hack' timestamp='1423772185' post='10940335']
Typically a really good fade pattern.
[/quote]

I was hitting some pretty powerful push draws with ease, almost automatic . I think it all stems from your original tip to me of the karate chop move.
[/quote]

Awesome mate. The karate chop move (iteach taught it to me) is great for people who are overly connected. Helps get lead arm off the chest coming down. For you, your backswing might have gotten a bit too deep, so the shift out helped get you back on plane.

Overall you are right, most of the WRX crowd hates seeing any downswing that's steeper than the backswing.
[/quote]
I do a karate chop move with my right forearm (feel, of course). Is this a feel of the whole left arm chopping down?

Wilson Staff Cortex 9.5*

Titleist 818 H1 17* down to 16*

Titleist 718 T-MB 3 iron

Titleist 718 AP2 4-GW

Titleist Vokey SM7 54* and 58*

Scotty Cameron Futura X

Titleist Pro V1X

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='parallax' timestamp='1423782834' post='10941653']
Can someone define "over the top"?

I thought it was the club head path in relation to the ball.
[/quote]
In this sense, it is that the plane of the downswing is above the plane of the backswing. So, the backswing plane is a little inside of the 'on plane/ideal' and then the downswing comes down 'on plane', slightly over the top of the backswing.

Wilson Staff Cortex 9.5*

Titleist 818 H1 17* down to 16*

Titleist 718 T-MB 3 iron

Titleist 718 AP2 4-GW

Titleist Vokey SM7 54* and 58*

Scotty Cameron Futura X

Titleist Pro V1X

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='iteachgolf' timestamp='1423781718' post='10941533']
Every swing I make is "OTT". As are most of my students
[/quote]

. . . but you do not cast; you do not get too steep; you do not early extend to shallow things out; and you do not swing out-to-in. Nor, I am certain, do any of your better students.

OTT pathology stems from the forearms and wrists. . . not the shoulders.

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='FatReed' timestamp='1423784168' post='10941783']
[quote name='iteachgolf' timestamp='1423781718' post='10941533']
Every swing I make is "OTT". As are most of my students
[/quote]

. . . but you do not cast; you do not get too steep; you do not early extend to shallow things out; and you do not swing out-to-in. Nor, I am certain, do any of your better students.

OTT pathology stems from the forearms and wrists. . . not the shoulders.
[/quote]

My arms work OTT of my backswing plane. As do most of my students. Those other things are completely separate.

Btw my "plane" is definitely left of my stance line as are all my divots

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='iteachgolf' timestamp='1423786345' post='10941985']
[quote name='FatReed' timestamp='1423784168' post='10941783']
[quote name='iteachgolf' timestamp='1423781718' post='10941533']
Every swing I make is "OTT". As are most of my students
[/quote]

. . . but you do not cast; you do not get too steep; you do not early extend to shallow things out; and you do not swing out-to-in. Nor, I am certain, do any of your better students.

OTT pathology stems from the forearms and wrists. . . not the shoulders.
[/quote]

My arms work OTT of my backswing plane. As do most of my students. Those other things are completely separate.

Btw my "plane" is definitely left of my stance line as are all my divots
[/quote]

I know Dan . . . I am just ribbing you a bit :-)

I know you have a stable of better players but, for what I suspect is the majority, I doubt that you tell them, "hey, we need to get you coming over the top."

Link to post
Share on other sites

Dan,

Actually, I find the “swinging left” part in you prior post to be interesting, as it pertains to your OTT comments. Probably would have been good for the swinging left thread. I certainly notice JC really gets left in the videos you referenced; honestly was not looking at his shoulder action.

It’s akin to when someone says they are flipping versus the professional flip we dissected, for example, with Phil in the swinging left thread. OTT certainly carries a negative connotation for the majority of golfers, however, as you suggest, there is what I will call the professional OTT move.

I am under the impression that if someone has a professional OTT move, it requires aggressively swinging left to be effective???

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='FatReed' timestamp='1423788174' post='10942177']
Dan,

Actually, I find the “swinging left” part in you prior post to be interesting, as it pertains to your OTT comments. Probably would have been good for the swinging left thread. I certainly notice JC really gets left in the videos you referenced; honestly was not looking at his shoulder action.

It’s akin to when someone says they are flipping versus the professional flip we dissected, for example, with Phil in the swinging left thread. OTT certainly carries a negative connotation for the majority of golfers, however, as you suggest, there is what I will call the professional OTT move.

I am under the impression that if someone has a professional OTT move, it requires aggressively swinging left to be effective???
[/quote]

The opposite. The transition and shift out shifts path left from there no intent to swing left. My arms are in front of me. I just happen to be facing left. I hit more draws than fades with all clubs but driver.

GMac has "OTT" move but definitely doesn't swing left and extends down target line

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='iteachgolf' timestamp='1423788711' post='10942233']
[quote name='FatReed' timestamp='1423788174' post='10942177']
Dan,

Actually, I find the "swinging left" part in you prior post to be interesting, as it pertains to your OTT comments. Probably would have been good for the swinging left thread. I certainly notice JC really gets left in the videos you referenced; honestly was not looking at his shoulder action.

It's akin to when someone says they are flipping versus the professional flip we dissected, for example, with Phil in the swinging left thread. OTT certainly carries a negative connotation for the majority of golfers, however, as you suggest, there is what I will call the professional OTT move.

I am under the impression that if someone has a professional OTT move, it requires aggressively swinging left to be effective???
[/quote]

The opposite. The transition and shift out shifts path left from there no intent to swing left. My arms are in front of me. I just happen to be facing left. I hit more draws than fades with all clubs but driver.

GMac has "OTT" move but definitely doesn't swing left and extends down target line
[/quote]

Dan, is this related to what you were saying about Hunter in the last thread. Namely, his release pattern (let's call it 'stable') causes his hands to disappear around him in DTL view quicker than his club head, so it only APPEARS he might be swinging more left than, let's say Phil or VJ. However, as you keenly pointed out, his arms/hands were actually swinging more out to ball (right); hence, his draw tendency, and I suspect yours as well?

Link to post
Share on other sites

This OTT move, I think, is one of the biggest misconceptions in golf. I see people stall and drop their trail shoulder
to try to get their path more inside or their arms trail from holding them back to get more inside.

If you take a person with a huge slice and put them on a sidehill lie with the ball above their feet, most of the time
they will hit a straight shot or hook because it forces the shoulders to turn more level on the downswing and/ or
they'll sequence better because they think they need to get their arms more in front of them to hit the ball.

It seems it works the same way with telling someone to slow their swing down. They're actually only slowing down
the transition which allows them to sequence correctly and into a more powerful hitting position.

Am I way off base here?

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='iteachgolf' timestamp='1423789529' post='10942345']
Different. Hunter is way deeper than me coming down. My draw tendency comes from my AoA and how far forward low point is in my swing
[/quote]

Dan, you have access and have reviewed just about every swing on the planet, and are brilliant at giving good visual analyses.

I do not know if you have time, but would it be possible to demonstrate in some DTL views the difference between you, Hunter and/or whomever else you feel represents a good example – as it pertains to a professional OTT move being discussed here?

Thanks

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='FatReed' timestamp='1423780423' post='10941377']
[quote name='Jonnybagadonuts' timestamp='1423770689' post='10940103']
So many of us are under the impression that swinging "over the top" is the worst thing that you can do. Also we get caught up in trying to shallow the swing
by dropping the club behind us or trying to turn the left arm clockwise while in transition ( Hogan,) .

i dont know if you have ever tried turning your arms clockwise in transition but its extremely difficult motion and requires a tremendous amount of timing.

We are looking at the transition of the great players and misinterpreting what is going on . What actually is happening is that they are swinging " OVER THE TOP " of the initial plane . Which in turn
is squaring the club face. I like to call it swinging over the top from the inside. There is no conscious twisting or chain pulling or side arm throwing. Its simply getting to a backswing position where the club is in sync with the body and on a neutral plane to slightly underneath . From there its simply rotating what feels like over the top. The pieces of the puzzle fall in place the club drops behind the player slighty which shallows out the swing path and the shoulders have more then enough room to rotate freely .

A perfect example is Robert Rock.



[url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FopnOW_-UCw"]https://www.youtube....h?v=FopnOW_-UCw[/url]
[/quote]

Johnny, perhaps you could explain a little bit more about what you are seeing. . . nothing about Rock's swing looks OTT to me.

You do indicate "what feels" like OTT, and I could never argue anyone's feels, however, I do not see OTT with Rock.

I am familiar with McLean's planes and, if memory serves me, Floyd is a good example of someone who goes back under plane and re-routes up and onto a higher plane, if you will. I do not know what he 'feels', but pretty sure that is not what most would consider an OTT move.
[/quote]

All I mean is over the top of the original plane or the backswing plane . However if you take the club outside on then OTT then obviously that would be bad .

If you take the club back neutral to slightly inside then swing slightly OTT allowing the club to reroute without pulling the handle or jerking on the club,the natural forces will force the shaft to shallow. In turn delivering a square club face along with speed without manipulation .


These moves are subtle yet should be evident .

Link to post
Share on other sites

Johnny, IMHO the "hands inside, club outside" backswing and "hands outside, club inside" downswing is more prevalent (and always have been) at the highest levels of golf than any other single pattern or whatnot.

Great pickup by you.

PS. I remember being a young man arguing with a guy about how Hogan "came over the top." He acted like I had called his grandmother a horrible cook or something. I mean, he was mad. And yet there it was, a hand path on the downswing that was above the hand path on the backswing.

Mavrik SZ 9.5° w/AD BB
Epic Flash 15° w/Rogue M•AX
Nickent Genex 3DX 18.5° w/VS Proto
X Forged UT 22° w/PX
Apex Pro '19 6-A w/PX
X Forged Jaws 56, 60, 64 w/PX
TP Mills Workshop III
[img]http://pxc86358mpx1hyn3hdxen4o1.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/171831.png[/img]

Link to post
Share on other sites

OTT is only bad because you have no room to swing coming down.

If you come over and still have room for the hands to swing it's fine. Problem is, most players that come over the top have no room to swing, thus early extension, flip etc happens and that's where the problem with coming over the top lies.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice smooth swing there Dan. :good:


PING G410 LST 9* - Diamana Ltd Dialead S+ 60X
Callaway Mavrik 15* - Diamana Ltd Dialead D+ 70X
Callaway Apex 18* - Diamana S+ 80X
PXG 0311T 4-P - DGTI AMT S400
Titleist SM7 50, 56, 60 - DGTI S400
Spider X Chalk
Titleist Pro-V1 Yellow

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='NoHipMove' timestamp='1423851215' post='10946559']
Another useless thread focusing on the semantics of teaching a golf swing, without actually helping anyone.

Looks like you are helping many of the high handicappers to continue on with their outside-in swings, good job!
[/quote]

^^That was informative.

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='NoHipMove' timestamp='1423851215' post='10946559']
Another useless thread focusing on the semantics of teaching a golf swing, without actually helping anyone.

Looks like you are helping many of the high handicappers to continue on with their outside-in swings, good job!
[/quote]

anyone that comes here and reads threads honestly expecting to improve from what they read is insane.

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='HawkeyeDan' timestamp='1423774691' post='10940683']
So, if I am following correctly, you are defining "over the top" as simply coming in steeper than where you started, correct? So would Kuchar be another example of this, or is he simply going underplane in the backswing then back on plane at impact?
[/quote]

not really. Most am's steepen the shaft, bring the club in and swing over the top while steepening. This is a bit of a different move, correct way to do it the shaft will lay flatter from top as a result of swinging arms out. Right shoulder will feel over the top

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='pinhigh27' timestamp='1423853480' post='10946821']
[quote name='NoHipMove' timestamp='1423851215' post='10946559']
Another useless thread focusing on the semantics of teaching a golf swing, without actually helping anyone.

Looks like you are helping many of the high handicappers to continue on with their outside-in swings, good job!
[/quote]

anyone that comes here and reads threads honestly expecting to improve from what they read is insane.
[/quote]

Good point, but a year ago, this site area did provide me with many useful insights. Maybe I've just gotten better and many of the threads are not as useful as they once were. But this particular thread just bugs me. ....Even worse then the swinging left thread.

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='NoHipMove' timestamp='1423854478' post='10946963']
[quote name='pinhigh27' timestamp='1423853480' post='10946821']
[quote name='NoHipMove' timestamp='1423851215' post='10946559']
Another useless thread focusing on the semantics of teaching a golf swing, without actually helping anyone.

Looks like you are helping many of the high handicappers to continue on with their outside-in swings, good job!
[/quote]

anyone that comes here and reads threads honestly expecting to improve from what they read is insane.
[/quote]

Good point, but a year ago, this site area did provide me with many useful insights. Maybe I've just gotten better and many of the threads are not as useful as they once were. But this particular thread just bugs me. ....Even worse then the swinging left thread.
[/quote]

bugs you cause you dont understand it?

Link to post
Share on other sites

I second the request for the high KARATE chop move !


Ping G400 Max 10.5* Fubuki K 60x

Ping G400 5w 16.5* Blueboard 73x
Callaway GBB 19* Aldila NVS 85x
Apex '16 4h 23* Fubuki ax400h 82x

Apex ‘16 5h 27* Mitsu KuroKage 90s

Ping s55 6 - PW Fujikura MCI 100s

Ping Glide 49*, 54* & 59* wrx Recoil 110s
Piretti Matera Elite
 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='pinhigh27' timestamp='1423853480' post='10946821']
[quote name='NoHipMove' timestamp='1423851215' post='10946559']
Another useless thread focusing on the semantics of teaching a golf swing, without actually helping anyone.

Looks like you are helping many of the high handicappers to continue on with their outside-in swings, good job!
[/quote]

anyone that comes here and reads threads honestly expecting to improve from what they read is insane.
[/quote]
i don't know if that's totally accurate. I've picked up a lot of helpful stuff from folks around here, including yourself by the way.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...