Jeff Mann versus Dan Carraher

[BatManOneTwo]

See this NGI forum thread - http://newtongolfinstitute.proboards.com/thread/580/carraher-misrepresents-golfwrx-forum-thread

 

Do you agree, or disagree, with Jeff Mann's many criticisms of Dan Carrher's opinions regarding clubface control issues in the pre-impact, and immediate post-impact, phase of a driver golf swing?

 

In particular, look at post #4 where Jeff Mann compares Henrik Stenson's pre-impact and immediate post-impact degree of clubface roll to Phil Mickelson's degree of clubface roll during the same time periods.

[jut111]

In before the lock.

[martynbirch]

In before the lock.

 

Me too! :busted_cop: :cheesy:

[Doppelganger]

* sees ten foot pole *

* ... *

* slowly backs out of the room *

[DavePelz4]

And that's his first post...

 

[jut111]

Anyone else post in that forum Jeff, I mean Batman?

[Jacob Mac]

Dan does attract the crazies.

[pusb365]

[starsail85]

I've always been interested in phils swing, what causes his release? And why does he pull his head off the line?

[pusb365]

Wow just had a look at the page, that guy has a LOT of free time.

[Poser]

Dan does attract the crazies.

 

For sure he does this guy created a forum to just talk to himself....

[Krt22]

lol wow. A bunch of 2D stills and gifs by some no name vs a well known instructor who teachs pros and elite ams using the latest tech.

 

Also, this guy has been grinding his axe for over 2 years. 2 years!

 

http://newtongolfinstitute.proboards.com/thread/551/golf-forum-thread-criticising-jeff

[Puppetmaster]

Dan does attract the crazies.

 

For sure he does this guy created a forum to just talk to himself....

 

So that's a "forum" for one person to post his criticisms and not entertain any feedback?

 

Here's what is in one of the stickies:

 

Newton Golf Institute

Improvement through the free exchange of golf swing method, analysis and discussion

 

And I found this classic "I think that you are wasting your time posting in this forum (which I run) as I am the only other member participating..." in rebuffing a poster.

 

That place seems about as free as N. Korean prison.

[Arafel]

TL/DR

 

Good luck Jeff. You're a bit cuckoo.

[Grayback1973]

What a complete waste of time and energy!

[dlygrisse]

Jeff was banned from here years ago, from what I recall he didn't play nice with anyone. I don't think the guy even actually plays golf from what I remember, he just likes to over analyze what others do and have to say.

 

IIRC he was totally bought into TGM stuff for awhile, and Dan isn't the type to back down from a good argument........gotta say I have always enjoyed Dan's posts, he is a real student of the game, and has evolved a lot over the years.

 

Dan if you read this just remember, never wrestle with a pig, the pig will enjoy it and you both will get muddy.

[dlygrisse]

LOL, I just clicked on the link.

 

Notice that Jeff Mann never demonstrates a real swing himself, only positions. I mean there is no way someone could actually swing a club with that much going on in their noggin. Total paralysis by analysis.

 

What a bunch of mumbo jumbo.

 

ROFL.

[MonteScheinblum]

He went off on my First lesson with Brendon.

 

He basically said I got results, but didn't understand or know why.

[Ghost of Snead]

Jeff obviously has a few axes to grind ... look at some of the other threads re Monte, Miyahira, Richie Hunt, Como.

[cwglum]

Who else thinks this guy has a manual with pics from several angles with instruction to unlock his car with a key fob?

[MakAttack]

Man that is a big ax lol

[DavePelz4]

Anyone think the OP will have a second post?

[starsail85]

Has anybody read his stuff or are people just laughing at his expense?

[SunkTheBirdie]

Anyone think the OP will have a second post?

nope !

I think Jeff Mann should be allowed back.

and if he gets out of line ...

 

It isn't really fair to criticize someone who can't reply.

[dan360]

I think neither one has all the answers so I really couldn't care less if they fight like grade school girls on here.

[Doppelganger]

Has anybody read his stuff or are people just laughing at his expense?

 

 

Dude has a 6 part series on the OTT move all in spandex shorts in a friends family room with a childs club.

[SunkTheBirdie]

Dude has a 6 part series on the OTT move all in spandex shorts in a friends family room with a childs club.

#1) That mini club is awesome.

#2) I watched that series a few years ago and I remember it was pretty informative.

#3) those are cycling shorts. check out his quads.

 

Foreshadowing.

[Ghost of Snead]

Dude has a 6 part series on the OTT move all in spandex shorts in a friends family room with a childs club.

#1) That mini club is awesome.

#2) I watched that series a few years ago and I remember it was pretty informative.

#3) those are cycling shorts. check out his quads.

 

Foreshadowing.

 

I'd bet that Jeff would let you be his apprentice if you asked. Kind of a liaison between his site and this one.

[SunkTheBirdie]

I'd bet that Jeff would let you be his apprentice if you asked. Kind of a liaison between his site and this one.

[dlygrisse]

Anyone think the OP will have a second post?

nope !

I think Jeff Mann should be allowed back.

and if he gets out of line ...

 

It isn't really fair to criticize someone who can't reply.

 

Sure it's fair, the OP is either JM with a fake account or one of his minions he sent to troll here. It's quite obvious.