Jump to content

How forgiving are Apex CF19’s?


Recommended Posts

Gaming mizuno HMP’s now and just don’t hit them that well. Even before buying I contemplated the apex 19’s. I know they’re in the players distance category, are these things going to be as forgiving as the HMPs? I see some reviews say they’re fine for mid to high handicappers and others say not so much due to the short blade length. Thoughts?

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 18
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

They are great for mid to high cappers. They felt great, look great...and I think one of the best irons Callaway ever made. Quite forgiving. I had them for almost a year before trading them in for a s

If you are looking for a mid sized head with reduced offset I believe the Apex 19's are one of the most forgiving iron on the market. They have the added benefit of being fully forged and extremely so

They are great for mid to high cappers. They felt great, look great...and I think one of the best irons Callaway ever made. Quite forgiving. I had them for almost a year before trading them in for a set that worked better for me. The Cally's have somewhat hot faces and I found the distance deviation a bit high for me.

I wouldn't say they are better than the HMBs though.

  • Like 1

PING G410 Plus 9* Graphite Design AD XC-6
Cobra KING Speedzone FW 14.5* 3W Graphite Design AD-DI 6
Cobra KING F9 Hybrid 21* Fujikura Atmos Red 7 TS
Cobra KING F9 Hybrid 24* Fujikura Atmos Red 7 TS
Cobra KING Forged Tec 6-PW $-Taper Lite
Cleveland CBX2 48* KBS C-Taper
Cleveland CBX2 54* KBS C-Taper
Cleveland RTX 4 60* TT DG S400
Taylormade Spider X/ Scotty Cameron Special Studio Newport
2019 Taylormade TP5 ball

Link to post
Share on other sites

They are pretty forgiving but id like to say they arent as forgiving as your hot metal pros.. those are great irons... i was very close to buying a set.. but went mmc 20. Id say for sure the hmp are more forgiving by at least a notch or two. Any reason why your not more in love with them?

Link to post
Share on other sites

At first I was drawn to the lack of offset with the HMP's just looks wise, and like you said they are real forgiving which I need. But in looking again at a set of Cf19's the other day I think the increased offset in those might help me (been spraying everything right). I also think I do like the shorter blade as long as they can hold up for someone who definitely doesn't hit the sweet spot every time.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I just got the Apex 19s 2 days ago. Switched from Steelhead XRs. I was a little worried about forgiveness as well, the club heads are so much smaller than my GI irons. But I am having no issues. My miss is toe side of center by half an inch or so, maybe lose 5-10 yds max. They feel so good and so soft, but I've never played forged before. I haven't had them long enough to hit the really bad shots yet, but I'm sure it will come. But a decent strike produces good results. I think they are slightly draw favored, I am finding it more difficult to hit fades, but I haven't put my midsize grips on yet either.

In the bag

Driver: Taylormade M6 

3w: Taylormade 2016 M2

5w: Taylormade 2017 M2

Irons: Callaway Apex CF 19 4i-AW

W1: Vokey SM7 54* S

W2: Vokey SM8 60* L

Putter: Scotty Cameron Select Newport 2.5

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thats another thing... callaway seems to be anywhere from strong draw bias to just a touch draw bias. I think the apex 19s are a tad over a touch draw bias if i had to say. I guess id just recommend tring to fix your shot to the right with your hmps before getting rid of them for the apex. I personally think the hmp are better then the apex 19 thats just me though and not to say the apexx are bad they arent. That being said... do what you feels best for your game.. sometimes that is the answer.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Might be the shaft and not the club head causing the rights, are you comfortable with the shaft in your HMP's? Always found the blade length on both the HMP and 919 Forged to appear a bit longer than what I like, especially the longer irons. But with the Apex I find the offset a bit too much when you get into the 4-7 irons.

Have you considered a lie angle adjustment on you HMP's to move your shots back to centre? Mizuno has flatter lie angles as standard, may be as simple as going to a fitter, running through the set and going more upright on those irons that require it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Agree with this. Apex a little too much offset and also don’t like the PW shape. HMP/HMB too long a blade length. Same with the z545s. I’m still searching for that iron that has a squat head...low offset, but a nice wide forgiving sole. Maybe the i210s?

Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are a high handicapper then a SGI club is better for you due to the wider sole and larger club face. Also consider going with a lightweight graphite shaft. The Apex 19 look nice and of course the better players club look nicer than SGI's but at the end of the day would you want looks or performance?

Cally B21 5 Wood

Cally B21 5 Hybrid

Cally Mavrik Max 6 iron through Approach Wedge

Cally MD4 52 degree wedge

Cleveland 56 and 60 degree Full Face wedges

Cleveland Frontline 4.0 putter

 

Ball Cally Superhot Bold yellow

Link to post
Share on other sites

When I got fit it actually came down to the hmp and apex. I felt the forgiveness was much better with the hmps. I went in wanting the apex but my numbers with hmp were much better. Also felt hitting a great shot took less work with the mizzys

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm surprised you didn't like the Z545's, thought the blade was shorter in the 4-6 than HMP. Z545 always looked a bit too square in the toe, but they've smoothed it out nicely in the Z585. I would go Z785 if my game was better, nicer feel than Z585, better looking short irons and a touch less offset. I'm a huge Ping guy but I hate the shape of the i210 wedges, too spoon like for my eye. Don't like the Apex PW either.

Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are looking for a mid sized head with reduced offset I believe the Apex 19's are one of the most forgiving iron on the market. They have the added benefit of being fully forged and extremely soft feel.

There are more forgiving irons in this category but they will be irons with larger heads, more offset and significantly firmer feel.

 

Relative to the Apex '19 here's my view on other irons in this category which I have hit extensively:

T200 - Less forgiving. Longer blade length. Firmer feel. Slightly longer blade length. Thinner topline.

P790 - Firmer feel. Face feels less hot. Slightly longer blade length & thicker top line.

HMB - Firmer feel. Muted feedback. Much longer blade length. Thicker topline.

HM Pro - Firmer feel. Face feels very hot. Similar look at address.

 

 

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1

d: G410+ | f: M3 |  h: Epic | i: 921 Tour | w: T-20 | p: SpiderX

Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been playing the Apex 19's for the last year. During that time, I've done a number of comparisons (with a fitter) to other irons and found that the Apex 19's are as easy to hit and longer than most of the other irons I've compared them to. I don't consider myself an extraordinary player... I play to about a 12-14, 72 years old, and only been playing golf for 5 years.

I recently purchased a set of Honma XP-1's - definitely in the GI category. Heads are larger than the Apex 19's. I played them for a couple months and found them enjoyable to play; however, I decided to switch back to my Apex 19's and found that they were more accurate (better dispersion), easier to shape (I do very little of this), and even more forgiving than the XP-1's. The smaller head really seems to appeal to me and I think I am more suited to play the Apex than any other iron I've tried thus far.

I was not fitted for the Apex 19's, but I was fitted for the Apex 16's and upgraded to the 19's with the same specs.

One thing that I think is misquoted is that this is a forged hear... I believe only the face is forged, not the entire head.

I think this is one of the best irons that Callaway has ever produced and you can do a blended set with the Apex Pros.

I've never played a Mizuno iron, but I did purchase a HM Pro in a 7 iron for comparison and found that it was not as good as the Apex 19's 7 iron.

I would also like to add that there are lots of irons that I have tried that are in the same category as the Apex 19's and I could easily play them. Would I be as good a player if I switched... I don't think so and that's why I have stayed with the Apex 19's ... for now. If you're looking for an investment that you can't go wrong with, then the Apex 19's are a safe pick. You might look at Callaway pre-owned for 2ndswing.com to see if you can pickup a used set. Or, Callaway accepts trade if you want to give up on the HMB's.

Link to post
Share on other sites

PING G25s

PING G410 Plus 9* Graphite Design AD XC-6
Cobra KING Speedzone FW 14.5* 3W Graphite Design AD-DI 6
Cobra KING F9 Hybrid 21* Fujikura Atmos Red 7 TS
Cobra KING F9 Hybrid 24* Fujikura Atmos Red 7 TS
Cobra KING Forged Tec 6-PW $-Taper Lite
Cleveland CBX2 48* KBS C-Taper
Cleveland CBX2 54* KBS C-Taper
Cleveland RTX 4 60* TT DG S400
Taylormade Spider X/ Scotty Cameron Special Studio Newport
2019 Taylormade TP5 ball

Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry misread this. I dropped the G25s for the Apex 19s. So I know forgiveness.

I moved on to the Cobra Forged Tec 2020 from the Apex 19s at the start of this year. Dispersion is super tight in comparison for me. Distance and left/right.

PING G410 Plus 9* Graphite Design AD XC-6
Cobra KING Speedzone FW 14.5* 3W Graphite Design AD-DI 6
Cobra KING F9 Hybrid 21* Fujikura Atmos Red 7 TS
Cobra KING F9 Hybrid 24* Fujikura Atmos Red 7 TS
Cobra KING Forged Tec 6-PW $-Taper Lite
Cleveland CBX2 48* KBS C-Taper
Cleveland CBX2 54* KBS C-Taper
Cleveland RTX 4 60* TT DG S400
Taylormade Spider X/ Scotty Cameron Special Studio Newport
2019 Taylormade TP5 ball

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...