Swing Caddie SC200+ is swing speed measurement accurate?

[me05501]

I recently got a SC200+ and so far I've only been able to use it at home, no ball. I'm using the Practice Mode which is supposed to measure swing speed. Has anyone compared this mode to a calibrated/reliable launch monitor? 

[Exactice808]

6 hours ago, me05501 said:

I recently got a SC200+ and so far I've only been able to use it at home, no ball. I'm using the Practice Mode which is supposed to measure swing speed. Has anyone compared this mode to a calibrated/reliable launch monitor? 

Not totally relevant,  But my take,

 

I have an SC100,  which is just the older version of the SC200.  The basic Swing speed is pretty accurate, Wedges, Irons and hybrids especially.  Woods and Driver are a little sketchy.

This was compared to a ES14 I recently purchased. (Last year, side by side testing)

 

Finally this was compared to numbers I have gotten on Trackman at fittings and a GCquad at other fittings. 

 

The biggest thing is that its a doppler that measure both ball and club.  The bigger issue is that Trackman Measure the middle of the club.  Dopplers sometimes picks up the heel, middle and toe.  So the +/- could be as much as 5mph.  meaning 100mph +/- 5mph,  which could be a big difference.

 

 

What I did find was really accurate? Ballspeed,  SC100, ES14 where super close and close to Trackman and GCQuad I would say +/-3mph,  which is reasonable considering the price disparity. ($250, $500 vs $5,000 to $25,000)