New Wedges, but Which?

[Evil R1]

I need to pick up a new Lob Wedge, but I'm having a hard time figuring out which direction to go. Just as some background, the Lofts of my Irons are a bit screwy. I don't have a the typical 46º PW, instead I have a 45º 10i and instead of a 51º Approach Wedge, I have a 50º Wedge.

 

I currently have a Callaway Forged+ 56º14º that I like alot. I love the weight of the club, feel, even thr grip how it's thicker at the bottom for choking up. But I can only produce OK shots with it and I am rather inconsistent. At the same time, my wife has the BB'04 55º SW that I hit rather well and consistently and generally produce much more accurate shots, but I don't like the feel as much as much as the forged.

 

So, do I go with works better for me (BB'04) and replace my Forged+, or do I go with what feels better (Forged+) and as my skill increases so will my ability to have better shots with these wedges?

 

*** EDIT ***

I was personally thinking of going with the BB'04's as they will probably produce lower scores right now. When I am ready to replace my Irons with something new, get new wedges too.

 

Thanks,

[BigBaller]

I'd say the smart play would be to go with the matching BB wedges...

 

By your own admission you'll probably score better with them at present, and if you plan on selling the BB's in the not too distant future in favor of a new set (sounds like it?), matching wedges will help enhance the trade in / re-sale value you'll be able to command from the BB set.