Rogue Silver/Black vs Aldila Tour Green

[ob1soccer]

Any direct comparisons between the rogue silver/black to the aldila tour green. as far as i can see there is no MSI listed for the green shaft so how do you compare it the the rogue shafts besides weight and torque. i have 3 tour greens in my fairways and hybrids and wanted information about the driver shafts between the 3, thanks

[NuckandCup]

[quote name='ob1soccer' timestamp='1429014559' post='11354759']
Any direct comparisons between the rogue silver/black to the aldila tour green. as far as i can see there is no MSI listed for the green shaft so how do you compare it the the rogue shafts besides weight and torque. i have 3 tour greens in my fairways and hybrids and wanted information about the driver shafts between the 3, thanks
[/quote]

Rogue Silver and Black are two differnt shafts....Black is Mid launch; Mid spin....Silver is low/mid launch; mid/low spin.

Tour Green is mid/low launch; low spin. New version of the NV. LOL

Personally, I found the Green to 'feel' a little looser than the Rogue, not more flexible, just looser. But it's a feel thing to me. So just an opinion there. I love the Rogue Black, feels a little tighter than the Diamana S+, better dispersion. I have it on order in the 915D3 & 915F I rececently placed.

[jgripp81]

The rogue is stiffer in the butt section and a little bit in the tip. Same mid section. It also plays a tad stiffer overall and cpms almost a flex stronger. The rogue has a little less torque that gives it that "tighter" feel.
I like both for different reasons. The green for me is a beast if my tempo is more on the smooth side. But with the driver it's about distance and the rogue feels like it can handle me going after it.
A cheaper, lower launching, similar feel to the rogue is the phenom NL (for me).

[ob1soccer]

so the main difference between the silver and the green is the silver is low to mid spin and the green is low spin? that sounds like it is not significant, is that correct. i hit the black and it was very different then the green, higher launch.

[PinonMagnolia]

[quote name='jgripp81' timestamp='1429018807' post='11355263']
The rogue is stiffer in the butt section and a little bit in the tip. Same mid section. It also plays a tad stiffer overall and cpms almost a flex stronger. The rogue has a little less torque that gives it that "tighter" feel.
I like both for different reasons. The green for me is a beast if my tempo is more on the smooth side. But with the driver it's about distance and the rogue feels like it can handle me going after it.
A cheaper, lower launching, similar feel to the rogue is the phenom NL (for me).
[/quote]

This mimics what I felt with the silver. I haven't hit the black, but I immediately tried the silver because I liked the greens so much.

[jgripp81]

Silver "should" launch and spin lower. But not much. Probably less than 100 rpms.
I maybe way off on my assumption, but I would say the rogue is more like a blueboard in the butt section and tip is closer to the whiteboard.
The green would be softer in the butt like a wb and softer tip like the bb.
I have no experience with the black rogue but I would say it's more like a tour blue or phenom.

[PinonMagnolia]

I will add that the plays stiffer comment was the first thing I noticed. The silver 110 played like a softer X to me, something like an AD DI X, not a whiteboard or speeder X.

[Sef]

Great info in this very old thread. I felt like the tour green in my X2 Hot Pro was creating dispersion issues. Like the shaft is soft to flex and I have to put a very smooth swing on it to keep it online. My driver shafts are rogue 125msi 70tx and speeder evo 2 757 x and neither feel loose like the green.

 

I wonder if the green 75 TX would be a better fit? And if I can find one...