Jump to content

mizuno mx-17 vs. mx-23


chukman

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 10
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Night and day difference. The MX-17 is cast and MX-23 is forged. If you are going to go Mizuno, go all in and get forged. The MX-23's are plenty forgiving, just not ultra forgiving like the 17's. The MX-17's are OK in the feel deptartment, but IMHO there are better super game improvement irons out there.

PING G430 Max 10.5 

PING G430 5w
Cleveland Launcher XL Halo 4H

Cleveland XL Halo 5H

Srixon MKii ZX5s 6-PW Modus 105s

Cleveland CBX4 Zipcore 48*

Cleveland CBX4 Zipcore 52*
Cleveland CBX4 Zipcore 56*

PXG Battle Ready 'Bat Attack' 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've owned both sets and each are outstanding IMO. Prior to buying the 17's I demo'ed and/or owned almost all of the popular OEM cast GI clubs and for me the 17's were easily the most appealing. I recently bought the 23's solely because I wanted to experience the soft Mizuno forged feeling, if I find that I don't consistently hit the 23's well this summer I'll acquire another set of 17's in a heartbeat. The two major differences between these are feel and look at address. The 23's are very soft at impact and although there's alot of game improvement built in, at address I feel like I'm using a "players" club because the topline is thin and the power bar is hidden at address. I found impact with the 17's to be excellent in a very different way, well struck shots were firm and satisfying (IMO a similar feel to Ping ISI's I once owned, but the 17's are more forgiving), and the 17's felt impressively stable on shots anywhere on the grooves. While offset specs may actually be similar, the 17's seemed to have more while I played them and the thick topline looks quite different from the 23. I know many players detest irons with a fat topline but I liked it in the 17's, the clubhead looks so dense and stable that I had no psychological hesitation swinging 100% (no worries about stinging thin or toe shots). Although the 23's seem smaller (probably because of the thin topline), when I held both up in a proshop to compare the 17's are actually shorter heel-to-toe and topline-to-sole. I can't compare the 3 and 4 irons in the set because my 23's are 5-PW, but the 17 long irons were the easiest to hit of any set I've ever owned or tried (the Big Bertha 2004 and Cobra 3100 long irons are also very easy to hit well), I haven't hit the MX-900's but I find it hard to believe that they could be any more user friendly than the 17's. I agree with an earlier post that the 17's don't seem to get much love on most forums but I think they deserve as much or more than any cast GI club available.

Rapture V1 10.5 BB
Rapture V1 14
G15 2,4,5,6 HY Recoil 95
G15 7-LW CFS
Karsten TR B60

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I went through the same decision about this time last year and chose the 17s based strictly on the price. I was too new to the game to know much about the different sets or where to get good deals at but I haven't regretted the decision in the least. They are extremely easy to hit, I've dropped from low 100s to low-mid 80s using them. Being new, I couldn't tell much difference in the feel and was more concerned about not spending a lot on something I might not be able to hit well but now I'll semi thinking of stepping up a little to the 23s or maybe the 60s. The 900s are way too overpriced for a GI set, if that's where you're going stay with the 17s. There are a couple of demo days coming up at local courses where I'm going to try them out. If I don't feel a noticeable difference I will gladly keep the 17s in the bag.

 

:idhitit:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Night and day difference. The MX-17 is cast and MX-23 is forged. If you are going to go Mizuno, go all in and get forged. The MX-23's are plenty forgiving, just not ultra forgiving like the 17's. The MX-17's are OK in the feel deptartment, but IMHO there are better super game improvement irons out there.

 

:stop:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey Guy, Iwould go with. the mx - 23, reasons being, I the mx-17 for a month. these are some excellent clubs, but don't get the respect they deserve. Ther good for the BEGINNERS, with some offset as oppose to some of the othe super game improvement clubs. Nice feel both long and short irons.The problem I had with the 17's were when i took some lessons, my ball striking improved. :stop: At thi point I decided to take the 17's back to golfsmith (100/100 playability) I was give a store credit and got fitted for the mx-23. From that point I've been in Mizuno heaven ever since :miz::miz::miz:

 

Do the Following:

 

 

1. Demo both clubs

2. chooooose one (mx 23)

3. GET FITTED :shout:

4. Lessons

 

5. Enjoy :D :WTF:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nice to see another budget minded man out there. I demo the 23's several times and just didnt get the feel or response I expected from Mizuno's. I ended up going to Cleveland Ta6's for the mid irons I was looking for. I really really wanted the Mizuno 23's but they just felt wrong. Off to Cleveland, I'm staying with my MP 30's for the "scoring" clubs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've owned both sets and each are outstanding IMO. Prior to buying the 17's I demo'ed and/or owned almost all of the popular OEM cast GI clubs and for me the 17's were easily the most appealing. I recently bought the 23's solely because I wanted to experience the soft Mizuno forged feeling, if I find that I don't consistently hit the 23's well this summer I'll acquire another set of 17's in a heartbeat. The two major differences between these are feel and look at address. The 23's are very soft at impact and although there's alot of game improvement built in, at address I feel like I'm using a "players" club because the topline is thin and the power bar is hidden at address. I found impact with the 17's to be excellent in a very different way, well struck shots were firm and satisfying (IMO a similar feel to Ping ISI's I once owned, but the 17's are more forgiving), and the 17's felt impressively stable on shots anywhere on the grooves. While offset specs may actually be similar, the 17's seemed to have more while I played them and the thick topline looks quite different from the 23. I know many players detest irons with a fat topline but I liked it in the 17's, the clubhead looks so dense and stable that I had no psychological hesitation swinging 100% (no worries about stinging thin or toe shots). Although the 23's seem smaller (probably because of the thin topline), when I held both up in a proshop to compare the 17's are actually shorter heel-to-toe and topline-to-sole. I can't compare the 3 and 4 irons in the set because my 23's are 5-PW, but the 17 long irons were the easiest to hit of any set I've ever owned or tried (the Big Bertha 2004 and Cobra 3100 long irons are also very easy to hit well), I haven't hit the MX-900's but I find it hard to believe that they could be any more user friendly than the 17's. I agree with an earlier post that the 17's don't seem to get much love on most forums but I think they deserve as much or more than any cast GI club available.

 

Right on Brother!!! I read this thread numerous times. All of you guys peaked my interest in these Mizunos. So, I went to the fitter today and hit about 100 balls with the 7's, 23's and the 900's. I liked both the 23's and the 900's, but I just keep going back to the 17's. They all had the Dynalite S300 stiffs in them.

 

The 17's felt heavier and more stable. Frankly, I did not have one miss hit with them. It was a really tough call as all of them were good. But I truly liked the feel the best with the 17's. I also got the best ball flight with them.

 

Trades in my X-18's, and got 4 through PW for $166.00. What a deal!!!

 

Thanks to all for your excellent input!

Best regards,

dukie mizuno :stop:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Our picks

    • Tiger Woods - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Tiger Woods - WITB - 2024 US Open
        • Like
      • 49 replies
    • 2024 US Open - Discussion and Links to Photos
      Please put any questions or comments here
       
       
       
       
      General Albums
       
      2024 US Open - Monday #1
       
       
       
       
      WITB Albums
       
      Tiger Woods - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Edoardo Molinari - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Logan McAllister - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Bryan Kim - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Richard Mansell - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Jackson Buchanan - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Carter Jenkins - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Parker Bell - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Omar Morales - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Neil Shipley - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Casey Jarvis - WITB - 2024 US Open
      Carson Schaake - WITB - 2024 US Open
       
       
       
       
      Pullout Albums
       

      Tiger Woods on the range at Pinehurst on Monday – 2024 U.S. Open
      Newton Motion shaft - 2024 US Open
      Cameron putter covers - 2024 US Open
      New UST Mamiya Linq shaft - 2024 US Open

       

       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
      • 5 replies
    • Titleist GT drivers - 2024 the Memorial Tournament
      Early in hand photos of the new GT2 models t the truck.  As soon as they show up on the range in player's bags we'll get some better from the top photos and hopefully some comparison photos against the last model.
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
        • Thanks
        • Like
      • 367 replies
    • 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge - Discussion and Links to Photos
      Please put any questions or comments here
       
       
       
      General Albums
       
      2024 Charles Schwab Challenge - Monday #1
      2024 Charles Schwab Challenge - Tuesday #1
      2024 Charles Schwab Challenge - Tuesday #2
      2024 Charles Schwab Challenge - Tuesday #3
       
       
       
       
      WITB Albums
       
      Keith Mitchell - WITB - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Rafa Campos - WITB - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      R Squared - WITB - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Martin Laird - WITB - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Paul Haley - WITB - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Tyler Duncan - WITB - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Min Woo Lee - WITB - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Austin Smotherman - WITB - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Lee Hodges - WITB - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Sami Valimaki - WITB - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
       
       
       
       
      Pullout Albums
       
      Eric Cole's newest custom Cameron putter - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      New Super Stroke Marvel comic themed grips - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Ben Taylor's custom Cameron putter - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Tyler Duncan's Axis 1 putter - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Cameron putters - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Chris Kirk's new Callaway Opus wedges - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      ProTC irons - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Dragon Skin 360 grips - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      Cobra prototype putters - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
      SeeMore putters - 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
      • 0 replies
    • 2024 PGA Championship - Discussion and Links to Photos
      Please put  any questions or comments here
       
       
       
       
      General Albums
       
      2024 PGA Championship - Monday #1
       
       
       
       
       
      WITB Albums
       
      Michael Block - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Patrick Reed - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Cam Smith - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Brooks Koepka - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Josh Speight - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Takumi Kanaya - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Kyle Mendoza - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Adrian Meronk - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Jordan Smith - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Jeremy Wells - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Jared Jones - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      John Somers - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Larkin Gross - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Tracy Phillips - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Jon Rahm - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Keita Nakajima - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Kazuma Kobori - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      David Puig - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
      Ryan Van Velzen - WITB - 2024 PGA Championship
       
       
       
       
      Pullout Albums
       
      Ping putter covers - 2024 PGA Championship
      Bettinardi covers - 2024 PGA Championship
      Cameron putter covers - 2024 PGA Championship
      Max Homa - Titleist 2 wood - 2024 PGA Championship
      Scotty Cameron experimental putter shaft by UST - 2024 PGA Championship
       
       
       
        • Like
      • 13 replies

×
×
  • Create New...