Do Not Pull On the Club from the Top of the Backswing...Stop the Handle Late In Downswing.

Righty to Lefty · March 25

1 hour ago, KMeloney said:

Right. The ball is impact, and the golfer dictates the plane. The ball ISN'T on a [let alone "the'] plane -- so why talk about it like it is?

Are you being serious? The ball must be placed at some point along your swing arc or you can't hit it. The plane angle and club face must also match your intentions because any change to any of those parameters will change what you must do in order to hit a given shot. If you come into a given shot above or under a given plane then I hope that it was planned for, because if not, the ball is not going where you thought it was. What are you really debating against? The build of the club will affect your plane angle and that plane angle determines the arc that the club will travel.

Edited March 25 by Righty to Lefty

GoGoErky · March 25

17 minutes ago, Righty to Lefty said:

I created the thread because I am interested in golf. If someone was a true teacher they would take my information and massage it to be 100% correct because they " see what I mean" and would educate the whole thread and we would all be better for it in the end but the disrespect is ridiculous and then I'm the one being warned by the MODS for telling someone to move along if my message isn't for them while using all capital letters. I personally disagree with his teaching method but I don't follow him around the thread and troll him because it is petty. I assure you that anyone that meets me in person would quickly see that I am not just making things up and that is why I offer to play with anyone in the area that wants to play as I am very passionate about the game and the main goal is to find improvement.

You have a teacher telling you that you are wrong.

You may disagree with his method which is ok, even he and Monte another teacher who has pointed out issues don’t agree.

You have yet to provide anything other than what you feel or what you think happens and each time it’s been shown to be false and that there is actual measurements and other data that shows why you are wrong and you have done nothing to provide data that shows why you are right and he is wrong. You have posted videos trying to prove you point and they actually contradicted your point.

Iacas has years of proven results of teaching the swing to various skills levels, and understands 3d and that’s why he’s able to show what’s right or wrong.

Others have pointed out in videos you posted from other instructors that your understanding of at least how you explain what’s being discussed in the video is incorrect

At some point when each and every thought and concept is proven to be wrong a person will accept it, admit it and try to learn, instead you hold to your guns and double down each time.

I won’t comment on the rest of your post because it just shows that you refuse to listen to what’s being said and that no matter what you are told or shown doesn’t matter because you despite no proof of getting multiple students of different skill levels are right and those who actually are the professionals have no idea what’s being said and that only you know the truth.