PXG One and Done putter reviews

[DLBTide7]

On 12/29/2020 at 9:59 PM, OspreyCI said:

Any update? Does it beat out all the putters in your quiver? 

Yes it does.

[OspreyCI]

On 12/19/2020 at 10:30 PM, DLBTide7 said:

 

Received my One and Done today in time to take it out to the course. 35”, Lamkin Sink Fit grip. 
 

A great feeling putter; very easy to align.  For those that are familiar with the PXG line, the pyramid face puts an outstanding roll on the ball.
 

From PXG, I have a: (i) Mustang, (ii) Spitfire; (iii) Bat Attack; (iv) Closer; and (v) Operator.  By far, the One and Done is my favorite from that lineup. 

Can you compare the Bat Attack and the O&D?  Stability? 

[DLBTide7]

9 minutes ago, OspreyCI said:

Can you compare the Bat Attack and the O&D?  Stability? 

Such a different feel between the two. My BA is a Gen 1 and I love the feel of the milled Gen 2 putters. 
 

To me (and it is always subjective) the BA might have a little more stability, but O&D is so much better visually on alignment. 

[OspreyCI]

1 minute ago, DLBTide7 said:

Such a different feel between the two. My BA is a Gen 1 and I love the feel of the milled Gen 2 putters. 
 

To me (and it is always subjective) the BA might have a little more stability, but O&D is so much better visually on alignment. 

Appreciate it. I need the most stable putter they have other than the O&D. My Gunboat was stable, but been trying various #7 putters a lot at PGA SS and love the stability and alignment of these styles. I just cannot justify $100 over a Gunboat or BA. 

 

Thanks for help. 

[Zonazoo]

Heading to PXG headquarters for a putter fitting this week. Top 3 I am looking to try are the 1. Blackjack 2. Gunboat 3. One&Done. Was excited to hear they have a quintic putting system in store for the fitting. 

 

I have a Scotty Cameron Newport now, it’s been great but looking to try out a higher MOI putter to see if it helps dial in my putting for longer putts. 

[OspreyCI]

On 1/24/2021 at 7:45 AM, Zonazoo said:

Heading to PXG headquarters for a putter fitting this week. Top 3 I am looking to try are the 1. Blackjack 2. Gunboat 3. One&Done. Was excited to hear they have a quintic putting system in store for the fitting. 

 

I have a Scotty Cameron Newport now, it’s been great but looking to try out a higher MOI putter to see if it helps dial in my putting for longer putts. 

They do a great job with putter fittings. I have been fit twice. Gunboat first time and putted so well with it. Spitfire second time, but did not purchase. I bought the O&D on the spot when trying it at HQ. Several rounds with it and it is just so good!
 

Report back how it goes and enjoy. 

[Zonazoo]

On 1/25/2021 at 3:21 PM, OspreyCI said:

They do a great job with putter fittings. I have been fit twice. Gunboat first time and putted so well with it. Spitfire second time, but did not purchase. I bought the O&D on the spot when trying it at HQ. Several rounds with it and it is just so good!
 

Report back how it goes and enjoy. 

Got fit today and wound up going with the blackjack slant neck. I am coming from a blade so I liked that it was a slimmer mallet profile. Overall great experience and their HQ is pretty impressive. Looking forward to getting it out on the course. 

[OspreyCI]

1 hour ago, Zonazoo said:

Got fit today and wound up going with the blackjack slant neck. I am coming from a blade so I liked that it was a slimmer mallet profile. Overall great experience and their HQ is pretty impressive. Looking forward to getting it out on the course. 

Glad you had a great experience. PXG really treats their customers top notch. 

[DG Tiger]

Tried the 1 & Done today with 37inch length & loved it over BlackJack & GEN2 putter. The best part is easy to align & roll baby!

[OspreyCI]

Twice in my group today the guys yelled “One and Done” when I made

some long birdies today. It was funny.

 

The alignment is just money! 

[getitdaily]

Just now, OspreyCI said:

Twice in my group today the guys yelled “One and Done” when I made

some long birdies today. It was funny.

 

The alignment is just money! 

 Nice. I may have found the key to unlock my blackjack...very different than any putter I've ever had...

 

380g headweight 

Wristlock grip with 50g counter weight.

 

Seems to have gotten my a touch inside the path, where I prefer to putt from. Just need distance work. I was terrible outside 20 feet with it last weekend. But that terrible distance control (everything short) led to me seeing that it was super solid inside 10 feet.

[OspreyCI]

My head seems a touch heavy. Might try a counterweight with the new SS grip I am installing. 

[Hotdocta]

35 minutes ago, OspreyCI said:

Twice in my group today the guys yelled “One and Done” when I made

some long birdies today. It was funny.

 

The alignment is just money! 

Did you say earlier in this thread that you were gaming spider x before?    Compare spider x and one and done., if you could, please

[OspreyCI]

Just now, Hotdocta said:

Did you say earlier in this thread that you were gaming spider x before?    Compare spider x and one and done., if you could, please

Yes, I have only played spiders for years to include the X. The O&D alignment is much better and the head is way more stable. I like the feel off the face better too. Putter outs a great roll on it. 
 

I played a PXG Gen2 Gunboat prior to the Spider X. Another PXG putter that is very stable. 

[MPAndreassi]

I have been a big mallet guy before, and I got my O&D a couple weeks ago and love it. Mine has two 10g and two 15g weights, playing at 375g headweight. The alignment is the best of anything I've ever putt with, and its incredibly stable. I've had snow on the ground since it's arrived, but have spent a ton of time putting with it on the mat inside. It'll be in my bag to start the season here. 

[snagy2000]

Mine is scheduled to arrive tomorrow after a way too long journey. I think someone at FedEx was playing with it for 2 weeks instead of moving it through the system. No biggies, gave me time to rekindle my Gen2 Mustang love affair. Hopefully One & Done will give the ol' girl a run for the money.

 

[OspreyCI]

Just picked up a SS Pistol GT 2.0 with 50g counterweight. Might just work. My partners today tried and both said it it was pretty head heaven. I was hitting numerous putts long. 

[snagy2000]

Mine came in a little over an hour ago. Have a question. How do you miss with this thing? Took it out to my green and preceded to drain 50 four footers in a row before stopping. Stupid easy today align and the roll is awesome. 

[getitdaily]

36 minutes ago, snagy2000 said:

Mine came in a little over an hour ago. Have a question. How do you miss with this thing? Took it out to my green and preceded to drain 50 four footers in a row before stopping. Stupid easy today align and the roll is awesome. 

Go to a practice green where the area around the hole isn't sloped toward the hole...lol

 

Hope your initial results prove true on the course.

[OspreyCI]

7 hours ago, snagy2000 said:

Mine came in a little over an hour ago. Have a question. How do you miss with this thing? Took it out to my green and preceded to drain 50 four footers in a row before stopping. Stupid easy today align and the roll is awesome. 

You too will be yelling “One and Done” when the birdies start falling. 

[DNice26]

Anyone see the new Bat Attack they have on the site?  Like the O&D, but the new BA looks more my style.

[getitdaily]

7 hours ago, DNice26 said:

Anyone see the new Bat Attack they have on the site?  Like the O&D, but the new BA looks more my style.

That definitely look sweet. Much better than the original bat attack.  

[getitdaily]

Hey @OspreyCIsince I know you want to see the new bat attack...how about you sneak over to pxg and snap a photo of the toe hang on it with a plumber's neck hosel...lol

[OspreyCI]

21 minutes ago, getitdaily said:

Hey @OspreyCIsince I know you want to see the new bat attack...how about you sneak over to pxg and snap a photo of the toe hang on it with a plumber's neck hosel...lol

Lol. I will tomorrow. I’ll be there picking up my new Proto 3 wood and some extra weights. I’ll ask to go back and look at it for you and snap a pic of the toe hang. 

[getitdaily]

7 minutes ago, OspreyCI said:

Lol. I will tomorrow. I’ll be there picking up my new Proto 3 wood and some extra weights. I’ll ask to go back and look at it for you and snap a pic of the toe hang. 

You're alright in my book!

[endy]

10 hours ago, getitdaily said:

That definitely look sweet. Much better than the original bat attack.  

Looks great, will also be checking that one out eventually.

[DFDLT]

I have the new PLD and a 2019 SC Phantom X 5.5. Planned on selling the 5.5 and replacing with the updated version and now that I’ve seen the new bat attack for $150 less, I may go that route. 

[OspreyCI]

23 hours ago, getitdaily said:

You're alright in my book!

Not happening today, maybe tomorrow. My weights are not ready yet. Don’t want to make two trips. I’ll be in touch. 

[getitdaily]

6 minutes ago, OspreyCI said:

Not happening today, maybe tomorrow. My weights are not ready yet. Don’t want to make two trips. I’ll be in touch. 

Right on man.

[OspreyCI]

On 2/10/2021 at 10:24 AM, OspreyCI said:

Not happening today, maybe tomorrow. My weights are not ready yet. Don’t want to make two trips. I’ll be in touch. 

Sorry man. There were no Bat Attacks out and they were too crazy busy to ask a fitter to go way in the back and see if they had one. Sorry I could not help.