We have launched our new enhanced Editor. There is an overview and tutorial Here.

Putting in 2019 - Flagstick in or out?

1356715
15

Comments

  • pinhigh27pinhigh27  9794WRX Points: 309Members Posts: 9,794
    Joined:  #62


    Please do give the physics lesson Mr wizard.





    Hit it 10 ft by dead center and it will hit the back and pop over or spit back out at you. If you hit it on the lip it will power off in the opposite direction. But there’s a chance of hitting it slightly off center and it staying in.



    Now add a flagstick there. It has almost zero shot at going in. If it hits the pin its coming out. Maybe won’t go by as far. But thats a poor lag putt strategy.



    I’m telling you that no good player who’s learned this game flag out is going to rewire his brain to putt flag in. Might as wel get used to putting your own pin back in. Because most arent going to do it for you.




    Not sure if you actually play golf. This is extremely simple
    Posted:
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • LondonerLondoner  1176WRX Points: 72Members Posts: 1,176
    Joined:  #63
    Explanation for Rule Change for 2019 - Ball Played from Green Hits Unattended Flagstick in Hole Current Rule: Under Rule 17-3, if a player makes a stroke on the putting green and the ball then hits the unattended flagstick that was left in the hole, the player gets the general penalty. 2019 Rule: Under Rule 13.2a(2):  There will no longer be a penalty if a ball played from the putting green hits a flagstick left in the hole.  Players will not be required to putt with the flagstick in the hole; rather, they will continue to have the choice to have it removed (which includes having someone attend the flagstick and remove it after the ball is played). Reasons for Change:  Allowing a player to putt with the flagstick in the hole without fear of penalty should generally help speed up play: o For example, if a putt is long enough that the player cannot easily see the hole unless the flagstick is left in, the player currently needs to wait for another person to attend the flagstick even if it is the player’s turn to play or (in stroke play) if the player is ready to play and it would save time to go ahead and do so. o This change could also speed up play for short tap-ins, as the player could simply putt the ball into the hole without first removing and then replacing the flagstick.  When the players do not have caddies, the current Rule can result in considerable delay, such as: o When the opponent (or the other player in stroke play) is raking a greenside bunker and will be delayed for a minute or two before coming on to the green. o When other players in stroke play are delayed in coming on to the green for other reasons, such as a ball search, indecision about what club to use or shot to play, etc. o When all players in the group have long putts and so will need to walk back and forth to the hole to attend the flagstick for one another (which sometimes produces uncertainty about who will or should attend for someone else).  In match play, a player without a caddie will now be able to choose to putt with the unattended flagstick in the hole rather than ask the opponent to attend the flagstick, reducing the potential for dispute that can arise when the opponent attends for the player (such as when the opponent fails to remove the flagstick and the ball hits it).  On balance it is expected that there should be no advantage in being able to putt with the unattended flagstick in the hole: o In some cases, the ball may strike the flagstick and bounce out of the hole when it might otherwise have been holed, and o In other cases, the ball may hit the flagstick and finish in the hole when it might otherwise have missed. http://www.usga.org/...olf for 2019 (1).pdf




    Ive already read that. It doesn't answer my questions.
    Posted:
    Mizuno mp h5. 4-W KBS tour stiff 2 iron modus 3 stiff.
    taylormade m2 Driver + hl 3 wood
    ping anser
    Titleist sm6 50 +54
    Cleveland 60
  • hybrid25hybrid25 michigan 1587WRX Points: 176Members Posts: 1,587
    Joined:  #64


    Explanation for Rule Change for 2019 - Ball Played from Green Hits Unattended Flagstick in Hole



    Current Rule: Under Rule 17-3, if a player makes a stroke on the putting green and the ball then

    hits the unattended flagstick that was left in the hole, the player gets the general penalty.



    2019 Rule: Under Rule 13.2a(2):



     There will no longer be a penalty if a ball played from the putting green hits a flagstick

    left in the hole.

     Players will not be required to putt with the flagstick in the hole; rather, they will

    continue to have the choice to have it removed (which includes having someone attend

    the flagstick and remove it after the ball is played).



    Reasons for Change:



     Allowing a player to putt with the flagstick in the hole without fear of penalty should

    generally help speed up play:



    o For example, if a putt is long enough that the player cannot easily see the hole

    unless the flagstick is left in, the player currently needs to wait for another person to

    attend the flagstick even if it is the player’s turn to play or (in stroke play) if the

    player is ready to play and it would save time to go ahead and do so.

    o This change could also speed up play for short tap-ins, as the player could simply

    putt the ball into the hole without first removing and then replacing the flagstick.



     When the players do not have caddies, the current Rule can result in considerable delay, such as:



    o When the opponent (or the other player in stroke play) is raking a greenside bunker

    and will be delayed for a minute or two before coming on to the green.

    o When other players in stroke play are delayed in coming on to the green for other

    reasons, such as a ball search, indecision about what club to use or shot to play, etc.

    o When all players in the group have long putts and so will need to walk back and

    forth to the hole to attend the flagstick for one another (which sometimes produces

    uncertainty about who will or should attend for someone else).



     In match play, a player without a caddie will now be able to choose to putt with the

    unattended flagstick in the hole rather than ask the opponent to attend the flagstick,

    reducing the potential for dispute that can arise when the opponent attends for the

    player (such as when the opponent fails to remove the flagstick and the ball hits it).



     On balance it is expected that there should be no advantage in being able to putt with

    the unattended flagstick in the hole:

    o In some cases, the ball may strike the flagstick and bounce out of the hole when it

    might otherwise have been holed, and

    o In other cases, the ball may hit the flagstick and finish in the hole when it might

    otherwise have missed.



    [url="http://www.usga.org/content/dam/usga/images/rules/rules-modernization/golf-new-rules/Explanation for Each Major Change in the New Rules of Golf for 2019 (1"]http://www.usga.org/...olf for 2019 (1[/url]).pdf
    My point all along is that I feel it will speed up the pace of play a bit. I think also damage to the green will be lessened a bit by virtue of removal and placing it on to the green and returning it to the hole with the possibility of careless digging in the rim of the cup. I think it's a wise Rule and good for the game. You will always get questions about a new policy or revision when enacted, and many rebel by living off their own doubt of what if this, what if that, what if this, etc. At least give it it a chance to fail if it's going to fail, but I don't think it will. Now if they could just take away the distance penalty off an OB shot we'd be all set.
    Posted:
  • bladehunterbladehunter Today was a good day... south carolina 28958WRX Points: 5,447Members Posts: 28,958
    Joined:  edited Sep 3, 2018 #65
    pinhigh27 wrote:



    Please do give the physics lesson Mr wizard.





    Hit it 10 ft by dead center and it will hit the back and pop over or spit back out at you. If you hit it on the lip it will power off in the opposite direction. But there’s a chance of hitting it slightly off center and it staying in.



    Now add a flagstick there. It has almost zero shot at going in. If it hits the pin its coming out. Maybe won’t go by as far. But thats a poor lag putt strategy.



    I’m telling you that no good player who’s learned this game flag out is going to rewire his brain to putt flag in. Might as wel get used to putting your own pin back in. Because most arent going to do it for you.




    Not sure if you actually play golf. This is extremely simple




    Lol. And here I was waiting for the physics lesson. I expected a delay to google. But this is out of hand.
    Posted:
    Ping G410  11.2* Tensei pro OrangeV2 proto 70TX 
    Ping G410 15.5* Graphite Design ADDI 8x
    Ping G410 21* ADDI 105x 
    Ping Blueprint  3- PW   Modus 130X 
    Ping Glide Forged  54 60 s400
    Cameron GSS 1.5 009. Sound slot,  tungsten weights. 


  • hybrid25hybrid25 michigan 1587WRX Points: 176Members Posts: 1,587
    Joined:  #66
    pinhigh27 wrote:



    Please do give the physics lesson Mr wizard.





    Hit it 10 ft by dead center and it will hit the back and pop over or spit back out at you. If you hit it on the lip it will power off in the opposite direction. But there’s a chance of hitting it slightly off center and it staying in.



    Now add a flagstick there. It has almost zero shot at going in. If it hits the pin its coming out. Maybe won’t go by as far. But thats a poor lag putt strategy.



    I’m telling you that no good player who’s learned this game flag out is going to rewire his brain to putt flag in. Might as wel get used to putting your own pin back in. Because most arent going to do it for you.




    Not sure if you actually play golf. This is extremely simple
    it really is simple, and people make it more difficult than it really is. Golfers have the choice to leave it in or pull it out. You can play the game you've always played or you can choose to play a bit differently, but the choice is still yours.
    Posted:
  • bladehunterbladehunter Today was a good day... south carolina 28958WRX Points: 5,447Members Posts: 28,958
    Joined:  #67
    hybrid25 wrote:

    pinhigh27 wrote:



    Please do give the physics lesson Mr wizard.





    Hit it 10 ft by dead center and it will hit the back and pop over or spit back out at you. If you hit it on the lip it will power off in the opposite direction. But there’s a chance of hitting it slightly off center and it staying in.



    Now add a flagstick there. It has almost zero shot at going in. If it hits the pin its coming out. Maybe won’t go by as far. But thats a poor lag putt strategy.



    I’m telling you that no good player who’s learned this game flag out is going to rewire his brain to putt flag in. Might as wel get used to putting your own pin back in. Because most arent going to do it for you.




    Not sure if you actually play golf. This is extremely simple
    it really is simple, and people make it more difficult than it really is. Golfers have the choice to leave it in or pull it out. You can play the game you've always played or you can choose to play a bit differently, but the choice is still yours.




    And i get that. I do. I just know that there are plenty of rule benders who love this because it’s legalized laziness. Or a legalized backstop and then there’s my opinion ( yes opinion ) that it shouldn’t be in with any putt unless tended. I’m not going to change. Plenty will change. So chances are 75% of the rounds I play wil be split down the middle. And In and out the pin will go. No way that’s quicker.



    In a casual round of All 4 wanted to putt with the pin in they already can now. You can be your own committee and enact your own local rule anytime.



    Is it a huge deal ? No. Is it a waste of time new rule ? Yes. Will it cause more issues than it fixes ? Most likely



    Will we all live ? Sure ...i hope so.
    Posted:
    Ping G410  11.2* Tensei pro OrangeV2 proto 70TX 
    Ping G410 15.5* Graphite Design ADDI 8x
    Ping G410 21* ADDI 105x 
    Ping Blueprint  3- PW   Modus 130X 
    Ping Glide Forged  54 60 s400
    Cameron GSS 1.5 009. Sound slot,  tungsten weights. 


  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • sui generissui generis  4210WRX Points: 538Members Posts: 4,210
    Joined:  #68
    Londoner wrote:


    Definitely going to slow things, the flags going to be in and out like crazy in the wrong 4 ball.



    A couple of questions.



    If left, does the flag have to be free standing with no one touching it?



    On long putts, if you elect to have the flag tended, when do you have to elect it being removed or left?



    In the above, what if the person tending the flag leaves it in (or removes it) against your wishes?




    You'll have to wait for the Interpretations (formerly known as Decisions). The Interpretations are not available to everyone just yet.
    Posted:
    Knowledge of the Rules is part of the applied skill set which a player must use to play a round of competitive golf.
  • BB28403BB28403  3959WRX Points: 559Members Posts: 3,959
    Joined:  edited Sep 3, 2018 #69
    I like it in, speeds up the round. It’s all practice outside of a tourney anyhow.
    Posted:
  • Hawkeye77Hawkeye77 Iowa 19209WRX Points: 3,195ClubWRX Posts: 19,209
    Joined:  #70
    hybrid25 wrote:



    Explanation for Rule Change for 2019 - Ball Played from Green Hits Unattended Flagstick in Hole



    Current Rule: Under Rule 17-3, if a player makes a stroke on the putting green and the ball then

    hits the unattended flagstick that was left in the hole, the player gets the general penalty.



    2019 Rule: Under Rule 13.2a(2):



     There will no longer be a penalty if a ball played from the putting green hits a flagstick

    left in the hole.

     Players will not be required to putt with the flagstick in the hole; rather, they will

    continue to have the choice to have it removed (which includes having someone attend

    the flagstick and remove it after the ball is played).



    Reasons for Change:



     Allowing a player to putt with the flagstick in the hole without fear of penalty should

    generally help speed up play:



    o For example, if a putt is long enough that the player cannot easily see the hole

    unless the flagstick is left in, the player currently needs to wait for another person to

    attend the flagstick even if it is the player's turn to play or (in stroke play) if the

    player is ready to play and it would save time to go ahead and do so.

    o This change could also speed up play for short tap-ins, as the player could simply

    putt the ball into the hole without first removing and then replacing the flagstick.



     When the players do not have caddies, the current Rule can result in considerable delay, such as:



    o When the opponent (or the other player in stroke play) is raking a greenside bunker

    and will be delayed for a minute or two before coming on to the green.

    o When other players in stroke play are delayed in coming on to the green for other

    reasons, such as a ball search, indecision about what club to use or shot to play, etc.

    o When all players in the group have long putts and so will need to walk back and

    forth to the hole to attend the flagstick for one another (which sometimes produces

    uncertainty about who will or should attend for someone else).



     In match play, a player without a caddie will now be able to choose to putt with the

    unattended flagstick in the hole rather than ask the opponent to attend the flagstick,

    reducing the potential for dispute that can arise when the opponent attends for the

    player (such as when the opponent fails to remove the flagstick and the ball hits it).



     On balance it is expected that there should be no advantage in being able to putt with

    the unattended flagstick in the hole:

    o In some cases, the ball may strike the flagstick and bounce out of the hole when it

    might otherwise have been holed, and

    o In other cases, the ball may hit the flagstick and finish in the hole when it might

    otherwise have missed.



    http://www.usga.org/...olf for 2019 (1).pdf
    My point all along is that I feel it will speed up the pace of play a bit. I think also damage to the green will be lessened a bit by virtue of removal and placing it on to the green and returning it to the hole with the possibility of careless digging in the rim of the cup. I think it's a wise Rule and good for the game. You will always get questions about a new policy or revision when enacted, and many rebel by living off their own doubt of what if this, what if that, what if this, etc. At least give it it a chance to fail if it's going to fail, but I don't think it will. Now if they could just take away the distance penalty off an OB shot we'd be all set.




    LOL, the ridiculous OB rule they've come up with should be good enough!
    Posted:
  • Hawkeye77Hawkeye77 Iowa 19209WRX Points: 3,195ClubWRX Posts: 19,209
    Joined:  #71
    Have never, with or without caddies, seen any significant or frankly, noticeable, time wasted by anyone I've played with, followed, etc. because of the status of the flagstick being out or in. Slow play will be slow play, this is 99th on a priority list of 100 things you might do, and the first 99 will all be negated just because people that are unreasonably slow players aren't that way because of the rules. I would hazard a guess in 90% plus of the rounds played out there on a weekend across the country actual rules issues aren't slowing folks down - it's personalities and ignorance of basic etiquette and lack of skill, IMO.



    One or two people per foursome want the stick in, play is now slowed down covering those issues for each person vs. automatically out while putting (it can't be faster). Then we'll have the "scientists" out there wanting it in, then out, then in as they 3 putt across the green because they've read something about odds from various distances, etc.



    Only folks it would have made sense for is people playing alone, who now can't post scores anyway, and were never holding anyone up.
    Posted:
  • SNIPERBBBSNIPERBBB Hit Ball Hard SE Ohio 3010WRX Points: 723Members Posts: 3,010
    Joined:  #72
    Once the novelty runs wears out, things really wont change really outside of maybe the first guy getting on the green with a long putt leaving the pin in and the guy that just knocked a shot close will tap it in without having to fool with the flag.



    Cant see it leading to any real problems amongst most "normal" golfers.
    Posted:
    2016 M1 9.5 tuned to 7.5
    TM r15 3 wood
    Adams Idea Pro 2h/4h
    Mizuno JPX 900 HM 5-PW
    Vokey SM7 48* F Grind
    Vokey SM7 54* F Grind
    Vokey SM7 58* M Grind
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • sailfishchrissailfishchris Long Island NY 942WRX Points: 145Members, ClubWRX Posts: 942
    Joined:  #73
    You could just let the guys who want the pin in putt out first. Then remove the pin for the guys who want it out. Or vice versa- It won't speed things up but, it will give some guys more time too read the green.... aim point.....yoga.
    Posted:
    Ping G400 LST 8.5 Synergy Proto 65TX
    Ping G400 14.5 Tensei Pro Orange 80 TX
    Mizuno JPX 919 Tours 3-PW Super Peening Blue X
    Vokey SM6 raw 52, 56, 60 DGTI-s400
    Ping Redwood
    ProV1X / TPX5
    Jones Utility Trouper
  • bladehunterbladehunter Today was a good day... south carolina 28958WRX Points: 5,447Members Posts: 28,958
    Joined:  #74
    Hawkeye77 wrote:


    Have never, with or without caddies, seen any significant or frankly, noticeable, time wasted by anyone I've played with, followed, etc. because of the status of the flagstick being out or in. Slow play will be slow play, this is 99th on a priority list of 100 things you might do, and the first 99 will all be negated just because people that are unreasonably slow players aren't that way because of the rules. I would hazard a guess in 90% plus of the rounds played out there on a weekend across the country actual rules issues aren't slowing folks down - it's personalities and ignorance of basic etiquette and lack of skill, IMO.



    One or two people per foursome want the stick in, play is now slowed down covering those issues for each person vs. automatically out while putting (it can't be faster). Then we'll have the "scientists" out there wanting it in, then out, then in as they 3 putt across the green because they've read something about odds from various distances, etc.



    Only folks it would have made sense for is people playing alone, who now can't post scores anyway, and were never holding anyone up.






    holy crap.. I hadnt thought of that ..The irony ... it would be good for solos.. BUT The usga decided to call all of them/us liars and refuse those scores.yet still not require a markers signature for groups..(dumb as can be) .. Double irony is that i dont know a single sand bagger who plays alone.. They Travel in packs always.
    Posted:
    Ping G410  11.2* Tensei pro OrangeV2 proto 70TX 
    Ping G410 15.5* Graphite Design ADDI 8x
    Ping G410 21* ADDI 105x 
    Ping Blueprint  3- PW   Modus 130X 
    Ping Glide Forged  54 60 s400
    Cameron GSS 1.5 009. Sound slot,  tungsten weights. 


  • b.mattayb.mattay New WRX'er  571WRX Points: 106Members Posts: 571
    Joined:  #75
    pinhigh27 wrote:




    Would have definitely hit the back lip and kept going. Anything with enough speed to bounce off flag out of hole will not stay in a hole without a flag. I think literally only time a flag can hurt you is if it's crooked or you hit it on fly with approach.




    Patently false, especially on uphill or downhill chips/putts
    Posted:
    2017 M1 (8.25, Grafalloy Blue 65X, Z-Cord)

    M5 (13.5, Grafalloy Blue 75X, Z-Cord)

    Sonartec GS Tour (18, Fujikura 370X, Z-Cord)

    712 CB (4-P, X100, Z-Cord, 1 Degree Flat)

    SM6 (51.13F, 55.15F, 60.12V, S400, Z-Cord, 1 Degree Flat)

    Spider Tour Black (35 inches, Garsen Ultimate Grip)
  • ThinkingPlusThinkingPlus South Texas 2022WRX Points: 911ClubWRX Posts: 2,022
    Joined:  #76
    The pin is out if the ball is on the green. I would like to think I will never hit a putt poorly enough where the pin helps more than hurts. If playing by myself, the RoGs are irrelevant anyway.
    Posted:
    Driver: Callaway GBB Epic 9° w/Project X HZRDUS T800 65 gm 6.0 flex
    3W: Callaway Rogue w/Project X Evenflow 5.5 Graphite R-flex
    Hybrids: Callaway Apex 3h, 4h w/MR Kuro Kage 80HY S-flex
    Irons: Maltby TS-1 5i-GW w/KBS Tour R-flex
    Sand Wedge: Titleist Vokey SM7 54/08 M Grind w/KBS Tour R-Flex
    Lob Wedge: Titleist Vokey SM6 58/04 L Grind w/TT Wedge Flex
    Putter: Scotty Cameron Futura X w/Super Stroke Claw 1.0
    Ball: Titleist AVX (wind) or ProV1X (tournaments) in yellow
  • McgeenoMcgeeno  2148WRX Points: 279Members Posts: 2,148
    Joined:  #77


    The pin is out if the ball is on the green. I would like to think I will never hit a putt poorly enough where the pin helps more than hurts. If playing by myself, the RoGs are irrelevant anyway.




    Pelz has done robotic tests showing the flag helps on almost every pace or angle from different distances.
    Posted:
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • pinhigh27pinhigh27  9794WRX Points: 309Members Posts: 9,794
    Joined:  #78
    b.mattay wrote:

    pinhigh27 wrote:


    Would have definitely hit the back lip and kept going. Anything with enough speed to bounce off flag out of hole will not stay in a hole without a flag. I think literally only time a flag can hurt you is if it's crooked or you hit it on fly with approach.




    Patently false, especially on uphill or downhill chips/putts




    not what testing shows but ok . you guys keep clinging to your 1 in a million where the ball hits the cup off-center and somehow goes in, when it would have normally rolled 10 feet by.
    Posted:
  • hybrid25hybrid25 michigan 1587WRX Points: 176Members Posts: 1,587
    Joined:  #79
    what if, what if?
    Posted:
  • bladehunterbladehunter Today was a good day... south carolina 28958WRX Points: 5,447Members Posts: 28,958
    Joined:  #80
    so let me pose this question..



    How many "pin in" fans here also cry out against pros seen on TV leaving balls by the hole for others to use as backstops ? How can you be a fan of one and not the other ? I say that using your opinion that the flag will help more than it hurts.
    Posted:
    Ping G410  11.2* Tensei pro OrangeV2 proto 70TX 
    Ping G410 15.5* Graphite Design ADDI 8x
    Ping G410 21* ADDI 105x 
    Ping Blueprint  3- PW   Modus 130X 
    Ping Glide Forged  54 60 s400
    Cameron GSS 1.5 009. Sound slot,  tungsten weights. 


  • bladehunterbladehunter Today was a good day... south carolina 28958WRX Points: 5,447Members Posts: 28,958
    Joined:  #81
    hybrid25 wrote:


    what if, what if?




    the examination of the hypothetical is how good rules and decisions are made.
    Posted:
    Ping G410  11.2* Tensei pro OrangeV2 proto 70TX 
    Ping G410 15.5* Graphite Design ADDI 8x
    Ping G410 21* ADDI 105x 
    Ping Blueprint  3- PW   Modus 130X 
    Ping Glide Forged  54 60 s400
    Cameron GSS 1.5 009. Sound slot,  tungsten weights. 


  • ThinkingPlusThinkingPlus South Texas 2022WRX Points: 911ClubWRX Posts: 2,022
    Joined:  #82
    Mcgeeno wrote:



    The pin is out if the ball is on the green. I would like to think I will never hit a putt poorly enough where the pin helps more than hurts. If playing by myself, the RoGs are irrelevant anyway.




    Pelz has done robotic tests showing the flag helps on almost every pace or angle from different distances.


    I have not read Pelz work. I have heard him discuss caveats. One is that the pin cannot be leaning which occurs more often than one would like. Also different diameter pins impact the results. I am not sure what he used or if he tested against all sizes available. Knowing the details in exactly how the tests were performed and how the data was analyzed is very important to understanding and applying the conclusions.
    Posted:
    Driver: Callaway GBB Epic 9° w/Project X HZRDUS T800 65 gm 6.0 flex
    3W: Callaway Rogue w/Project X Evenflow 5.5 Graphite R-flex
    Hybrids: Callaway Apex 3h, 4h w/MR Kuro Kage 80HY S-flex
    Irons: Maltby TS-1 5i-GW w/KBS Tour R-flex
    Sand Wedge: Titleist Vokey SM7 54/08 M Grind w/KBS Tour R-Flex
    Lob Wedge: Titleist Vokey SM6 58/04 L Grind w/TT Wedge Flex
    Putter: Scotty Cameron Futura X w/Super Stroke Claw 1.0
    Ball: Titleist AVX (wind) or ProV1X (tournaments) in yellow
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • pinhigh27pinhigh27  9794WRX Points: 309Members Posts: 9,794
    Joined:  #83


    so let me pose this question..



    How many "pin in" fans here also cry out against pros seen on TV leaving balls by the hole for others to use as backstops ? How can you be a fan of one and not the other ? I say that using your opinion that the flag will help more than it hurts.




    Not sure how one person going out of their way to help their competitor is similar to using the rules to your advantage. Golf is a game of intent. If you purposefully don't mark your ball to help your playing partner, that is wrong IMO. If the rules say you can keep the flag in, then you can keep the flag in.
    Posted:
  • Hawkeye77Hawkeye77 Iowa 19209WRX Points: 3,195ClubWRX Posts: 19,209
    Joined:  #84
    pinhigh27 wrote:



    so let me pose this question..



    How many "pin in" fans here also cry out against pros seen on TV leaving balls by the hole for others to use as backstops ? How can you be a fan of one and not the other ? I say that using your opinion that the flag will help more than it hurts.




    Not sure how one person going out of their way to help their competitor is similar to using the rules to your advantage. Golf is a game of intent. If you purposefully don't mark your ball to help your playing partner, that is wrong IMO. If the rules say you can keep the flag in, then you can keep the flag in.




    In fairness, I don't think he's talking about rules in a literal way so much as the idea that if the pin is demonstrated to be an aid in play, it is taking some measure of skill out of the game, and getting artificial, if not intentional assistance, with the help of an unnecessary rules change?



    But, that's just my take.
    Posted:
  • bladehunterbladehunter Today was a good day... south carolina 28958WRX Points: 5,447Members Posts: 28,958
    Joined:  #85
    pinhigh27 wrote:



    so let me pose this question..



    How many "pin in" fans here also cry out against pros seen on TV leaving balls by the hole for others to use as backstops ? How can you be a fan of one and not the other ? I say that using your opinion that the flag will help more than it hurts.




    Not sure how one person going out of their way to help their competitor is similar to using the rules to your advantage. Golf is a game of intent. If you purposefully don't mark your ball to help your playing partner, that is wrong IMO. If the rules say you can keep the flag in, then you can keep the flag in.




    So if the rule changed to allow purposeful backstopping it would be ok ?
    Posted:
    Ping G410  11.2* Tensei pro OrangeV2 proto 70TX 
    Ping G410 15.5* Graphite Design ADDI 8x
    Ping G410 21* ADDI 105x 
    Ping Blueprint  3- PW   Modus 130X 
    Ping Glide Forged  54 60 s400
    Cameron GSS 1.5 009. Sound slot,  tungsten weights. 


  • b.mattayb.mattay New WRX'er  571WRX Points: 106Members Posts: 571
    Joined:  edited Sep 4, 2018 #86
    pinhigh27 wrote:

    b.mattay wrote:

    pinhigh27 wrote:


    Would have definitely hit the back lip and kept going. Anything with enough speed to bounce off flag out of hole will not stay in a hole without a flag. I think literally only time a flag can hurt you is if it's crooked or you hit it on fly with approach.




    Patently false, especially on uphill or downhill chips/putts




    not what testing shows but ok . you guys keep clinging to your 1 in a million where the ball hits the cup off-center and somehow goes in, when it would have normally rolled 10 feet by.




    Depends highly on flagstick thickness and how well hole is cut relative to slope.
    Posted:
    2017 M1 (8.25, Grafalloy Blue 65X, Z-Cord)

    M5 (13.5, Grafalloy Blue 75X, Z-Cord)

    Sonartec GS Tour (18, Fujikura 370X, Z-Cord)

    712 CB (4-P, X100, Z-Cord, 1 Degree Flat)

    SM6 (51.13F, 55.15F, 60.12V, S400, Z-Cord, 1 Degree Flat)

    Spider Tour Black (35 inches, Garsen Ultimate Grip)
  • sticknerstickner  378WRX Points: 2Members Posts: 378
    Joined:  edited Sep 4, 2018 #87

    Hawkeye77 wrote:


    Have never, with or without caddies, seen any significant or frankly, noticeable, time wasted by anyone I've played with, followed, etc. because of the status of the flagstick being out or in. Slow play will be slow play, this is 99th on a priority list of 100 things you might do, and the first 99 will all be negated just because people that are unreasonably slow players aren't that way because of the rules. I would hazard a guess in 90% plus of the rounds played out there on a weekend across the country actual rules issues aren't slowing folks down - it's personalities and ignorance of basic etiquette and lack of skill, IMO.



    One or two people per foursome want the stick in, play is now slowed down covering those issues for each person vs. automatically out while putting (it can't be faster). Then we'll have the "scientists" out there wanting it in, then out, then in as they 3 putt across the green because they've read something about odds from various distances, etc.



    Only folks it would have made sense for is people playing alone, who now can't post scores anyway, and were never holding anyone up.






    holy crap.. I hadnt thought of that ..The irony ... it would be good for solos.. BUT The usga decided to call all of them/us liars and refuse those scores.yet still not require a markers signature for groups..(dumb as can be) .. Double irony is that i dont know a single sand bagger who plays alone.. They Travel in packs always.




    I never understood not being able to post your score if you play as a single.


    Rule 1 states:

    "You are responsible for applying your own penalties if you breach a Rule, so that you cannot gain any potential advantage over your opponent..."




    The USGA expects you to play with integrity and by the rules, including calling penalties on yourself (even if nobody else sees the infraction).



    Why can't those standards be applied to someone playing solo?
    Posted:
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • bladehunterbladehunter Today was a good day... south carolina 28958WRX Points: 5,447Members Posts: 28,958
    Joined:  #88
    stickner wrote:


    Hawkeye77 wrote:


    Have never, with or without caddies, seen any significant or frankly, noticeable, time wasted by anyone I've played with, followed, etc. because of the status of the flagstick being out or in. Slow play will be slow play, this is 99th on a priority list of 100 things you might do, and the first 99 will all be negated just because people that are unreasonably slow players aren't that way because of the rules. I would hazard a guess in 90% plus of the rounds played out there on a weekend across the country actual rules issues aren't slowing folks down - it's personalities and ignorance of basic etiquette and lack of skill, IMO.



    One or two people per foursome want the stick in, play is now slowed down covering those issues for each person vs. automatically out while putting (it can't be faster). Then we'll have the "scientists" out there wanting it in, then out, then in as they 3 putt across the green because they've read something about odds from various distances, etc.



    Only folks it would have made sense for is people playing alone, who now can't post scores anyway, and were never holding anyone up.






    holy crap.. I hadnt thought of that ..The irony ... it would be good for solos.. BUT The usga decided to call all of them/us liars and refuse those scores.yet still not require a markers signature for groups..(dumb as can be) .. Double irony is that i dont know a single sand bagger who plays alone.. They Travel in packs always.




    I never understood not being able to post your score if you play as a single.


    Rule 1 states:

    "You are responsible for applying your own penalties if you breach a Rule, so that you cannot gain any potential advantage over your opponent..."




    The USGA expects you to play with integrity and by the rules, including calling penalties on yourself (even if nobody else sees the infraction).



    Why can't those standards be applied to someone playing solo?




    Absolutely agree. And on the other hand I’m ok with not allowing single scores to post IF they required everyone else to post through the club handicap committee or with signature of a marker. And let’s say can’t use the same marker for consecutive rounds.

    Instead they leave it as the Wild West and somehow claim to have done something by stopping singles. WHich by the way there’s no way to police either. A true cheater can sit on his couch and enter 18 scores in 30 min and create any cap he wants. Yet somehow singles were an issue. Smh.
    Posted:
    Ping G410  11.2* Tensei pro OrangeV2 proto 70TX 
    Ping G410 15.5* Graphite Design ADDI 8x
    Ping G410 21* ADDI 105x 
    Ping Blueprint  3- PW   Modus 130X 
    Ping Glide Forged  54 60 s400
    Cameron GSS 1.5 009. Sound slot,  tungsten weights. 


  • sui generissui generis  4210WRX Points: 538Members Posts: 4,210
    Joined:  #89
    stickner wrote:


    Hawkeye77 wrote:


    Have never, with or without caddies, seen any significant or frankly, noticeable, time wasted by anyone I've played with, followed, etc. because of the status of the flagstick being out or in. Slow play will be slow play, this is 99th on a priority list of 100 things you might do, and the first 99 will all be negated just because people that are unreasonably slow players aren't that way because of the rules. I would hazard a guess in 90% plus of the rounds played out there on a weekend across the country actual rules issues aren't slowing folks down - it's personalities and ignorance of basic etiquette and lack of skill, IMO.



    One or two people per foursome want the stick in, play is now slowed down covering those issues for each person vs. automatically out while putting (it can't be faster). Then we'll have the "scientists" out there wanting it in, then out, then in as they 3 putt across the green because they've read something about odds from various distances, etc.



    Only folks it would have made sense for is people playing alone, who now can't post scores anyway, and were never holding anyone up.






    holy crap.. I hadnt thought of that ..The irony ... it would be good for solos.. BUT The usga decided to call all of them/us liars and refuse those scores.yet still not require a markers signature for groups..(dumb as can be) .. Double irony is that i dont know a single sand bagger who plays alone.. They Travel in packs always.




    I never understood not being able to post your score if you play as a single.


    Rule 1 states:

    "You are responsible for applying your own penalties if you breach a Rule, so that you cannot gain any potential advantage over your opponent..."




    The USGA expects you to play with integrity and by the rules, including calling penalties on yourself (even if nobody else sees the infraction).



    Why can't those standards be applied to someone playing solo?




    This thread is about 2019 Rule 13.2.
    Posted:
    Knowledge of the Rules is part of the applied skill set which a player must use to play a round of competitive golf.
  • SirFuegoSirFuego  246WRX Points: 99Members Posts: 246
    Joined:  edited Sep 4, 2018 #90
    PingEye2 wrote:


    I told my son to do what Bryson does since he will probably have all the stats worked out!




    I'm being 100% serious when I say that this is probably the best suggestion in the thread so far. Fact of the matter is that without hard data, it's impossible to know when it is statistically optimal to pull the flag vs leave it in. Anything else is just speculation formed by anecdotal evidence. The experiments Pelz did years ago are about as close as we have come. There are of course some limitations to that work (pin width and at what point does a leaning flag become detrimental), but it's obviously something someone can re-create with enough time or money to pay someone to do it. I'm sure Bryson would be willing to throw a few grand at someone to at least capture the data. I could even see some college professors conducting these experiments to get their names out to the masses.



    I'd imagine the USGA conducted similar studies when they decided to change the rules.



    Another speculative variable in this whole ordeal is does the flag being in the hole impact one's ability to actually aim at the hole? Or is the flag itself a distraction to throw off one's aim?



    Bottom line is that unless there are "definitive" studies done on it, it's all speculation and it'll be a heavily debated topic where the most out-spoken have their own opinion and most people will just say to do whatever works for you as long as it doesn't slow down play.
    Posted:
  • GolfWRXGolfWRX Warning Points: 0  11 Members Posts: 11 #ad
    Joined:  ...

    Advertisement
  • 27x10.527x10.5  989WRX Points: 138Members Posts: 989
    Joined:  #91
    I hate that I'm going to have to ask the question so many more times per round
    Posted:
15

Leave a Comment

Rich Text Editor. To edit a paragraph's style, hit tab to get to the paragraph menu. From there you will be able to pick one style. Nothing defaults to paragraph. An inline formatting menu will show up when you select text. Hit tab to get into that menu. Some elements, such as rich link embeds, images, loading indicators, and error messages may get inserted into the editor. You may navigate to these using the arrow keys inside of the editor and delete them with the delete or backspace key.