Bourbon

[ScurvyDog]

New here and thought I would revive this thread. I am a serious bourbon snob. I have about 30 bottles horded in my closet. Yes I have some Pappy bottles hidden.

To answer the above question, Evan Williams single barrel vintage is probably my favorite. It does vary from year to year and 2014 bottling is a little sweeter than prior years. I have had better bourbons but not for $26!!! The 2011 bottling was the best ever!
Maybe it is a mental thing but I have more enjoyment from drinking a bottle that I paid less than $30.

90% of the time I drink it neat. The other %10 is split between Old Fashions and Manhattans.
I am all about value bourbons. There are some great bottles out there for less than $25.

[itchyfinger]

I'm in love with Makers 46 & Angel's Envy.

[highdraw69]

I did a blind whiskey tasting this weekend with a friend; there were 9 American whiskey/bourbons, 1 scotch and 1 irish...we both rated angel's envy rye #1 in our blind test, which was astounding (we did NOT include any of my pappy in the test)

[ScurvyDog]

I have had Angels envy Rye and it is more like rye flavored rum. Is it good? Hell Yeah, but its not traditional bourbon and it was overpriced. I really like Rittenhouse rye botted in bond 100 proof (not bourbon either), great for Manhattans.

[scratchswinger]

So you guys like Bourbon over Scotch?

[FAbb]

[quote name='scratchswinger' timestamp='1403400828' post='9548681']So you guys like Bourbon over Scotch?[/quote]

I've only had a couple scotches, but they are decent ones from what I understand (macallan 12 and 18, and another I can't remember the name of). I just can't get into it. The aftertaste borderline makes me gag. I love bourbon though!

[highdraw69]

[quote name='scratchswinger' timestamp='1403400828' post='9548681']
So you guys like Bourbon over Scotch?
[/quote]

definitely prefer American whiskey/bourbon over scotch (and I detest most irish whisky)

[pappaf2]

[quote name='scratchswinger' timestamp='1403400828' post='9548681']
So you guys like Bourbon over Scotch?
[/quote]

I do...

[pappaf2]

[quote name='ScurvyDog' timestamp='1403112714' post='9525189']
New here and thought I would revive this thread. I am a serious bourbon snob. I have about 30 bottles horded in my closet. Yes I have some Pappy bottles hidden.

[b]To answer the above question, Evan Williams single barrel vintage is probably my favorite. [/b] It does vary from year to year and 2014 bottling is a little sweeter than prior years. I have had better bourbons but not for $26!!! The 2011 bottling was the best ever!
Maybe it is a mental thing but I have more enjoyment from drinking a bottle that I paid less than $30.

90% of the time I drink it neat. The other %10 is split between Old Fashions and Manhattans.
I am all about value bourbons. There are some great bottles out there for less than $25.
[/quote]

Thanks for the review, I'll try picking up a bottle next time.

[scratchswinger]

If you guys haven't already, you should try Hibiki 12. Delicious stuff...

[ScurvyDog]

[quote name='scratchswinger' timestamp='1403575449' post='9562921']
If you guys haven't already, you should try Hibiki 12. Delicious stuff...
[/quote]

I have heard of it but have not seen it at any stores here in N. Florida.

[johnnybogey]

[quote name='scratchswinger' timestamp='1403575449' post='9562921']If you guys haven't already, you should try Hibiki 12. Delicious stuff...[/quote]

Haven't tried the hibiki yet. Had the pleasure of trying yamazaki 12. Enjoyed it. Very smooth.

As for bourbon, recently picked up a bottle of woodford reserve. Really good. Want to try blantons next.

[bscinstnct]

Got some Hudson Baby Bourbon.

Think it's the 1st *legally* made bourbon in NY since prohibition.

It is petty good.

[johnnybogey]

Had a chance to pick up a bottle of Blanton's. Haven't tried it yet, will be this weekend with the in-laws.

Spoke to the guy at the local liquor store, they typically get the Pappy stock sometime in November. Asked him to put me on the mailing list to be notified. So we'll see.

Cheers!

[mflores]

Picked up some E Craig Barrel Proof - 4th release I believe - very tasty - needs a cube or a drop of water since it's got a high proof. Lots of sweet goodness with a bite.

[Myherobobhope]

I'm sad to see this thread so far down!

I picked up Rough Rider double oaked bourbon and really enjoyed it.

I've been making lots of manhattans with Rittenhouse Rye and Dolin vermouth (and a variety of bitters).

Sadly, I've been drinking more bourbon and playing less golf... very little time and too much stress recently.

[blaird]

[quote name='johnnybogey' timestamp='1403669519' post='9571893']
[quote name='scratchswinger' timestamp='1403575449' post='9562921']If you guys haven't already, you should try Hibiki 12. Delicious stuff...[/quote]

Haven't tried the hibiki yet. Had the pleasure of trying yamazaki 12. Enjoyed it. Very smooth.

As for bourbon, recently picked up a bottle of woodford reserve. Really good. Want to try blantons next.
[/quote]

I tried the woodford reserve on the way back from a golf trip a few months ago and fell in love with it. Very good and smooth!!

[bppry]

[quote name='Myherobobhope' timestamp='1407853962' post='9916609']
I'm sad to see this thread so far down!

I picked up Rough Rider double oaked bourbon and really enjoyed it.

I've been making lots of manhattans with Rittenhouse Rye and Dolin vermouth (and a variety of bitters).

Sadly, I've been drinking more bourbon and playing less golf... very little time and too much stress recently.
[/quote]
That last line rings true here as well. I wish I was trying some bourbons for the first time but my state only has been allowing very over priced bottles into the market. I have a coworker on his way to Nashville and he said he will bring back a few bottles. I recall enjoying Larceny when in South Carolina, so that's one. Any other ideas would be great. I look for value in the dollar. Ancient ancient age 10 year may be another if it's easily found.

[Myherobobhope]

[quote name='bppry' timestamp='1407892971' post='9921201']
[quote name='Myherobobhope' timestamp='1407853962' post='9916609']
I'm sad to see this thread so far down!

I picked up Rough Rider double oaked bourbon and really enjoyed it.

I've been making lots of manhattans with Rittenhouse Rye and Dolin vermouth (and a variety of bitters).

Sadly, I've been drinking more bourbon and playing less golf... very little time and too much stress recently.
[/quote]
That last line rings true here as well. I wish I was trying some bourbons for the first time but my state only has been allowing very over priced bottles into the market. I have a coworker on his way to Nashville and he said he will bring back a few bottles. I recall enjoying Larceny when in South Carolina, so that's one. Any other ideas would be great. I look for value in the dollar. Ancient ancient age 10 year may be another if it's easily found.
[/quote]

Ancient Ancient Age 10 is gone forever, sadly... amazing value bourbon. I just finished my last bottle.

What state do you live in? There are always SOME options, though they might be overpriced.

[bppry]

That is unfortunate. I am in Michigan. State controls pricing and even what can be sold. Quite sad.

[teckneeklyperfect]

Always have a bottle of Pendleton around…. for me

[Myherobobhope]

[quote name='ScurvyDog' timestamp='1403112714' post='9525189']
New here and thought I would revive this thread. I am a serious bourbon snob. I have about 30 bottles horded in my closet. Yes I have some Pappy bottles hidden.

To answer the above question, Evan Williams single barrel vintage is probably my favorite. It does vary from year to year and 2014 bottling is a little sweeter than prior years. I have had better bourbons but not for $26!!! The 2011 bottling was the best ever!
Maybe it is a mental thing but I have more enjoyment from drinking a bottle that I paid less than $30.

90% of the time I drink it neat. The other %10 is split between Old Fashions and Manhattans.
I am all about value bourbons. There are some great bottles out there for less than $25.
[/quote]

Evan Williams Single Barrel is definitely a good pour. I need to buy it again.

My cabinet always has the following:
Old Forester Signature - 1.75L. It's $35 in KY, and my go to mixer bourbon. I can and will drink it neat or on the rocks, but usually I make something with it. Bourbon and Ginger Ale or Manhattan are my go to options
Four Roses Single Barrel 750mL - Any time I see a bottle for under $27 I buy it. I only drink it on the rocks (or neat on occasion),
Rittenhouse Rye: 750 mL - I forgot what I usually pay... I want to say $23? This is just for mixing, I don't love ryes straight up.

I'm currently awaiting the release of Old Forester Birthday Bourbon, which comes out the beginning of September. If you want a "rare" bottle, spend the money on this one. It's a great pour and it's easy to find.

[itw419]

I'm heading to Kentucky in October. What bottles would you guys recommend that I can't get here in Michigan. I'm going to be in the Louisville area.

[Myherobobhope]

[quote name='itw419' timestamp='1408576233' post='9975899']
I'm heading to Kentucky in October. What bottles would you guys recommend that I can't get here in Michigan. I'm going to be in the Louisville area.
[/quote]

Where in Louisville are you going to be? I can recommend a store.

Elmer T Lee is a good buy.
Weller is good
Pick up a hand picked bottle of Four Roses

[pappaf2]

For some reason I haven't been drinking bourbon as much in the summer time. I did just pick up a bottle of Elijah Craig 12 so I'll report back after I put it through its paces.

[knock it close]

I know its not a pure bourbon but anyone have some thoughts on the High west campfire whiskey? Looking for a solid bottle of something to break in the new apartment and school year.

[itw419]

[quote name='Myherobobhope' timestamp='1408733156' post='9988585']
[quote name='itw419' timestamp='1408576233' post='9975899']
I'm heading to Kentucky in October. What bottles would you guys recommend that I can't get here in Michigan. I'm going to be in the Louisville area.
[/quote]

Where in Louisville are you going to be? I can recommend a store.

Elmer T Lee is a good buy.
Weller is good
Pick up a hand picked bottle of Four Roses
[/quote]

I'm going to be downtown near The baseball stadium. I have a bottle of Elmer right now. We get that in michigan. Weller has always interested me so I might pick that up. What's the deal with the hand picked four roses?

[MtlJeff]

i'm currently rocking a Blanton's , Jack's single barrel and Buffalo Trace

but i've been drinking scotch too

[johnnybogey]

[quote name='MtlJeff' timestamp='1409021982' post='10008295']i'm currently rocking a Blanton's , Jack's single barrel and Buffalo Trace

but i've been drinking scotch too[/quote]

How is the Blantons? Have a bottle sitting at home. Going to finish the Evan Williams single barrel and woodford reserve first.

Dads 70th bday coming up. Going to treat him to a bottle of johnnie walker blue. Looking forward to it.

[pappaf2]

Anybody on here going to give this a run??? Holy moly! 138.1 proof!