Best Driver of 2019 | Full Article _HERE_ | Discussion Thread _HERE_

Blades and the search for "game improvement"

1235710

Comments

  • NRJyzrNRJyzr Allez Allez Allez Minnesota, USAMembers Posts: 6,605 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    edited Sep 17, 2018 #122

    BiggErn wrote:

    BiggErn wrote:


    It’s all relative. Unless you hit the pea size sweet spot of a blade like 99.9% of the time there’s absolutely no benefit in playing them. I guess there’s an argument that “I” shoot 95 more consistently with blades and around 100 with a cavity back so they just work for me kinda thing going on too that fuels the debate somehow.
    lol i don't think there is anyone on here saying they shoot 95 with blades compared to 100 with cavity backs man. there really isn't an argument here... your results differ fro mine, and my results differ from the next guy. I have been golfing for over 25 years and i am playing my first set of blades. Recently i have found that i am struggling with them as i have not been able to commit to practicing. i know that in order to commit to playing blades i have to practice a couple times a week or more in between playing. i may be one of the guys that are a "one and done" with trying blades. I can say that as a 7.6 i am as low as i have been in years... now there is an argument that i could be better with CB's but the unknown is by how much or if any at all. I will never know, just like if i go to CB's tomorrow and if i get to say a 5, that i wouldn't have gotten there without them. Who knows. All i know is that there should be a buyer beware tag on the better players irons regardless of CB or MB. They are not for everyone thats for sure. I can appreciate the opinions of everyone on the site, as long as everyone understands that they are just that... opinions. The only thing i can say for a fact is how all of this applies to me, beyond that its just my opinion.






    When someone wants something they will use any means and excuse necessary to attempt to justify it. Rationality doesn’t apply to everyone. The fact is if you don’t hit the ball like previously stated there is ZERO benefit in playing them. You can say that you can’t stand to look at a certain club or some turf interaction nonsense or whatever and that’s fine. I guess it’s acceptable some have mental issues, ego issues, and/or denial issues and that’s ok. It’s just a game. Some are good, some are great, some are terrible, and some are in between. When it comes to Golf ignorance is abound.




    thats a heap of absolutes in a mostly grey game my friend... If we use those logics as laws then no player over a 0-2 cap should play any putter that resembles an Anser etc ..But many many do and they do it ridicule free. Point is the handicap test doesnt really work ...



    I wish i had taken pics of these..But i once owned a set of mizuno MP33 that i bought sight unseen .. The toe of these irons was worn to nothing..a tight quarter size spot on each toe ...Now this person had a very repeatable strike , obviously ...but played this toe miss...was it swing or lie angle issues ? i dont know...But im guessing he/she knew how far each iron went on pure toe strikes ( lol) and how far if they missed. Thats all it boils down to...knowing your game and playing the right club for the shot at hand . with some sets it will have a 7 on the sole..with some a 9... thats all.






    From my perspective, what you termed "absolutes" in ernie's post above aren't even valid. I've done a fair bit of side by side testing; since ernie wants to wallow in the anecdotal, let's add to it. image/smile.png' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':)' />



    The best example.... Maxfli A10 6 iron, Rifle 6.5 shaft, 37.5" long, 30°. Hit way out on the toe on a 180 yd par 3. Ball comes up short of green. Next up, Ram Tour Grind 5 iron, Rifle 6.5 shaft, 37.5" long, 30°. Hit way out on the toe on the same 180 yd par 3, right after the A10 shot. Ball comes up short of green. Get up to the golfballs on the fringe, you could throw a blanket over them. They were within a foot of each other in terms of distance. Amusingly, the Ram was actually the longer shot.



    Forgiveness levels.... the MOI of the A10 is 2520. The MOI of the Ram Tour Grind is 1972. Same strike, but the higher MOI produced no result improvement. Which is in line with Britt Lindsey's comments about the MOI differences in irons not being significant.



    It's just one example of what I've seen, doing tests over the years. It's anecdotal as ****. But it's real world results, not theories spun from bias.



    Side note: it's harder than it might seem to intentionally hit a ball that far on the toe. LOL
    The Ever Changing Bag!

    Driver: Adams Fast 12 LS 9.5* set to 10.5*, Xcaliber T6+, TS, 44.25", D6
    3w:  Bridgestone J's Professional Weapon 14*, stock stiff, 42.5", D5
    1i:  Golden Ram Vibration Matched, DGS400
    3-PW:  Mizuno MP-37, DGS300
    GW:  Mizuno Pro 52*, DGS300
    SW:  Scratch 8620 58*, DGS400
    Putter: Cleveland Huntington Beach #1 35"
    Balls: in no particular order... Wilson Staff FG Tour, Duo Urethane/Professional, or 50 Elite, Srixon ZStar/ZStar XV, Snell MTB Black... will trot out Maxfli HT-100 or Elite 90 from time to time

    I've proven once again that anything over 44.5" or even 44.25" is a horrible fit for my tee game
  • cliffhangercliffhanger spruce grove albertaClubWRX Posts: 1,761 ClubWRX
    BiggErn wrote:

    BiggErn wrote:


    It’s all relative. Unless you hit the pea size sweet spot of a blade like 99.9% of the time there’s absolutely no benefit in playing them. I guess there’s an argument that “I” shoot 95 more consistently with blades and around 100 with a cavity back so they just work for me kinda thing going on too that fuels the debate somehow.
    lol i don't think there is anyone on here saying they shoot 95 with blades compared to 100 with cavity backs man. there really isn't an argument here... your results differ fro mine, and my results differ from the next guy. I have been golfing for over 25 years and i am playing my first set of blades. Recently i have found that i am struggling with them as i have not been able to commit to practicing. i know that in order to commit to playing blades i have to practice a couple times a week or more in between playing. i may be one of the guys that are a "one and done" with trying blades. I can say that as a 7.6 i am as low as i have been in years... now there is an argument that i could be better with CB's but the unknown is by how much or if any at all. I will never know, just like if i go to CB's tomorrow and if i get to say a 5, that i wouldn't have gotten there without them. Who knows. All i know is that there should be a buyer beware tag on the better players irons regardless of CB or MB. They are not for everyone thats for sure. I can appreciate the opinions of everyone on the site, as long as everyone understands that they are just that... opinions. The only thing i can say for a fact is how all of this applies to me, beyond that its just my opinion.






    When someone wants something they will use any means and excuse necessary to attempt to justify it. Rationality doesn’t apply to everyone. The fact is if you don’t hit the ball like previously stated there is ZERO benefit in playing them. You can say that you can’t stand to look at a certain club or some turf interaction nonsense or whatever and that’s fine. I guess it’s acceptable some have mental issues, ego issues, and/or denial issues and that’s ok. It’s just a game. Some are good, some are great, some are terrible, and some are in between. When it comes to Golf ignorance is abound.
    what i said was that when i do not commit to practicing multiple times per week i have been struggling. In an earlier post i stated that my GIR % has suffered as a result. At no time have i said i play blades because of the look or because of turf interaction. In fact i can't recall saying anything other than because i wanted to try them and to be honest i don't need to justify that anymore than you need to justify your last iron purchase (i notice like a lot of people who argue in these threads you do not post your equip or index... interesting). I have not even committed to play them beyond this year. Truth be told my posts have actually been me trying to talk myself into CB's for next year because i am not sure if i can commit to practicing the amount i need to continue playing the MBs. What's interesting in the whole MB vs CB debate is how people continue to try and push their opinions on others like it is a fact. I am simply stating that my results are my results and that everyone's results will vary. One player might be a 3-4 stroke per round difference and another player might be 12-15... who knows right. I also believe that someone doesn't have to be suffering from mental issues, ego issues or be in denial to play a golf club that contradicts your decision (or my decision as well). The biggest part of this thread is the tendency to try and insult others to get a point across like it validates the facts (i mean the opinion)... is that really necessary? i applaud those who feel that a larger club will make the game easier for them if that is what brings them happiness, i also applaud those who try to play a smaller club for whatever crazy reason they have as long as it brings them happiness. And what brings me happiness is simply playing the game regardless of score. I don't expect you to understand that because it is a personal thing for me. I get to play with my son who also loves the game... i haven't beat him in over two years and i don't care lol.


    Driver: TM M6 (10.5 deg) with Project X Smoke 60X playing at 45 inches
    3Wood: TM M6 (14 deg) with Project X Smoke 70X playing at 43 inches
    2 iron: TM 790 UDI bent to 19 degrees with Project X HZRDUS 85 X (6.5) at 39.5 inches
    4-GW: TM P760 with KBS Tour X (all bent 2 deg flat) standard length
    Wedges: TM Hi-Toe 56/10 and 60/10 (all bent 2 deg flat) with 2.0 hi-rev shafts both standard lengths
    TM Mullen 2 TP putter @ 34 inches 
    TM TP 5 ball 

     All grips 360 tour velvet burgundy with 1 extra wrap

    Sun mountain 4.5 stand bag

  • PorscheFanPorscheFan Members Posts: 1,278 ✭✭✭✭✭✭
    duffer987 wrote:

    PorscheFan wrote:


    I can only assume that this is a very individual topic, and people get relatively individual results.



    Personally I'm an average golfer and I play blades. The only time I haven't been happy with them is when I'm not playing well in general, or when I start to believe there are clubs out there that I would get better results from, or score better with.



    I have no pride in playing blades. Nobody cares. I think two people have commented on it in an entire year. I'd switch tomorrow if I could get better results.



    Larger sweet spots, better MOI etc. makes complete sense to me, yet I've invested in multiple cavity back sets and countless individual heads in an attempt to find clubs that will give me better results. To date I haven't found anything that improves my game or saves my wilder strikes. My bad ones are so bad they cannot be saved.



    My guess is if you're very precise and your misses are by a mil or two that there's a meaningful difference in result on those 'bad' strikes vs. what a blade would give? I can see that's entirely possible.



    All I know is it's a confounding topic. I think marketing has helped to create the more extreme differences in perception.


    What blades are you currently playing and where do you start with them in the bag?




    MP33s, PW thru 6i



    I swapped out my 5i this season for an MP18 MMC and I've gained distance on that club (and therefore tweaked other lofts), but as best I can see I'm not getting better performance. I'm going to play a few rounds with my MP33 5i and maybe 4i to give myself a better perspective on what I've lost or gained.



    I played in a friendly scramble yesterday, and I'm still getting over a hand injury, but the only two complete duffs I had were with non-blades:



    > MMC 5 iron into a long par 3... Hit it so far toe that it went maybe 130 yards straight and then died in the hazard

    > Demo JPX 900F into a 150 yd par 3. I don't hook my irons, but I hooked this so far left that I almost missed the left side trap
  • GautamaGautama Members Posts: 800 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I think it's almost entirely a mental thing. If you believe your irons have certain specific traits that work for you then they will. If you look down and believe they work against you they will. In a game that's 99% "half mental," that's hugely important.



    This was a cool video from Crossfield on the matter a while back. Not crazy about him but think he's absolutely right. (And before you cry "yeah, but but but he's a pro!" he addresses that numerous times.) Food for thought



    It's nearly all in one's head I think, and since that's where the game is played, heck yeah it matters
    "I see the distorted swings, the hurried rounds, and now the electric carts tae ruin the course and rob us of our exercise...we have gone off the mark, gone after the wrong things, forgotten what it's all about"

    -Dr. Julian Sands, Golf in the Kingdom
  • chisagchisag Members Posts: 3,038 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    BiggErn wrote:

    BiggErn wrote:


    It’s all relative. Unless you hit the pea size sweet spot of a blade like 99.9% of the time there’s absolutely no benefit in playing them. I guess there’s an argument that “I” shoot 95 more consistently with blades and around 100 with a cavity back so they just work for me kinda thing going on too that fuels the debate somehow.
    lol i don't think there is anyone on here saying they shoot 95 with blades compared to 100 with cavity backs man. there really isn't an argument here... your results differ fro mine, and my results differ from the next guy. I have been golfing for over 25 years and i am playing my first set of blades. Recently i have found that i am struggling with them as i have not been able to commit to practicing. i know that in order to commit to playing blades i have to practice a couple times a week or more in between playing. i may be one of the guys that are a "one and done" with trying blades. I can say that as a 7.6 i am as low as i have been in years... now there is an argument that i could be better with CB's but the unknown is by how much or if any at all. I will never know, just like if i go to CB's tomorrow and if i get to say a 5, that i wouldn't have gotten there without them. Who knows. All i know is that there should be a buyer beware tag on the better players irons regardless of CB or MB. They are not for everyone thats for sure. I can appreciate the opinions of everyone on the site, as long as everyone understands that they are just that... opinions. The only thing i can say for a fact is how all of this applies to me, beyond that its just my opinion.






    When someone wants something they will use any means and excuse necessary to attempt to justify it. Rationality doesn’t apply to everyone. The fact is if you don’t hit the ball like previously stated there is ZERO benefit in playing them. You can say that you can’t stand to look at a certain club or some turf interaction nonsense or whatever and that’s fine. I guess it’s acceptable some have mental issues, ego issues, and/or denial issues and that’s ok. It’s just a game. Some are good, some are great, some are terrible, and some are in between. When it comes to Golf ignorance is abound.




    ... A friend of mine coaches a high school golf team. His #1 player uses forged CB's and his #5 player uses MB's. His #3 and 4 use GI and SGI irons. His #5 player loves WRX and thinks MB's will help him play better golf. My friend never even heard of WRX and talked him into playing a round with #1's CB's. He shot his best round by 2 strokes, his personal best. His response was he can do the same with MB's and the CB's will stop his progress because they will cause him to get sloppy. My friend had no idea what he was talking about as he watched the entire round and saw zero difference in his swing or game, other than his misses turned out better. My friend tells me his #5 should be his #2 because he has the 2nd best swing and second best all around game, but he insists on playing MB's and it is clear to everyone on the team that MB's hurt his game and his score.
    Cobra F9 Tour Length ... Tensei Orange 65s
    Cobra F9 15.5* ... Atmos Blue TS 75s
    Cobra F8 18.5* ... Even Flow Blue 75s
    Tailor-made RBZ Tour  21.5 hybrid ... Matrix Altus 85s
    TaylorMade UDi 18* TP 2 iron... Kuro Kage Black 90hy
    4-pw TaylorMade P760 ... Recoil Prototype 95's
    SM6 52* F Grind /SM7 D Grind 58* ... Recoil 110s
    Bobby Grace 6330 ... 33.5"
  • jppatton2jppatton2 Members Posts: 96 ✭✭
    I’m currently playing a set of used MBs I bought on here mostly because I wanted to try the shafts. I had my previous irons for 8 years and also just wanted to change and the difference in buying new shafts and used sticks was close enough to make the switch.



    All of that to say, I love playing MBs because of the way they look and when you hit it pure I think it genuinely feels better. However, when I miss a shot out on the toe it is much more noticeable and def impacts my game, but not necessarily my score. Just depends on the day. How is my short game? How is my putting? I don’t hit it any closer with MBs, but my misses are further away from the hole. I plan to get new irons sometime next year and it will probably be some type of combo set up.



    It’s been said already, but how you feel at address looking down at the club is number 1 in my opinion. I don’t like looking at larger cavity backs when I am about to hit. On the flip side, my brother is a 16 HC and dreads looking down at my 5 iron if he is trying to hit it.
  • PorscheFanPorscheFan Members Posts: 1,278 ✭✭✭✭✭✭
    Gautama wrote:


    I think it's almost entirely a mental thing. If you believe your irons have certain specific traits that work for you then they will. If you look down and believe they work against you they will. In a game that's 99% "half mental," that's hugely important.



    This was a cool video from Crossfield on the matter a while back. Not crazy about him but think he's absolutely right. (And before you cry "yeah, but but but he's a pro!" he addresses that numerous times.) Food for thought



    It's nearly all in one's head I think, and since that's where the game is played, heck yeah it matters




    I think there’s something to that, but in the case of any ‘friendlier’ clubs I’ve experimented with both my hope and my expectation were that I would get results at least similar to what I do with my own clubs.



    I’d never fork out a single dollar on something that I wasn’t either hoping or expecting to produce results.
  • puttingmattputtingmatt puttingmatt Summer/ Michigan-- Winter/ FloridaMembers Posts: 5,209 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    Crossfield makes some very good points,


    Play Golf.....Play Blades......Play Something Else.....Just Go Play.....

    4 HC
  • North ButteNorth Butte Members Posts: 11,415 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭


    Crossfield makes some very good points,




    Mark Crossfield has exactly one "point" to make. He says buy whatever clubs you like because it doesn't matter you're going to suck no matter what clubs you use. Which is a perfectly true "point".



    The question is why the world needs him to drop dozens of videos every year describing new clubs when he's already said 100x before that what clubs you use doesn't matter.
    “1lb beefstak, with
    1pt bitter beer
    every 6 hours.
    1 ten-mile walk every morning.
    1 bed at 11 sharp every night.
    And don't stuff your head with things you don't understand.” 
  • chch3chch3 Members Posts: 825 ✭✭✭✭✭
    The correlation between a person's scores and their ball striking ability, is not always true.
    Cobra Bio Cell // HZRDUS Black
    Cobra F6 Baffler // HZRDUS Black
    Cobra F7 Hybrid // Diamana D+
    Mizuno JPX 900 Forged 5-GW // Project X
    Ping Tour Gorge 52 // Project X
    Callaway PM Grind 56 // Project X
    Taylormade Tour Spider Black
  • North ButteNorth Butte Members Posts: 11,415 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    Yeah, there's lots of guys who stripe it like a mini-Tour player but chip and putt their way to a 15 HCP. Wait, no there aren't.
    “1lb beefstak, with
    1pt bitter beer
    every 6 hours.
    1 ten-mile walk every morning.
    1 bed at 11 sharp every night.
    And don't stuff your head with things you don't understand.” 
  • chch3chch3 Members Posts: 825 ✭✭✭✭✭


    Yeah, there's lots of guys who stripe it like a mini-Tour player but chip and putt their way to a 15 HCP. Wait, no there aren't.




    Saying that only a certain handicap should play certain clubs is the dumbest thing I have ever heard. When I got down to a single digit handicap a few years ago, it was because of short game lessons I took. I dropped almost 7 points on my handicap because of that. So saying that a person who is a 15 shouldn't play blades because they are a 15 is dumb.
    Cobra Bio Cell // HZRDUS Black
    Cobra F6 Baffler // HZRDUS Black
    Cobra F7 Hybrid // Diamana D+
    Mizuno JPX 900 Forged 5-GW // Project X
    Ping Tour Gorge 52 // Project X
    Callaway PM Grind 56 // Project X
    Taylormade Tour Spider Black
  • BiggErnBiggErn Members Posts: 2,638 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    chch3 wrote:


    Yeah, there's lots of guys who stripe it like a mini-Tour player but chip and putt their way to a 15 HCP. Wait, no there aren't.




    Saying that only a certain handicap should play certain clubs is the dumbest thing I have ever heard. When I got down to a single digit handicap a few years ago, it was because of short game lessons I took. I dropped almost 7 points on my handicap because of that. So saying that a person who is a 15 shouldn't play blades because they are a 15 is dumb.






    It would only be dumb if they rarely hit a perfectly struck shot. I’ve never met a person that had tour level ball striking skills with irons but had had 15+ HC skills with the driver and short game.
  • MtlJeffMtlJeff MontrealMembers Posts: 28,705 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    chch3 wrote:



    Yeah, there's lots of guys who stripe it like a mini-Tour player but chip and putt their way to a 15 HCP. Wait, no there aren't.




    Saying that only a certain handicap should play certain clubs is the dumbest thing I have ever heard. When I got down to a single digit handicap a few years ago, it was because of short game lessons I took. I dropped almost 7 points on my handicap because of that. So saying that a person who is a 15 shouldn't play blades because they are a 15 is dumb.




    I'm fine with avoiding generalizations, and i'm also fine with players of any ability playing what they want. As i posted earlier i doubt blades vs SGI clubs for players of any handicap level would cost the player more than MAYBE 2 strokes on their index. And that's at the highest. There's just not much difference in the 7-PW and if you are playing the correct tees you shouldn't be hitting ten 5 irons every round. And handicap is an average of your best 10/20 scores too....



    But the great ballstriking 15 index is one of the great internet tall tales. They just don't exist. They would have to have the short game of someone playing their first round of golf ever. To shoot 87 in your 10 best rounds out of 20 while hitting 10+ greens and keeping balls in play for the most part, you'd have to be trying to miss at some point
    Ping G400 Max 10 w/ Matrix Black Tie 80
    Callaway Epic Subzero 14* w/Matrix Black Tie 80
    Callaway Apex Hybrid 20 w/S300
    Ping G410 4-SW w/S300
    Callaway MD 2.0 60 PM grind w/S300
    Odyssey O-works Red Tank #7
  • TexasCarlosTexasCarlos Unregistered Posts: 861 ✭✭
    If you suck with a Ping G MAX, you'll suck with MB's too. Handicaps come in all shapes and sizes, usually the difference between a 14 and a 6 cap is putting and chipping, looking at all the bogey golf guys out there. Short game will save you no matter what iron you want.
    G400 LST
    TM SLDR TS
    Apex UT 18'
    Apex MB 18'
    RTX 2.0 Raw
    Ping Anser Milled
  • duffer987duffer987 I'm old enough to remember a time when Ignore and Feedback worked. Canadian in CaliforniaMembers Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    edited Sep 17, 2018 #137


    If you suck with a Ping G MAX, you'll suck with MB's too. Handicaps come in all shapes and sizes, usually the difference between a 14 and a 6 cap is putting and chipping, looking at all the bogey golf guys out there. Short game will save you no matter what iron you want.




    No way. Simply no way that is the case. So you dropped 7+ points off your index solely by improving your putts per round and your up/down %? No way.

    The difference between 14 index and a 6 index is GIRs.



    Whatever clubs get those increased GIRs, who cares, but that's where the consistent lower scores are.
  • pallagrinpallagrin Members Posts: 122 ✭✭
    Play what you want to play is my philosophy. It's hard to comment on these posts because I can see it from other member's perspective if someone were to say "I hit X blade vs. Y CB almost the same". Personally, I tend to gravitate towards looks and feel in my choice of irons. Woods, I pick based on performance and numbers. Wedges? Not really my strong suit but getting better! (Don't worry, my major focus these days are my wedges and putter)
  • Lagavulin62Lagavulin62 Members Posts: 2,329 ✭✭✭✭✭✭
    So glad I started playing in the early 70’s. When did this blade vs GI crap start? I had no idea this was going on until I joined WRX. All my years nobody ever questioned someones preference for clubs. Play what you want. Of course everyone wanted pro line clubs but the only barrier was money. And if someone was lucky enough to have a set everyone admired them. Nobody ever said, “hey, you’re not good enough for those clubs”. What the heck has golf become?
  • North ButteNorth Butte Members Posts: 11,415 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    It’s purely an artifact of anonymous online forums. Nobody in the real world cares what kind of clubs some other guy uses. But on a forum DEDICATED to buying and comparing and discussing golf clubs that’s the kind of thing that gets talked about.
    “1lb beefstak, with
    1pt bitter beer
    every 6 hours.
    1 ten-mile walk every morning.
    1 bed at 11 sharp every night.
    And don't stuff your head with things you don't understand.” 
  • GautamaGautama Members Posts: 800 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Funny, you read this stuff and you'd think the ball won't even advance with a blade unless it's in the hands of a Ben Hogan on his A game. That's simply isn't the case, like at a all. The difference is tiny really. Seems to me if you like what's in your bag, play em and and don't be swayed by anyone's else's misguided ideas... because TRUSTING your clubs, on the other hand, is huge.



    Which I guess is why people argue with such silly fervor over this nonsense. Maybe they just don't want to let doubt creep into whatever good thing they've got going. And that's probably smart, but there's no actual debate or discussion being had, just a lot of everyone convincing and reassuring themselves they're playing the right thing.
    "I see the distorted swings, the hurried rounds, and now the electric carts tae ruin the course and rob us of our exercise...we have gone off the mark, gone after the wrong things, forgotten what it's all about"

    -Dr. Julian Sands, Golf in the Kingdom
  • Aviador NavalAviador Naval equus mortuus non caedis Members Posts: 1,148 ✭✭✭✭✭✭
    Gautama wrote:


    Funny, you read this stuff and you'd think the ball won't even advance with a blade unless it's in the hands of a Ben Hogan on his A game. That's simply isn't the case, like at a all. The difference is tiny really. Seems to me if you like what's in your bag, play em and and don't be swayed by anyone's else's misguided ideas... because TRUSTING your clubs, on the other hand, is huge.




    Amen.



    And not only that, the very little bit of difference that does exist is not a prescription for all issues. I'm a high launch kind of guy. I'm happy to admit its at best a swing idiosyncrasy and at worst a pure swing flaw. Regardless, until I run out of sufficient swingspeed at about 25 degrees or so, the very last thing I need are the attributes in a typical GI/SGI club. They would actually make the game harder since at its core the offset, big sole, and perimeter weighting are primarily to help get the ball airborne.



    On the other hand, I've played with some scratch guys that use SGI clubs. They had no trouble controlling trajectory or distance.



    Play what you like to look at and what gives you confidence.
    917 D2 9.5
    Original Ti Launcher 3w-13
    TS2 18 deg
    818 H1
    716 T-MB 5i
    919 Tour 6-P
    50-12, 54F, 58D
    Old Mn-Bn Anser
  • chch3chch3 Members Posts: 825 ✭✭✭✭✭
    When I was growing up pretty much everyone played hand me down blades. I learned to play on a set of Top Flights Dynertials from the 70's. I guess that is why I have never been afraid to play blades.
    Cobra Bio Cell // HZRDUS Black
    Cobra F6 Baffler // HZRDUS Black
    Cobra F7 Hybrid // Diamana D+
    Mizuno JPX 900 Forged 5-GW // Project X
    Ping Tour Gorge 52 // Project X
    Callaway PM Grind 56 // Project X
    Taylormade Tour Spider Black
  • Jacked_LoftJacked_Loft Steps Ahead Members Posts: 487 ✭✭
    edited Sep 18, 2018 #144
    If you believe the number on your scorecard is the test of your ability, then you also know that golf is a game of dealing with those mistakes that you WILL make during a round.



    That said, the iron head should be choosen which matches your ability to reduce YOUR number of mistakes to YOUR manageable level .



    If your goal is "fairways & greens" I would be looking at GI equipment.



    If your goal is "be aggressive and go low" I'd be using irons which I could move the ball with.



    However the deciding factor will always be your short game, which will allow you to deal with the mistakes which you will make. If my short game is sharp and I've been practicing it, I'll put my blades in play. If not I'll stick to my P770's.
    WIMB:

    `16 M1 9.5 Fuji Evo TS 661
    `17 M1 3&5 Kuro Kage 70
    P790 3I Nippon 950
    P770 4-GW Nippon 950
    MG 56° LB KBS REV
    Spider Tour BLK
    H2NO Carry
  • mahoniemahonie EnglandMembers Posts: 2,522 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    edited Sep 18, 2018 #145
    duffer987 wrote:



    If you suck with a Ping G MAX, you'll suck with MB's too. Handicaps come in all shapes and sizes, usually the difference between a 14 and a 6 cap is putting and chipping, looking at all the bogey golf guys out there. Short game will save you no matter what iron you want.




    No way. Simply no way that is the case. So you dropped 7+ points off your index solely by improving your putts per round and your up/down %? No way.

    The difference between 14 index and a 6 index is GIRs.



    Whatever clubs get those increased GIRs, who cares, but that's where the consistent lower scores are.




    D, I played a scratch match the other week. Being off 10 I was expecting a drubbing tbh and it was all over after 15. I looked to see what the differences were between our games. He was a bit longer off the tee, but I was a bit straighter. GIR? I hit 6/15, he hit 5/15. I got up and down 2/7, he got up and down 7/10! His combination of chipping and putting was so much better than mine and was the difference on the day. He told me he spends 80% of his practice time working on 50 yards in. I spend about the same, but my practice amounts to about one range session a month...he was spending 3 hours 3 times a week. We didn’t ask handicaps until towards the end of the round. I guessed he was about a 4 or 5 (he was off 5) and he thought I was 6 or 7 but with a very poor short game. I actually shot pretty close to my handicap...he was 2+ and it was all down to his short game.



    Edit - forgot to mention he was playing Ping i25s and played every shot, even driver, with left hand below right (right-hander)!
    Callaway Big Bertha Alpha Fubuki ZT Stiff
    MD Golf Superstrong 3-wood UST Proforce 65 Stiff
    Wilson Staff FG Tour M3 21* Hybrid Aldila RIP Stiff
    Mizuno MP4 4-PW DG S300
    Wilson Staff PMP wedges 50/54/58 KBS Hi-Rev 2.0
    Radius Classic 8
  • wmblake2000wmblake2000 Los AngelesMembers Posts: 5,942 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    Gautama wrote:
    Funny, you read this stuff and you'd think the ball won't even advance with a blade unless it's in the hands of a Ben Hogan on his A game. That's simply isn't the case, like at a all. The difference is tiny really. Seems to me if you like what's in your bag, play em and and don't be swayed by anyone's else's misguided ideas... because TRUSTING your clubs, on the other hand, is huge.



    Which I guess is why people argue with such silly fervor over this nonsense. Maybe they just don't want to let doubt creep into whatever good thing they've got going. And that's probably smart, but there's no actual debate or discussion being had, just a lot of everyone convincing and reassuring themselves they're playing the right thing.




    That makes a lot of sense to me.



    And to be sure trusting my clubs is huge. A close second is wanting to like them. If they are too ugly I don’t even give them half a chance.
    Ping GMax 400 10.5 TPT 17 LKP
    Callawy Epic 5W 
    Callaway X-hot pro 3,4 h
    Mizuno MP4 4-W, KBS tour-v, 110 S
    Mizuno MP-64 4-W, c-taper lite, 105 R
    Fourteen mt28v3 50, 54, 58
    Cameron Futura 5W


  • BearQBearQ Members Posts: 3,644 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    edited Sep 18, 2018 #147
    Properly fitted shaft + bit of tungsten help in the long irons. Blades should be no difference to your play, if anything you may get better from more practice to consistently lavish in the sweet sensation of a blade strike.



    Blending in a cb or udi style club at the 3-5 iron spot is the best play for most.
    Cobra LTD Pro (9.5*) - Matrix SR Type C 70X 
    Callaway XR 3Deep (14*) - GD Tour AD TP-8X
    TM P790-UDI #2 (17.5*) | TP UDI #3 (20*) - Matrix Black Tie HM4 105X 
    Srixon Z945 (4-P) - Nippon SPB X
    Nike VR Forged (56DS) | Cleveland RTX2 raw (60.08W)
    TM Spider Tour Black 35" - Ping blackout


  • TexasCarlosTexasCarlos Unregistered Posts: 861 ✭✭
    duffer987 wrote:



    If you suck with a Ping G MAX, you'll suck with MB's too. Handicaps come in all shapes and sizes, usually the difference between a 14 and a 6 cap is putting and chipping, looking at all the bogey golf guys out there. Short game will save you no matter what iron you want.




    No way. Simply no way that is the case. So you dropped 7+ points off your index solely by improving your putts per round and your up/down %? No way.

    The difference between 14 index and a 6 index is GIRs.



    Whatever clubs get those increased GIRs, who cares, but that's where the consistent lower scores are.




    GIR is probably the biggest factor you’re right, but’s its no crazy to think that if you get up and down 6 times that your HC will drop if this is done consistently? If ppl don’t have the time to hit full shots, at least putting and short game can shave off a few
    G400 LST
    TM SLDR TS
    Apex UT 18'
    Apex MB 18'
    RTX 2.0 Raw
    Ping Anser Milled
  • bladehunterbladehunter Today was a good day... south carolinaMembers Posts: 27,898 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    edited Sep 18, 2018 #149
    duffer987 wrote:



    If you suck with a Ping G MAX, you'll suck with MB's too. Handicaps come in all shapes and sizes, usually the difference between a 14 and a 6 cap is putting and chipping, looking at all the bogey golf guys out there. Short game will save you no matter what iron you want.




    No way. Simply no way that is the case. So you dropped 7+ points off your index solely by improving your putts per round and your up/down %? No way.

    The difference between 14 index and a 6 index is GIRs.



    Whatever clubs get those increased GIRs, who cares, but that's where the consistent lower scores are.




    Have to disagree man.





    Won’t say a 15. But as I’ve said many times I started really playing this game in 2014. I’d shoot high 80s with some sprinkled in 77-79s. Kept my stats then. I hit 6-9 greens most rounds. And 3 putted regularly. But more importantly averaged 2 ob drives a round.



    Today my low round is 65. Perfect day. With a lot of 72-74. But. I’ve shot 77-84 9 times this summer in comp while hitting 12 or more greens. I’ve improved tons all over. But still if I’m not getting up and down will shoot 8-12 handicap scores. Shortgame ( wedges) is solid. But it’s alwsys putter. You can hit 14 greens and 3 putt 7 times and be s***. I’ve done it too many times. Severa guys on this board have played with me. Seen it I person.



    In the last 3 months I belive this putting issue is under control. So a non issue now. But just saying the idea that putting comes automatic to a good ballstriker isn’t true. Look at Rory. look at jason Duffner. It’s all relative. But how many 68s do they turn into 74 ? A ton. Blow that up on the scale and you have a guy turning 72 into 80 in the am world.
    Ping G410  11.2* Tensei pro OrangeV2 proto 70TX 
    Ping G410 15.5* Graphite Design ADDI 8x
    Ping G410 21* ADDI 105x 
    Ping Blueprint  4-PW   Modus 130X 
    Ping Glide Forged  50  54 60 s400
    Spider X Tour Armlock.  42 inch with jumbo max 17 inch  grip.   


  • anthanth From the Land Down Under Members Posts: 2,778 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    edited Sep 18, 2018 #150
    Yes but you’re nowhere near a mid handicapper with those scores, and that’s exactly Jeff’s point.



    A 15 capper on a bad day is throwing up close to 100.



    So a legitimate 15 capper has more issues than short game and putting going on
    Callaway Rogue 10.5
    Callaway BB Alpha 816 16
    Srixon Z H45 19 Hybrid
    Srixon Z U45 23 Utility
    Srixon Z 765/965 5 - PW
    TaylorMade Milled Grind 50 & 54
    TaylorMade Milled Grind Hi Toe 58
    TaylorMade Spider Tour Red
    TaylorMade TP5
  • duffer987duffer987 I'm old enough to remember a time when Ignore and Feedback worked. Canadian in CaliforniaMembers Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    edited Sep 18, 2018 #151
    TC & BH - I don't disagree with either of you that putting and chipping can help someone for particular rounds or particular stretches of play, but you don't make a fundamental and long-lasting improvement in your game/index (such as going from 14 to 6) without improving your ballstriking and increasing your GIR.



    I'll have to google/search here, but there is absolutely a direct correlation between the two.

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file