Most Overrated Course

1356732

Comments

  • theshieldtheshield Members Posts: 72
    Dove Mountain - pretty forgettable layout with the exception of a couple decent holes

    Grayhawk raptor - even more forgettable than dove mtn

    PGA national - eh



    As for the wolf creek comments, I don't really consider it golf so much as an experience. Fun to play but it's completely ridiculous. I wouldn't call it overrated, just really don't know what to call it
  • Mike TMike T Members Posts: 57
    Understand when people say Pebble and Torrey Pines are overrated.



    I would play them again however.



    One course I would never replay is Doral Blue Monster. Mind you, I played before the renovation. Left me feeling ripped off with what they were charging for a very average parkland course.



    I haven't felt that about any other course I've experienced.
  • MyShortGameSucksMyShortGameSucks His doesn't.... Members Posts: 1,349 ✭✭
    edited Aug 12, 2015 #64
    I am going to go with Pinehurst #2....and that is not in anyway influenced by what I did or didn't pay to get on image/smile.png' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':)' />



    It looks great on TV and in photos. It was great fun being there watching the women play there at the US Open but...when you stand on the tees there's just something that does not fit my eye. It's not that it's a real tough driving course but for me I just did not like or enjoy the sight lines. A lot of times I stood on the tee and thought "meh". Add the fact that the greens contours are famously border-line silly it just added up to a deeply uninspiring and unenjoyable day. I am probably not going to get many to agree but I would say say that Pinehurst #8,and Dormie Club are better courses. Maybe even #4 as well,,,



    Honorable local mention goes to Salem CC. Bar 2 or 3 holes it's totally underwhelming and over-rated.
    Callaway Epic Sub Zero Custom All-Black 10.5 deg, Diamana Ahina 60x
    TM 790 UDI 2 iron / PX Hzrdus 85
    Titleist 816H1 19 deg, Fuji 88H
    Titleist 816H2 23 deg, Fuji 88H
    Mizuno JPX 900 Forged 5-7, Tour 8-PW. Nippon Modus 105x
    Mizuno S18, 50, 54, 58 deg - Nippon Modus 120s
    SC Futura XR / SC Golo 5 / SC Notchback
    Bridgestone B330 - B
  • oregongolforegongolf Lefty Boomers Posts: 8,573 ✭✭
    Harding Park is another course I would consider extremely overrated.
  • jptruckjptruck Unregistered Posts: 842
    edited Aug 13, 2015 #66
    sharkiesj wrote:

    jptruck wrote:

    sharkiesj wrote:

    jptruck wrote:


    Easy: SPYGLASS HILLS. Two interesting holes in the dunes and then it's basically Poppy Hills II through the woods. Will never go back.




    Spyglass Hill, not Hills



    I'm sorry to be such a stickler but it is one of my pet peeves when people do not correctly spell the names of golf courses. Especially the one's here in California.




    Spyglass Hill. Thanks for giving me the chance to say it sucks twice.




    Ha! Love it. I happen to agree with you. Of any course on the entire Monterey Peninsula, the most overrated is Spyglass Hill AT THE RACK RATE.. Holes 1-4 define the place then you're playing Poppy Hills but you're paying near Pebble prices. Duke's Club price is easier to justify but really, can anyone here honestly recall a single hole on the back nine that stands out as sheer genius or even half memorable? If you can you're a liar. I've played it 6 times and while nice, I can't wait to finish so I can leave and go eat somewhere. The pro shop is a 2 foot by 3 foot cardboard box. My a$$ sticks out the front door while I'm paying my green fee.




    It's a classic case where you step on the course with high expectations and then walk off disappointed. I didn't help that the starters and others were hyping it as the best course on the peninsula, which is a joke. I've played them all (on the peninsula), and this is probably the worst of the bunch (which is better than a lot of courses). It's just not worth $400, or whatever it costs to play it. I'd go back there if I had to, but I didn't enjoy the course.
  • SixcatSixcat SWVAMembers Posts: 1,466 ✭✭


    I am going to go with Pinehurst #2....and that is not in anyway influenced by what I did or didn't pay to get on image/smile.png' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':)' />



    It looks great on TV and in photos. It was great fun being there watching the women play there at the US Open but...when you stand on the tees there's just something that does not fit my eye. It's not that it's a real tough driving course but for me I just did not like or enjoy the sight lines. A lot of times I stood on the tee and thought "meh". Add the fact that the greens contours are famously border-line silly it just added up to a deeply uninspiring and unenjoyable day. I am probably not going to get many to agree but I would say say that Pinehurst #8,and Dormie Club are better courses. Maybe even #4 as well,,,



    Honorable local mention goes to Salem CC. Bar 2 or 3 holes it's totally underwhelming and over-rated.




    I can't agree with you on #2. One of my favorites I have played. I will absolutely agree with you on Dormie, #4 and #8 being great tracks also. #2 gets all the attention and fanfare but the surrounding area at Pinehurst has 6 or 7 of the best courses I have ever played.
  • LlortamaiseyLlortamaisey Members Posts: 5,959 ✭✭
    Oakland Hills South Course. I guess I was just expecting more considering all the U.S. Opens, PGA Champs, and Ryder Cup that were played there. It was a very nice club, just not sure why it gets all those majors.
  • MaxBuckMaxBuck Members Posts: 383 ✭✭




    One more overrated course. The Scarlet course at Ohio State. It's fairly highly ranked in the state of Ohio. I can't for the life of my understand the allure to the course. All the course is, is a old design that was remodeled (because it wasn't very good in the first place). All the redesign did was lengthen the course to make it actually difficult and build some of the most rediculously large green complexes I have ever seen. The course is just super long, with huge greens that run really quick and a mix of large bunkers. Nothing more to it. Almost every hole looks the same and each of those are simply mediocre. I'm left shaking my head everytime I hear someone rave about it. I don't enjoy courses that are just long and straight with little else to them.




    Just goes to show how subjective and personal this stuff is, because Scarlet has always been one of my very favorite layouts. Hardly just "long and straight" in my view, and the par-3s there are phenomenal IMO. Each to his own, obviously.



    My own "overrated" list includes Caledonia (a very popular course, so I know this is very personal) and the Old Course at The Homestead. Caledonia is to me claustrophobic - very short, very tight, though extremely pretty - and the Homestead course is just kind of meh.



    I also think Scioto CC is a little dull as a layout, though the overall experience of playing there is very special. The history, especially - playing where Jack grew up - brings chills to the avid golfer. But as for my favorite Ross layouts I'd put both Inverness and Pinehurst #2 well above it.
  • stlglfrstlglfr Members Posts: 126 ✭✭
    Not as big a name as some of the other courses that have been discussed but I'll say that Disney's Magnolia Course was an utter disappointment in my eyes. Orlando golf is usually pretty solid and given the PGA Tour's stop there, I had high expectations. I have a really hard time remembering many of the holes out there, nothing gave me the "wow factor" when I was playing it, and it was way too crowded (It is a Disney course, I get that). Certainly not on my repeat list for Orlando golf.
    Taylormade M1 430, 9.5*, Project X Hzrdous 6.5
    Taylormade M1; 15*; Fujikura VC 7.1 X
    Titleist 913 Hd; Diamana D+ 103 x
    Taylormade RSi TP 4-PW, DG Tour Issue S400
    Vokey SM6 (Black); 50*, 55*, 60*; DG Tour Issue Onyx S400
    Scotty Cameron X5 - 34"
  • RichieHuntRichieHunt Members Posts: 3,671 ✭✭


    I couldn't disagree with you more on Somerset Hills...I would go as far as to say it is the most UNDERRATED course I have ever played




    I didn't think the entire front nine was very special at all. I enjoyed the back nine more. The clubhouse and pro shop was a joke. I understand a minimalist philosophy, but they just looked like garbage to me.



    The conditioning was fantastic, but I've just seen far better courses out there that if it Ron Garl had designed it instead of AW Tillinghast...nobody cares.













    RH
  • mr_lt21mr_lt21 Members Posts: 34
    kg92lefty wrote:


    Wolf Creek in mesquite. By far the most overrated dump I've played. My dad said pebble was overrated when he played there.


    only because you couldn't break 100
    Nike vapor tw driver
    Nike vapor flex 3 wood
    nike pro combo irons
    titleist vokey wedge 52, 54, 58
    scotty cameron newport putter
  • Tipsy McHookerTipsy McHooker Members Posts: 555 ✭✭
    i agree with pawleys plantation and cog hill dubsdread overrated and Cog at $160 is way overpriced as well....I liked Quintero and Tullymore very much...which some have ripped on...don't see that they have the same rep as (Tournament courses, etc) being incredible so you would be the most disappointed in your life after round.
  • kg92leftykg92lefty Members Posts: 2,331 ✭✭
    edited Aug 15, 2015 #74
    mr_lt21 wrote:

    kg92lefty wrote:


    Wolf Creek in mesquite. By far the most overrated dump I've played. My dad said pebble was overrated when he played there.


    only because you couldn't break 100




    Shot 71 first time there from back tees. Good try though. You must have struggled yourself... The course is a pitch and putt if you find the fairway. Extremely easy after you find grass.



    Edit.. Not a fan of target Canyon golf. Plus the greens were covered in ball marks and bunkers had no sand.
  • 3GoodPutts3GoodPutts Members Posts: 46
    Any of the Disney courses. You can play 20 better courses in Orlando for half the price.
  • MrTmagMrTmag Members Posts: 2,383
    edited Aug 15, 2015 #76
    Augusta is a very overrated course in my opinion. I think it's image and history overshadow the actual course which isn't all that special in my eyes. I know it's on most golfers bucket list but I'd honestly decline the invitation to play there if I was ever offered.
  • gophergutsgopherguts Banned Posts: 2,511
    I second St Andrews.



    Without "weather" the Pros would kill it at any length and the winning score would be -30, the cut probably around -10.



    Only memorable hole was the Road Hole. And a drivable 100 yard wide finishing hole ? Sheesh.



    I get it's the home of golf and all and that in itself makes it historical but,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
    [font=comic sans ms,cursive]Cobra Bio Cell+
    Adams A12 Pro 16, 20, 23
    Ping G20, 5-SW, C-Taper stiff
    TM xft wedge 64
    Scotty Futura X[/font]
    [font=comic sans ms,cursive]ProV1x[/font]
  • edresnickedresnick FranktheHeadcover Members Posts: 169
    JumboJack wrote:


    Trum LA by far. Like someone previously mentioned. You can stripe one down the middle and end up in jail. No way in the world would I pay 280.00 to play it. I have a coupon to play for 150.00 and I'm not going to use it.
    JumboJack wrote:


    Trum LA by far. Like someone previously mentioned. You can stripe one down the middle and end up in jail. No way in the world would I pay 280.00 to play it. I have a coupon to play for 150.00 and I'm not going to use it.




    Totally agree. Have no idea how this makes GD top 100 public list. All gimmicks and on a piece of land not big enough for a golf course. Might have been able to fit 13 good holes there, but not 18
  • oregongolforegongolf Lefty Boomers Posts: 8,573 ✭✭
    MrTmag wrote:


    Augusta is a very overrated course in my opinion. I think it's image and history overshadow the actual course which isn't all that special in my eyes. I know it's on most golfers bucket list but I'd honestly decline the invitation to play there if I was ever offered.




    Nice to see you back, JonesScott.
  • edresnickedresnick FranktheHeadcover Members Posts: 169
    QMany wrote:


    The Ocean Course at Kiawah.



    It was good, but not great, and certainly not Top 20 in the USA. I have played $50 public tracks in Nebraska that are better.




    Nebraska must be the most under rated golf state in the country! I have played a bunch of the top 100 courses and Kiawah is right at the top. Great mix of short and long holes with strategy and wind in the mix. I suggest you give it another try.
  • gophergutsgopherguts Banned Posts: 2,511
    oregongolf wrote:

    MrTmag wrote:


    Augusta is a very overrated course in my opinion. I think it's image and history overshadow the actual course which isn't all that special in my eyes. I know it's on most golfers bucket list but I'd honestly decline the invitation to play there if I was ever offered.




    Nice to see you back, JonesScott.




    image/cheesy.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':cheesy:' /> image/cheesy.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':cheesy:' /> image/cheesy.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':cheesy:' />
    [font=comic sans ms,cursive]Cobra Bio Cell+
    Adams A12 Pro 16, 20, 23
    Ping G20, 5-SW, C-Taper stiff
    TM xft wedge 64
    Scotty Futura X[/font]
    [font=comic sans ms,cursive]ProV1x[/font]
  • MrTmagMrTmag Members Posts: 2,383
    oregongolf wrote:

    MrTmag wrote:


    Augusta is a very overrated course in my opinion. I think it's image and history overshadow the actual course which isn't all that special in my eyes. I know it's on most golfers bucket list but I'd honestly decline the invitation to play there if I was ever offered.




    Nice to see you back, JonesScott.


    I'm serious I don't like the course like others don't like the various other courses mentioned.
  • mac94mac94 Banned Posts: 6,321 ✭✭

    zer0 wrote:





    I'm with you on Whistling Straits. But not due to conditioning. I thought it was in great shape when we were there last summer. I just didn't love the design. I thought it was completely overdesigned and a bit unnecessary and ridiculous at times. I thought some of the overdesigning done by Dye actually ended up taking away from the course at times. It's one of the few great golf courses (at least by ratings) that I walked away from thinking I was glad I played it once but not sure I care to play it again.








    Funny you say that, yesterday I was talking about WS and Pete Dye in general and the term that came to mind when describing his courses was "ridiculous". Almost seems like he is making holes that are over the top and ridiculous as opposed to thinking about making good golf holes. Just look at 18 at WS. Looking back at the fairway from the green it looks like the worms from the movie Tremors must live under the fairway. I feel like Dye was more concerned with making holes difficult and gimicky and that will look crazy on tv vs making holes that are challenging, but rewarding and flow together with the rest of the course.



    I played WS once and I didn't walk off the course thinking about how much I wanted to get another shot at it. I was just happy I survived. Other great courses, I find myself wanting to go back and replay it with knowledge I learned the first time around. With WS it seemed like the whole focus of the round was trying to avoid the sure triple bogeys that existed on either side of the fairways.




    This echoes my feelings exactly.



    I will say, I played The Ocean Course about a month after WS and thought it was a brillant track. Nothing crazy, nothing absurd, just a handful of flat out great golf holes. It's one of the only Dye courses I have walked away thinking not only do I want to play it again but I could play it everyday.



    One more overrated course. The Scarlet course at Ohio State. It's fairly highly ranked in the state of Ohio. I can't for the life of my understand the allure to the course. All the course is, is a old design that was remodeled (because it wasn't very good in the first place). All the redesign did was lengthen the course to make it actually difficult and build some of the most rediculously large green complexes I have ever seen. The course is just super long, with huge greens that run really quick and a mix of large bunkers. Nothing more to it. Almost every hole looks the same and each of those are simply mediocre. I'm left shaking my head everytime I hear someone rave about it. I don't enjoy courses that are just long and straight with little else to them.




    I think Scarlet is highly rated only in the minds of old timers, Buckeye fans and Nicklaus lovers.
  • mac94mac94 Banned Posts: 6,321 ✭✭
    MrTmag wrote:


    Augusta is a very overrated course in my opinion. I think it's image and history overshadow the actual course which isn't all that special in my eyes. I know it's on most golfers bucket list but I'd honestly decline the invitation to play there if I was ever offered.




    Troll alert.
  • OpusX20OpusX20 The balance. The poise. The finish. It's like a dance. Members Posts: 1,856 ✭✭
    I felt like The Prince course at the Princeville Resort in Kauai and Sahalee CC in Seattle were very overrated. Princeville seemed like gimmicky target golf and all the holes at Sahalee seemed the same. The conditioning at both courses (especially Sahalee) were fantastic. I just wasn't a fan of either layout.



    I was very surprised to see two people mention Hazeltine as being overrated. I loved Hazeltine. But, as Dalton astutely observed in Roadhouse, "Opinions vary."
    Driver: TaylorMade M1 9.5*, Fujikura Motore Speeder VC 6.2 Tour Spec X
    3 Wood: Taylormade R15 15*, Fujikura Motore F1X
    Hybrid: TaylorMade M1 19*, Fujikura Speeder Evo 82H X
    Irons: Titleist 716 AP2 4-PW , Tour Issue TT DG X100
    Wedges: Yururi Gekku Raw 49*, 53* & 57* Nippon NS Pro Modus3 130X
    Putter: Scotty Cameron Futura 6M
  • PepsiDuckPepsiDuck Members Posts: 1,867 ✭✭
    My contribution to this thread isn't a $300+ course, but I played Pacific Grove Golf Links for the first time today since my home course was closed. Known as the "Poor Man's Pebble Beach," I found that the course was just 7 holes in the ground with a view of the coastline.



    And the fact that they don't have a drop of drinking water on the course just made it tough for me to like the place.
    TaylorMade M2 (2017) 10.5* - Aldila Synergy Black 70TX
    TaylorMade M2 (2017) Tour 15* - Fujikura Motore Speeder 757 X
    Callaway 815 Alpha Hybrid 21* - Mitsubishi Tensei Pro White 90TX
    Miura CB57 4-P - KBS C-Taper Lite X
    Miura Series 1957 Wedges - 51* (Y), 56* (K) - KBS C-Taper Lite X
    Cleveland RTX 3.0 60*
    TaylorMade Spider Tour Red
  • HardHatsRequiredHardHatsRequired Members Posts: 120 ✭✭


    Oakland Hills South Course. I guess I was just expecting more considering all the U.S. Opens, PGA Champs, and Ryder Cup that were played there. It was a very nice club, just not sure why it gets all those majors.




    Same vein, different venue: Medinah #3 tops my list. I'd rather get a colonoscopy than play there again. Long, straight, tree-lined holes, back and forth. Difficult and bland. And the place is a factory.
  • stevopagolfstevopagolf Members Posts: 1,464 ✭✭
    edited Aug 16, 2015 #88
    OpusX20 wrote:


    I felt like The Prince course at the Princeville Resort in Kauai and Sahalee CC in Seattle were very overrated. Princeville seemed like gimmicky target golf and all the holes at Sahalee seemed the same. The conditioning at both courses (especially Sahalee) were fantastic. I just wasn't a fan of either layout.



    I was very surprised to see two people mention Hazeltine as being overrated. I loved Hazeltine. But, as Dalton astutely observed in Roadhouse, "Opinions vary."




    I love the Roadhouse reference! Best "bad' movie ever! "I thought you'd be bigger"
    Post edited by Unknown User on
  • CDLgolfCDLgolf Members Posts: 838 ✭✭
    jptruck wrote:


    Easy: SPYGLASS HILLS. Two interesting holes in the dunes and then it's basically Poppy Hills II through the woods. Will never go back.




    I would agree I was underwhelmed after I left Spyglass.
    Cobra F8
    Ping G25 3 wood
    Ping G25 20 & 23 hybrid G30 26 hybrid
    Ping i e1 6- uw
    Ping Tour Gorge 56 & 60
    Odyssey
  • golfheaven69golfheaven69 Members Posts: 1,146 ✭✭
    Bay Hill. Every time I've played it conditions have been subpar. Go around tournament time or don't go at all.
  • Bonneville85308Bonneville85308 Members Posts: 1,666 ✭✭
    Ballyowen in NJ.
Sign In or Register to comment.