Ball in the thick rough - what club do you pick?

24

Comments

  • MountainKingMountainKing Members Posts: 1,530 ✭✭

    Not a 5 iron, that's for sure...

    Taylormade M1 8.5* Fujikura Pro Tour Spec 73x
    Taylormade Stage 2 HL Accra FX 300
    Callaway Razr Tour Hybrid 19* Nunchuk
    Rocketbladez Tour 4-PW TT X100
    Tour Preferred 50/54 S400
    TM HI Toe 58 ATV S400
    TM Itsy Bitsy

  • kcd38kcd38 Members Posts: 344 ✭✭

    If it is 200 plus from the green and a decent lie, hybrid.
    If it is less than 200 from the green and sunk down a little I usually go with my 8 iron and play the face slightly open knowing the grass will grab the hosel and shut the face. Definitely need some speed to get out of the thick stuff.

    Driver - PING G400 LST 8.5, Project X HZRDUS Smoke Black 6.0
    3 Wood - PING G400 14.5, AD Di 6s
    Hybrid - Ping G410 19 degree, Tour AD DI 95x Hybrid 
    4-UW - Ping i210 DG 120 S300
    Wedges - Vokey SM7 52 F, 56 F, 60 D 
    Putter - Taylormade Spider Tour Black
  • DavidvDavidv Members Posts: 734 ✭✭

    A pitching wedge.

  • North ButteNorth Butte Members Posts: 10,085 ✭✭

    I live in the land of Bermuda. If it's thick summer rough and the entire ball is below the surface it's usually a LW and swing as hard as I can, just trying to get the ball into the fairway somewhere. Maybe if the grass is really dry I'll take a GW or PW and try to advance it 50-60 yards.

    “1lb beefstak, with
    1pt bitter beer
    every 6 hours.
    1 ten-mile walk every morning.
    1 bed at 11 sharp every night.
    And don't stuff your head with things you don't understand.” 
  • RJ_MJ_JJRJ_MJ_JJ Members Posts: 21 ✭✭

    Wedge. Take your medicine! A low-lofted club will get caught up in long rough more than a higher-lofted club. Think of your angle of descent relative to your club's loft (especially if you come at it steeper since it's buried). The more loft, the less the face will be square to the grass, causing less resistance through to the ball. Also - MUSCLE-UP, keep your wrists strong.

    GHIN = ~5
    -WITB-
    DRIVER: Cobra F7+ set to 8.5* w/ Tensei Blue 70x
    DRIVING IRON: Mizuno FLI HI 2i w/ KBS C Taper 125 S+, hard step +1
    IRONS: Ping i210 Irons 3-P w/ KBS C Taper 125 S+, hard step +1, blue dot
    WEDGES: Vokey SM7 Wedges, 50, 54, 58
    PUTTER: Ping Sigma G KUSHIN w/ lots of lead tape
    BALL: Bridgestone Tour B330
    GRIPS: Winn Dri Tac

  • taporsnap17taporsnap17 Members Posts: 811 ✭✭

    Depends what the score is.

    If I'm making the "smart" play, nothing more than a 7. If it's really bad, a hand wedge

  • YepyukonYepyukon Hinge + Hold Members Posts: 4,127 ✭✭

    @Nixhex524 said:

    @Yepyukon said:
    Judging by several of the responses, I am not sure a lot of people know what "course management" means.

    Care to elaborate?

    Always depends on yardage but if it's a really poor lie and is going to take a miracle to get it on or close to the green, just get it back in play and live to fight another day.

    Just reading a lot of post about people thinking they are going to hit a miraculous shot into the green after they just missed a massive fairway (assuming normal fairway size). The OP stated "thick rough". To me, that means rough that you nearly cannot find your ball in until you step on it. If that is what was referred, then taking a wedge and putting it back into play is course management. Trying to pull off the hero shot - while fun - can lead to a really big number and is generally not the smart play.

    Srixon 785 10.5* w/ Oban Devotion
    Nike VR Pro Limited 15* w/ Diamana Kai'li
    Srixon ZU85 18* w/ Diamana WB
    Srixon ZU85 22* w/ AxivCore Blue
    Srixon 785 5 - 8 w/ Project X Flighted
    Srixon Z Forged 9 - PW w/ Project X Flighted
    Cleveland RTX 4 50* 55* 60*
    Nike Method 003 Oven Prototype
    Srixon ZSTAR XV Tour Yellow
  • clp34vmpclp34vmp Cancel that mead Members Posts: 254 ✭✭

    My course has an extremely long, double-dogleg par 5. Really long hitters can cut the first dogleg and make the hole play a good bit shorter, but most of us don't have that option. The tee shot is particularly brutal for those, like me, who tend to fade/slice the ball. Going right makes this already long hole play even longer, and the rough on the right side can be brutal. It's not uncommon for me to find my ball sitting down in thick rough and still needing to cover about 375 yards to get to the green. So I'm wondering how this scenario would affect peoples' decision making - would you still wedge out from a really bad lie knowing how much of the hole is still left to negotiate? Thinking about it now, it seems like that is still the smart play, especially as trying to go after it with a hybrid brings other potential disasters like OB into play, but it's tough for me in the moment to take my medicine and accept that I'll still have no chance to be able to go for the green with my third shot.

  • davep043davep043 Members Posts: 3,246 ✭✭
    edited May 14, 2019 2:12pm #40

    The first time I was really close to PGA Tour golfers was when I marshaled a couple of US Open practice rounds at Congressional, in 1997. The rough that year was brutal, 4 to 6 inches. During the practice rounds, the players would try their "normal" club from the deep rough, then a couple of clubs down, all the way to wedges. I saw a couple of mid-irons that only went 15 or 20 yards, so it's obviously really tough no matter how well you play. They had to learn what they could (and couldn't) do, and its just the same for you. If you can practice from deep rough, try a few options, so you learn about different lies and different clubs. For me, the most important thing is to advance the ball into a "good" location. The deeper the rough, and the longer the club, the more difficult that becomes. I'm not embarrassed at all when I need to hit a sand wedge from 120 yards, knowing I'm going to come up short.

  • timbo08timbo08 Members Posts: 2,084 ✭✭

    Take my medicine and hit the highest lofted club I can to a safe spot and hopefully good wedge distance. Best case, wedge it close and sneak out a 1 putt par, or worst case I walk away with a bogey and move on.

  • hartrick11hartrick11 San DiegoMembers Posts: 47 ✭✭

    I usually hit PW out just to get back into play. If I'm playing a course with crazy rough like Torrey I will also ditch my driving iron for an old bio-cell hybrid which I can usually trundle forward with a steep AOA if I have a really long way in and need to advance out of thick stuff, but that is still admittedly not the smart play.

    @clp34vmp said:
    My course has an extremely long, double-dogleg par 5. Really long hitters can cut the first dogleg and make the hole play a good bit shorter, but most of us don't have that option. The tee shot is particularly brutal for those, like me, who tend to fade/slice the ball. Going right makes this already long hole play even longer, and the rough on the right side can be brutal. It's not uncommon for me to find my ball sitting down in thick rough and still needing to cover about 375 yards to get to the green. So I'm wondering how this scenario would affect peoples' decision making - would you still wedge out from a really bad lie knowing how much of the hole is still left to negotiate? Thinking about it now, it seems like that is still the smart play, especially as trying to go after it with a hybrid brings other potential disasters like OB into play, but it's tough for me in the moment to take my medicine and accept that I'll still have no chance to be able to go for the green with my third shot.

    Driver: Cobra F8+, Hzrdus Black
    3w: Cobra F7, AD DI
    UT: TaylorMade Gapr LO, KBS Proto
    Irons: Cobra King Forged CB, KBS $ Taper
    Wedges: Bridgestone Tour B X-W1 54 & 60
    Putter: Scotty Cameron California Hollywood

  • JoeFrigoJoeFrigo Members Posts: 37 ✭✭

    @MtlJeff said:
    At Torrey I hit gap wedge from 180 out of the rough a couple of times LoL

    When rough is that bad just advance it into the fairway and wedge it in

    Glad I saw this. Im playing Torrey south at the end of the month

    TM M5 9* UST Elements Chrome 7x
    TM M6 15* GD AD IZ 7tx
    TM M6 18* GD AD IZ 8tx
    Ping 410 Crossover 2i
    Sub 70 CB 4i - 6i PX 6.5
    Sub 70 MB 7i - Pw PX 6.5
    Cleveland RTX4 52*, 58* DG S400
    Swag Suave One Raw Proto w/ BGT Stability shaft

  • pinestreetgolfpinestreetgolf Members Posts: 3,473 ✭✭

    @jjfcpa said:
    Played a round yesterday and found my ball in some very thick rough. Grass was almost like crab grass and about 4 - 5 inches deep. I was about 150 from the green and decided to go with a 5 iron. Could not get the club on the ball directly and when I swung, the grass just completely grabbed the club and the ball went maybe 30 - 40 yards. On second thought, I think I should have chosen a different club.. perhaps a hybrid. What would you have chosen.

    Its not the club, its the technique. Imagine a clock around the ball, where 12 and 6 are on your target line - 6 at the rear of the ball and 12 at the front, so 9 is pointing right at you. Most players are used to coming into the ball at 6 o'clock without shaft lean. You can get away with that on a clean lie - you add loft, but you can still hit the ball even if you don't compress it. The problem is that in deep rough you can't come in like that - the grass is in the way. You have to have a much steeper angle of attack. The more its buried the steeper you have to be.

    Because of a concept known as the D Plane (beyond this thread, but basically attack angle alters your club face and club path) you have to rotate much harder/faster through impact and come from much more inside. The steeper the swing the more out to in the swing path all else being equal.

    If you swing normally one of two things will happen. One, you'll hit nothing but rough, and it will be like a bunker shot. It will go straight, just not very far. Two, you will sense you are going to hit rough and flip, the grass grabs the hosel of the club, and you hit a line drive left going left.

    To prevent that and hit a good shot, you have to swing down steeply. Go into the ball at what feels like 7 or 8 or even 9 o'clock - from the inside - but turn your body much faster. The face will stay open much longer in the downswing and the club will come in way steeper so it can actually hit ball-first. However, at impact, it will be identical to a normal shot - you don't need to take more club unless you can't perform the technique at speed.

    I couldn't disagree more with the poster who advised putting the ball back in the stance. It seems like this would make sense, as your low point would be in front of the ball more, but the issue isn't low point. Its keeping the club head clear of the grass until it hits the ball. The only way to do that is to become much steeper into the ball. The low point doesn't matter. This is one reason grouping all shots into "bad lie" isn't smart. Moving the ball back helps you make contact but it actively hurts you when you are trying to avoid an obstacle (like grass) because it shallows the swing.

    So, to hit it when its buried:

    1. Close your stance. This will encourage a in-to-out swing path and cancel out some of the steepness.
    2. Come into the ball at what feels like 8 o'clock instead of 6 o'clock. Feel like you are hitting the ball with the face wide open but use your body turn to counteract this.
    3. Steepen your swing significantly (feet closer together, more wrist hinge, there are a lot of ways to do this)
    4. Turn like an absolute m*****f****cker through the ball to square the face at the last second. If you square the fact like in a normal swing to 6 o'clock early you'll hit the grass.

    A good downswing feel for this shot is to narrow your stance, hinge your wrists and then feel like you are elbowing someone behind you with your left elbow as hard as you can. The key to getting out of deep rough is to be steep, and the key to hitting it straight while steep is to be significantly from the inside and fast.

    Ping g30 driver, various shafts
    Adams tight lies 3 wood
    rest is up for debate
  • GLF4EVRGLF4EVR Members Posts: 797 ✭✭

    From the description.....have lies like this occasionally at local course. Will use 58 & will have a steep angle of descent on the ball. The idea is to pop the ball up & out quickly. I normally will have the ball closer to my back foot & will vary the position & angle of the face of the club. First rule is how quickly I need to get the ball up; then if needing to keep it under any overhanging objects; then how far I need the ball to carry before it starts to run. Last is looking at the easiest place to get the ball to as opposed to where I would like to get the ball to. Majority of the time it is my 58, but have gone to an 8 at times when I am able to get some distance & hopefully run up to the green. What can make this funner....course is in National Forrest land. So you might only have one "hole" to try & get the ball thru. Beer does not help!

  • Jack PearsallJack Pearsall Members Posts: 3,351 ✭✭

    A heavier wedge club, and with reduced expectations, Attempt an open faced, V angle into the ball’s backside. Usually works. Reduced expectations is somewhat key.

    Taylormade SLDR TP 430 10*
    Taylormade Aeroburner 15*
    Taylormade SLDR 19*
    Mizuno MP FliHi 21* 24*
    Mizuno MP-15 5-PW
    Mizuno MP T7 52* 58*
    Scotty Cameron TeI3 Newport Longneck
  • c7015c7015 Members Posts: 2,129 ✭✭

    wedge, the same club as from the fairway ....

    golfwrx

    TS3 Smoke 70g (S Flex)
    913 FD 3 wood Whiteboard (X Flex)
    915 F 5 wood Blueboard (S Flex)
    712U 4 Iron
    715CB 5-6
    718MB 7-PW 
    Vokey SM7 50, 55, 60 
    SC Newport 2.5
  • PepperturboPepperturbo Midwest and SouthwestMembers Posts: 15,528 ✭✭

    Yesterday I hit a crappy drive on #18. Found my ball just far enough into deep rough to be problematic. Anyhow, had 190 yards in and mistakenly chose 4 iron knowing I wasn't going to reach the pin. Unfortunately, I proceeded to put a crappy swing on the ball and only got 75yards and now on a downhill lie, still in the rough to an elevated tight left pin. Again, a poor choice in club ended short of the green and up and down for double. Up to 18, I was doing fine, then one mental mistake on top of another. Major brain-**** hole. It happens to all of us.

    Normally, club choice depends on how far I am from the green front, pin position, obstacles in between and if there's a bet. Typically, I take my medicine with a short iron of sorts and get up and down from there.

    • Titleist TS2 9.5, Fujikura Fuel Tour Spec 60 "S"
    • Titleist 917D2 15*, Blueboard 83 x5ct "S"
    • Titleist 716T-MB 17* 2 iron, Project X 5.5
    • Titleist 716CB 3i-PW, Project X 5.5
    • SM6 F-52*, Project X 5.5
    • SM6 M-58*, DG-S200
    • SC California Monterey
    • AVX or ProV1



  • YuckYuck Fore! Members Posts: 2,463 ✭✭

    If I am playing with a small headed iron like 716 CB or S56, an 8 iron. (39 or 40 Degrees of loft), It it is really bad, a 54 degree back to the fairway. I don't even understand how someone could even get the ball out with a hybrid. Heck, DJ was in heavy rough today and did not even get 50 yards of carry on a wedge.

  • Poor PosturePoor Posture Members Posts: 397 ✭✭

    I use my foot to kick back into the fairway and then just play my normal club for whatever the yardage is.

    Bigmean, on 08 September 2015 - 07:21 PM, said: "I know it is really frowned upon here, but hitting the club somewhere near the middle is generally the greatest tech advancement you can put in your bag."

    Titleist 917d2
    Titleist 917f 15*
    Taylormade V-steel 21* 7w
    4-P Mizuno MMC
    Edel 52*
    PXG 56*
    Byron dh89 raw
  • Johnny_FairwayJohnny_Fairway South Jersey (Philly Burbs)Members Posts: 554 ✭✭

    @Pepperturbo said:
    Yesterday I hit a crappy drive on #18. Found my ball just far enough into deep rough to be problematic. Anyhow, had 190 yards in and mistakenly chose 4 iron knowing I wasn't going to reach the pin. Unfortunately, I proceeded to put a crappy swing on the ball and only got 75yards and now on a downhill lie, still in the rough to an elevated tight left pin. Again, a poor choice in club ended short of the green and up and down for double. Up to 18, I was doing fine, then one mental mistake on top of another. Major brain-**** hole. It happens to all of us.

    Normally, club choice depends on how far I am from the green front, pin position, obstacles in between and if there's a bet. Typically, I take my medicine with a short iron of sorts and get up and down from there.

    I just tried the 4 iron second shot from a bad lie in the rough today. And similarly was still in the rough for my third. I should've just got back in the fairway somewhere and moved on.

  • Jakob 91Jakob 91 Members Posts: 64 ✭✭

    @Sweden_William said:
    I use my 23° hybrid for those shots.

    If we're talking semi-rough, that seems reasonable. OP was asking about THICK rough, though. As for the latter, I usually hack at it with a PW. When it's less buried, a 7i max.
    What I find very important is aiming correctly. I try to find the line that guarantees making it to the short grass but doesn't find the rough on the other side of the fairway should I get a flyer, which happens ever so often. Those are the mistakes that kill you.

    WITB 2019
    Woods
    Mizuno JPX 900 driver (9.5°)
    Mizuno JPX 900 3-wood (14°)
    Mizuno MP-18 MMC Fli-Hi 2i (16°)
    Nike Vapor Fly 3 Hybrid (20°)
    Irons
    Mizuno MP-15 (4-5)
    Mizuno MP-33 (6-PW)
    Mizuno S5 Wedges (56°/60°)
    Mizuno T-105 putter
    Ball
    Bridgestone B330 BXS/Snell MTB-X
    GPS/Scorekeeping
    Precision Pro NX7 Pro Slope
    The Grint/18 Birdies
  • brew4eaglebrew4eagle VAMembers Posts: 2,748 ✭✭

    I'd grab the 58* and try to lay up to 100 yds

    PING i20 10.5*
    Adams a7 19*
    PING G25 23*
    Nike VR Forged Pro Combo 5-P
    Titleist SM6 52.08F, 58.08M
    TaylorMade Spider Tour Black



  • davep043davep043 Members Posts: 3,246 ✭✭

    @Jakob 91 said:

    @Sweden_William said:
    I use my 23° hybrid for those shots.

    If we're talking semi-rough, that seems reasonable. OP was asking about THICK rough, though. As for the latter, I usually hack at it with a PW. When it's less buried, a 7i max.
    What I find very important is aiming correctly. I try to find the line that guarantees making it to the short grass but doesn't find the rough on the other side of the fairway should I get a flyer, which happens ever so often. Those are the mistakes that kill you.

    I agree, aiming is critical. I've seen lots of folks still line up for the flag, hit a half-decent shot along that line, and end up in the heavy rough again. You have to aim kind of across the fairway most times. Coming from heavy rough, with even the shortest club, the variability in results will increase substantially, and you have to take that into account when selecting your intended line. Move the ball closer to the hole, and keep it out of trouble spots like bunkers and more heavy rough.

  • Chowdah86Chowdah86 Members Posts: 342 ✭✭

    For me, in that situation, ball position and attack angle are most important. I move it back in stance so i catch it early in the swing and get the sweet spot to it through as little grass as possible. I also club up, however I avoid the flat faced irons and opting for hybrids if I'm too far away. So, its like either shorter irons or hybrids, never a 5i 4i 3i.

    The last thing: Hit that sonofabitch as hard as you can. Theres a certain threshold of swing speed, under which the thick grass will completely deny your clubhead. If you have a slow swing speed, move it back in your stance and use a hybrd, just try to get the sweet spot to the ball.

  • Plus2DegreesPlus2Degrees Members Posts: 15 ✭✭

    I would consider this a hazard situation and while tempted I would maintain my course mgmt and use a 9 iron to pop it to the fairway with a hinge and hold swing and move on.

    3 Wood: Callaway X2Hot Pro
    Hybrid: Ping I20 3H
    Irons: Callaway Steelhead XR
    PW: Callaway Steelhead XR
    GW: Ping iE 49
    AW: Cleveland 900 Tour Action 52
    SW: Cleveland 900 Tour Action 56
    LW: Cleveland CG 12 58/14
    SLW: Callaway Mack Daddy PM 60/10
    Putter: Taylormade Spider Vinco Center shaft
    Ball: Snell MTB

  • flanign2flanign2 Members Posts: 4

    I think most have covered it saying to use between 7i to SW. However, there's a riskier option if distance is required. Using a 3i-5i can work if you modify your setup. Biggest key is to hit steep down towards the ball. Any loop in the swing will catch grass before contact and ruin speed/direction. To negate the steep angle of attack, open the face and your stance. One swing thought would be to not allow your wrists to turn over. Keep the lead arm above the trail arm as long as possible. This will obviously produce a cut, but if executed, can produce a clean strike with more distance. Not a high percentage play, but a thought to consider at times!

  • jjfcpajjfcpa Driver - Tour Edge EXS 10.5 Omaha, NEMembers Posts: 408 ✭✭

    During my round yesterday, I watched my playing partner get into the same situation. Ball was in the thick rough about 5 - 6 yards off the fairway. I watched him hit the ball, which went about 40 yards and landed in the thick rough again. I asked him what club he hit and he said a 4 iron. He was about 200 from the green. I suggested next time he use a 8 or 9 iron and just try to get it back to the fairway and advance it about a 100 yards. he concurred. I hope I remember this the next time I get in the thick rough. Fortunately, yesterday I was finding nothing but fairways.

  • ThertyTherty SDMembers Posts: 78 ✭✭

    The wrong one, obviously.

    SLDR 430 (lol) + Kuro Kage Stiff 
    Ping G 3 wood 14.5* + Ping Tour 80 Stiff
    Maltby TS-2 2 Iron 18*
    Adams DHy 21* + White Tie Stiff
    CG16 Tour Black Pearl 4i-P + TT DG S300
    53* and 58* Mizuno S5 Blue Ion
    Nike Origin B1-01 34"
  • JAMH03JAMH03 Members Posts: 552 ✭✭

    @jjfcpa said:
    Played a round yesterday and found my ball in some very thick rough. Grass was almost like crab grass and about 4 - 5 inches deep. I was about 150 from the green and decided to go with a 5 iron. Could not get the club on the ball directly and when I swung, the grass just completely grabbed the club and the ball went maybe 30 - 40 yards. On second thought, I think I should have chosen a different club.. perhaps a hybrid. What would you have chosen.

    Hybrids, or smaller headed FW woods are better out of the rough.

    If the rough is especially knarly from 150 not sure how I would control the distance though. Another trick is to attack the ball a lot steeper if you can so using a less lofted iron knowing you can't get the ball there. Say 8 or 9 iron.

    Comparisons are odious.



Sign In or Register to comment.