Most Overrated Course

2456732

Comments

  • SilverBulletsSilverBullets BMW Members Posts: 5,884 ✭✭
    double_d wrote:


    The Ocean Course at Kiawah is better than Pebble Beach and has more seaward holes. It's also more difficult.



    There. I said it.



    I know many people who agree and few who disagree personally.



    If you haven't played both, your vote doesn't count.




    More seaward holes? There were only like 3 or 4 holes that you could even see the ocean on at Kiawah. I agree though, Kiawah was harder. Kiawah has less boring holes. My only problem is, the great holes at pebble are truly breathtaking. Truly incredible golf holes. Kiawah, while an absolutely fantastic golf course, didn't have that wow factor to me. Like I said in my earlier post, I love Kiawah. I think it's great. It has probably 15-16 very very good golf holes. Just IMO it didn't have any incredible golf holes. Pebble has 6 or so incredible holes and 12 above average holes.



    If given equal price for greens fees, I'd take pebble nearly every time... At $500 for pebble and $300 for Kiawah... I'm taking Kiawah 70% of the time.
    Taylormade M6 10.5* - HZRDUS Smoke Black 6.5
    Taylormade '16 M2 15*
    Titleist 816h 21*
    Callaway Apex 4i thru PW - Nippon Modus 125 Tour X
    Vokey SM6 50*, 54*, 58*
    Scotty Cameron Circa 62 No. 2 - Scotty Custom Shop
  • kadillackountrykadillackountry Members Posts: 207
    teejaywhy wrote:



    I'll get grief for this, but Quintero is way overrated IMO.




    No grief from me. I agree with you.


    I'll bite. Must not have been hitting the driver straight. There are some things to complain about (similar club in hand on all the Par 3s), but all in all that is a spectacular track. One is hard pressed to find better golf in the Phoenix area for public consumption. It competes with the best tracks out here (Southern Dunes, Troon North, Greyhawk, WeKoPa) and is never over priced like several on that list.
    Driver - 2017 Taylormade M2 10.5* - Project X Hzrdus T1100 75g 6.5 shaft
    3 Wood - TaylorMade M1 Fuji Speeder 767 X
    Irons 3-PW - Mizuno MP 4 - Project X 6.0
    Wedges - Titleist Vokey SM6 - 50* 54* 60*
    Putter - Scotty Cameron Newport 2 TEI3
    Ball - Taylormade TP5x
  • kg92leftykg92lefty Members Posts: 2,309 ✭✭
    Wolf Creek in mesquite. By far the most overrated dump I've played. My dad said pebble was overrated when he played there.
  • SilverBulletsSilverBullets BMW Members Posts: 5,884 ✭✭

    teejaywhy wrote:



    I'll get grief for this, but Quintero is way overrated IMO.




    No grief from me. I agree with you.


    I'll bite. Must not have been hitting the driver straight. There are some things to complain about (similar club in hand on all the Par 3s), but all in all that is a spectacular track. One is hard pressed to find better golf in the Phoenix area for public consumption. It competes with the best tracks out here (Southern Dunes, Troon North, Greyhawk, WeKoPa) and is never over priced like several on that list.




    Yeah I thought Quintero was spectacular. The par 3's were pretty redundant but other than that I thought it was great.



    However, if I lived in Phoenix, I would never play sans special occasions (friends traving in). While the course is very cool, it's kind of gimmicky at the same time and I'm not sure I would want to play it regularly.
    Taylormade M6 10.5* - HZRDUS Smoke Black 6.5
    Taylormade '16 M2 15*
    Titleist 816h 21*
    Callaway Apex 4i thru PW - Nippon Modus 125 Tour X
    Vokey SM6 50*, 54*, 58*
    Scotty Cameron Circa 62 No. 2 - Scotty Custom Shop
  • JumboJackJumboJack Members Posts: 864 ✭✭
    Trum LA by far. Like someone previously mentioned. You can stripe one down the middle and end up in jail. No way in the world would I pay 280.00 to play it. I have a coupon to play for 150.00 and I'm not going to use it.
    TM M2 2017 10.5 Hzrdus Yellow 65 S
    Ping G400 14.5 Alta CB S
    Ping Anser 17* 23* Kuro Kage 80H S
    PING iE1 5-PW Modus3 105 S
    PING Glide 2.0 50* 54* 60* Modus 115 Wedge S
    PING Craz-e h Vault 2.0
    NDMC Plus 4
    ProV1
  • Grizz06Grizz06 Members Posts: 266 ✭✭
    oh, I would have to add Doral to that list as well. Personally, I kind of thought all golf (I played) in Miami sucked.
  • sharkiesjsharkiesj Members Posts: 2,992 ✭✭
    edited Aug 12, 2015 #38
    jptruck wrote:


    Easy: SPYGLASS HILLS. Two interesting holes in the dunes and then it's basically Poppy Hills II through the woods. Will never go back.




    Spyglass Hill, not Hills



    I'm sorry to be such a stickler but it is one of my pet peeves when people do not correctly spell the names of golf courses. Especially the one's here in California.
  • Thunder DanThunder Dan Members Posts: 1,240 ✭✭
    edited Aug 12, 2015 #39


    I've always felt Cog Hill #4 was overrated.




    This.



    I also thought Pinehurst #2 was overrated. I played it last year, it was nice and fun to play, but I doubt I'd drop another $500 to play it. I didn't feel like it was that memorable. Whereas I played Whistling Straits and kept looking around and couldn't believe I was in Wisconsin. Some of the views at that place were incredible.



    Played Doral last year... it's overrated for a $495 price tag that's for sure.
  • BrooklynGolferBrooklynGolfer Members Posts: 327
    Tallgrass, Long Island....Somehow it manages to creep into top public NY courses....looks and plays like an open cow field to me.....horribly overrated.
  • dlygrissedlygrisse Members Posts: 13,109 ✭✭
    edited Aug 12, 2015 #41
    Here is the problem, many of you are comparing the price you played to how you rate the course. I played #2 and Pebble on someone elses dime....loved them both.



    Pebble is a bit of a let down once you step onto the 11th tee... having just played the most breath taking and famous stretch of golf in the world. You finish pretty strong on 17 and 18, but even 18 doesn't seem as cool in real life as it does on TV. Still everyone should play it once, it's a great experience. So I don't think it's overrated, it's just that some holes are so spectacular that the others pale in comparison. Still the history and experience of the place is something any golfer should appreciate.



    #2 is 18 of the finest golf holes on an single course I have played. Nothing really jumps out at you, there are no mountains, there is no water, no major elevation changes. Just 18 holes that appear to be no harder than most courses you play at first site. When you combine the fact that Donald Ross spent his life perfecting the layout and the history of the place it is very special. If you really think about he architecture...bunker placements, the green complexes, the strategy needed to play each hole properly I think it is almost the perfect course. It is very playable for a high handicapper and challenging for a pro, fairways are easy to hit but the bunkers are placed in a way that you should flirt with them to attack the green, if you play safe you have a tough angle, much like the Old Course.



    In my opinion the most overrated courses are any designed by Jack Nicklaus. I love Jack the player but his courses are all predictable, par 5's are generally reachable for long hitters, par 4's are generally barely reachable for average hitters, the greens are overly sloped with huge contours. Tons of forced carries and because his name is on it they cost $50 more to play than they should. I have played several of his courses and none of them blow me away.

    Ping G400
    Callaway Rogue 3w, HW
    Ping G 4 hybrid
    Ping G 4-U
    Ping Glide 2.0 Stealth 54* SS
    Vokey 58 M grind
    Odyssey Pro #1 black
    Jones Utility
    ECCO Biom Hybrid 3
  • MichiganManMichiganMan HAIL TO THE VICTORS! GO BLUE! Winston-Salem, NCMembers Posts: 1,600 ✭✭
    dlygrisse wrote:


    Here is the problem, many of you are comparing the price you played to how you rate the course. I played #2 and Pebble on someone elses dime....loved them both.



    Pebble is a bit of a let down once you step onto the 11th tee... having just played the most breath taking and famous stretch of golf in the world. You finish pretty strong on 17 and 18, but even 18 doesn't seem as cool in real life as it does on TV. Still everyone should play it once, it's a great experience. So I don't think it's overrated, it's just that some holes are so spectacular that the others pale in comparison. Still the history and experience of the place is something any golfer should appreciate.



    #2 is 18 of the finest golf holes on an single course I have played. Nothing really jumps out at you, there are no mountains, there is no water, no major elevation changes. Just 18 holes that appear to be no harder than most courses you play at first site. When you combine the fact that Donald Ross spent his life perfecting the layout and the history of the place it is very special. If you really think about he architecture...bunker placements, the green complexes, the strategy needed to play each hole properly I think it is almost the perfect course. It is very playable for a high handicapper and challenging for a pro, fairways are easy to hit but the bunkers are placed in a way that you should flirt with them to attack the green, if you play safe you have a tough angle, much like the Old Course.



    In my opinion the most overrated courses are any designed by Jack Nicklaus. I love Jack the player but his courses are all predictable, par 5's are generally reachable for long hitters, par 4's are generally barely reachable for average hitters, the greens are overly sloped with huge contours. Tons of forced carries and because his name is on it they cost $50 more to play than they should. I have played several of his courses and none of them blow me away.




    I understand what you're saying, but I didn't pay a dime to play any of the courses I listed....and to me they (Doral & Poppy Hills) were still vastly overrated.



    The only complaint I had about Pebble was that the greens were SLOW. But considering their tee sheet is stacked literally every single day, and the views the course provides, pace of play would be 6 hours if they cut them much shorter.



    I do agree with your assessment of Nicklaus courses though. I've never been a big fan of his designs. Too many dog leg rights for a guy who likes to play a high draw. To be fair though, most courses designed in the last 20 years don't do a whole lot for me (generally speaking). Courses today are built way too long and way too challenging for the average player.
    TaylorMade M3 9.5* - Fujikura Atmos Tour Spec Blue 7x
    Nike Vapor Speed 15* - Fujikura Rombax P95x
    TaylorMade UDI 2 iron - Tour Only Project X HZRDUS 105g 6.5
    Mizuno JPX 919 Forged 4 iron - KBS C Taper X
    Mizuno JPX 919 Tour 5-PW - KBS C Taper X
    TaylorMade Antique Bronze Milled Grind 54* SB - KBS 610
    TaylorMade Milled Grind Hi-Toe 58* - KBS 610
    Custom Cameron & Crown Mallet 1
    TaylorMade TP5x
  • exgolfproexgolfpro Members Posts: 767 ✭✭
    MarkCPA wrote:

    exgolfpro wrote:


    Of the courses that I have played that others would have heard of, TPC Southwind (Memphis) was the most disappointing. After leaving the course, I couldn't remember a few of the holes and the maintenance of the course was what you would find and most good public courses in your home town.



    Disclaimer: I believe they have remodelled the course since I played there, so things may have changed.




    No remodeling or redesign that I know of. Just a conversion from bent to bermuda greens some years ago. Otherwise, I'm not aware of anything different from the course that John Cook smoked to the tune of a 54 hole scoring record to the one where now the 72 hole winning score is usually around -10.




    You may be right. Every year when I watch the tourney, they talk about how the course is 'different' so I assumed it was redesigned.
  • QManyQMany #TheWRX ClubWRX Posts: 9,044 ClubWRX
    The Ocean Course at Kiawah.



    It was good, but not great, and certainly not Top 20 in the USA. I have played $50 public tracks in Nebraska that are better.
    Currently in #TheWRX...

    Taylormade M3 460 (9.5°) Tensei CK Pro White 70TX
    Callaway GBB Epic SZ (15°) Tensei CK Pro Blue 80TX
    Callaway XR Pro (20°) Diamana White 90X
    Callaway Apex Pro (4i-PW) DG X100 TI
    Ping Glide 2.0 (50° & 54°) DG S400 TI
    Artisan MT Grind (58°) DG S400
    Odyssey O Works R-Line
    Taylormade TP5X


    QMany's Swing/Sticks / Instagram
  • LittleLeftToRightLittleLeftToRight Turn that frown upside down! Members Posts: 2,036 ✭✭
    dlygrisse wrote:




    In my opinion the most overrated courses are any designed by Jack Nicklaus. I love Jack the player but his courses are all predictable, par 5's are generally reachable for long hitters, par 4's are generally barely reachable for average hitters, the greens are overly sloped with huge contours. Tons of forced carries and because his name is on it they cost $50 more to play than they should. I have played several of his courses and none of them blow me away.




    The most overrated course that I have played since I took up golf again is Old Corkscrew outside of Naples. It is a Nicklaus design and it is exactly like you describe. I had no trouble getting around it from the tippy tips even though I accidentally grabbed the wrong driver leaving the house (10.5º instead of my usual 6º) and didn't hit a long drive all day. They had also punched the greens poorly probably a couple weeks before I played it and the greens rolled like crap. I didn't make a putt outside of 6 feet all day. On the 16th I missed a 12 footer and had enough. I pulled the putt back five times, and didn't make any of them. Each one missed differently too. It was like playing a muni. I thought the layout was rather bland. It basically looked like just about every other course here in the swamp. Little bit of roll on the fairways and elevated greens. Miss the fairway and you are in the jungle. Nothing special about it. Courses in Fl tend to be all the same though. I miss growing up playing golf in the MidWest. Courses had character.
    [font=georgia,serif]Cobra Bio Cell Pro 8.5º Aldila Black Mamba 60TX T1"[/font]

    [font=georgia, serif]Tour Edge Exotics CB4 16.5º Oban Devotion 8/05 T1.5"[/font]

    [font=georgia, serif]Tommy Armour "Heater" 14º DI Aldila Rip Tour X[/font]

    [font=georgia, serif]Srixon I-701 Tour TT Black Gold X 3-PW[/font]

    [font=georgia,serif]Callaway Jaws CC 50º/54º/58 PX 6.5
    Hogan P131[/font]
  • golfdummygolfdummy Members Posts: 149 ✭✭
    I would have to say for me it's a tie. Hazeltine for the same reason another poster said. Difficult and I'm not sure I can remember more than 2 holes. Medinah #3 for the same reasons
  • mallratmallrat Members Posts: 2,913 ✭✭
    This may be sac religious to some but Torrey and Spanish Bay, IMO.



    Spanish Bay was the epitoMe of target golf and that is not my favorite, but I thoroughly enjoyed Spyglass on the other hand.



    Now Torrey, IMO, was a bunch of utterly forgettable holes with 2 or 3 scenic holes thrown in. If it wasn't on the coast would it be talked about at all?
  • SilverBulletsSilverBullets BMW Members Posts: 5,884 ✭✭
    mallrat wrote:


    This may be sac religious to some but Torrey and Spanish Bay, IMO.



    Spanish Bay was the epitoMe of target golf and that is not my favorite, but I thoroughly enjoyed Spyglass on the other hand.



    Now Torrey, IMO, was a bunch of utterly forgettable holes with 2 or 3 scenic holes thrown in. If it wasn't on the coast would it be talked about at all?




    I thought Spanish bay was pretty weak as well. Then again I played it just before playing Spyglass, Pebble and Cypress so ultimately it just got completely forgotten haha.



    For the poster who said Jack courses.. I completely agree. It's probably why I hate the Ohio State course which he redesigned. The only exception I have is Muirfield Village. That is a excellent golf course. It's not just a masterpiece for him, it's simply a masterpiece for any golf design.
    Taylormade M6 10.5* - HZRDUS Smoke Black 6.5
    Taylormade '16 M2 15*
    Titleist 816h 21*
    Callaway Apex 4i thru PW - Nippon Modus 125 Tour X
    Vokey SM6 50*, 54*, 58*
    Scotty Cameron Circa 62 No. 2 - Scotty Custom Shop
  • oregongolforegongolf Lefty Boomers Posts: 8,569 ✭✭
    edited Aug 12, 2015 #49
    mallrat wrote:


    This may be sac religious to some but Torrey and Spanish Bay, IMO.



    Spanish Bay was the epitoMe of target golf and that is not my favorite, but I thoroughly enjoyed Spyglass on the other hand.



    Now Torrey, IMO, was a bunch of utterly forgettable holes with 2 or 3 scenic holes thrown in. If it wasn't on the coast would it be talked about at all?




    I would also vote Spanish Bay and Torrey Pines. Great post-round environment at Spanish Bay.



    Sahalee is also incredibly overrated. I have always thought there are 9 good holes throughout the whole property... the other 18 are pretty average. Typically, it's in great shape though. It's not even in my top 10 for the entire state (ouch).



    I can see how Wolf Creek would be voted as overrated. It should probably be voted as more fun than highly rated.
  • Indy GolferIndy Golfer Members Posts: 271 ✭✭


    I've always felt Cog Hill #4 was overrated.




    Ditto
    TM M2 8.5* Graphite Design Tour AD GP 6X+
    TM TP UDi #1 w/ Diamana
    TM TP UDi #3, MC 4-7, MB 8-P w/ Tour V S+
    TM TP EF Tour Issue 50* & 56*, 62*
    TM Spider Mallet w/ Carbon insert
    TM TPx
  • One_Putt_BlunderOne_Putt_Blunder Members Posts: 10,801 ✭✭
    Torrey South, when it is not in tournament condition becomes a very overrated $250 difficult muni (from a non resident standpoint)



    In AZ Pre 2015 renovation TPC Scottsdale hands down most over rated track in the state. Renovation came out very good and it is an enjoyable track now.



    AZ state rankings wise I agree Quintero very over rated.
    [twitter]oneputtblunder[/twitter]
    10.5 Aeroburner TP Fujikura Speeder Pro XLR8
    14.5 X2 Hot 3 Deep Tour Green
    18* X2 Hot Pro Hybrid
    RSI TP 4-PW KBS Tour 120
    Byron Morgan DH89 Rincon Neck deep mill or Circa 62 No 2
    Vokey 52/56/60 SM5/TVDK/TVDVgrind DG S300
    WITB Link
  • ChilidogChilidog Members Posts: 3,970 ✭✭
    Torrey South has to win this argument. I would throw the other muni across the country in the mix as well in Bethpage Black. They just made long, narrowed in courses by the rough with small greens. The designs are very ordinary. Spyglass has to be one of the biggest let downs I've experienced in a while. And this is going to be blasphemy to say but Pine Valley is up there as well. Was so pumped for that first trip and was so let down. Coming off 18 I couldn't believe that was the course I was so excited about.
  • kobes31kobes31 EFF Members Posts: 790 ✭✭
    Paiute wolf course. Probably the most recommended to me before I went to Vegas. Not amazing shape considering the price. Nothing unique besides a remake of Sawgrass 17, but how many if those exist? They had to make theirs play 190 though good luck holding that With a strong tailwind. Every hole is just pure brute. Flat, windy and if you're just a bit off you'll find yourself in rock desert ****. Hated every minute of that course.
  • apprenti23apprenti23 ClubWRX Posts: 3,885
    edited Aug 12, 2015 #54
    Pebble Beach (overpriced) and Whistling Straits (over designed and overpriced).
  • bcawley01bcawley01 Members Posts: 171 ✭✭
    Dove Mountain, Tuscon AZ. Good course, friendly staff but many forgettable holes and way overpriced
    Titliest 913D2 10.5*
    Cobra Fly-Z 13*
    Titliest 910D2 15*
    Cobra Fly-Z 22*
    Nike Vapor Fly Pro 5-P
    Vokey SM5 52*
    Vokey SM5 56*
    Vokey SM5 60*
    Scotty Cameron Newport 2.6
  • jptruckjptruck Unregistered Posts: 842
    sharkiesj wrote:

    jptruck wrote:


    Easy: SPYGLASS HILLS. Two interesting holes in the dunes and then it's basically Poppy Hills II through the woods. Will never go back.




    Spyglass Hill, not Hills



    I'm sorry to be such a stickler but it is one of my pet peeves when people do not correctly spell the names of golf courses. Especially the one's here in California.




    Spyglass Hill. Thanks for giving me the chance to say it sucks twice.
  • ryu123ryu123 Members Posts: 494 ✭✭
    maybe some people are talking about overpriced courses, rather than overrated ones.



    Pebble Beach is overpriced, but I think it's a very good course and not overrated. Holes #7, 8, 9 and 18 are world class, and even the 'weakest' of the rest are still good. (I haven't played it since the recent renovation of #17, but photos of the new green look fine.)



    I agree with Oregongolf that Sahalee (north / south) is overrated. (I don't think it's overpriced, because a buddy and I paid $200 to play it.)



    For me, Sherwood Country Club is overrated.
  • 2bGood2bGood Members Posts: 4,974 ✭✭
    edited Aug 12, 2015 #58
    ryu123 wrote:


    maybe some people are talking about overpriced courses, rather than overrated ones.



    Pebble Beach is overpriced, but I think it's a very good course and not overrated. Holes #7, 8, 9 and 18 are world class, and even the 'weakest' of the rest are still good. (I haven't played it since the recent renovation of #17, but photos of the new green look fine.)



    I agree with Oregongolf that Sahalee (north / south) is overrated. (I don't think it's overpriced, because a buddy and I paid $200 to play it.)



    For me, Sherwood Country Club is overrated.




    I tend to think they go hand in hand. They can charge the price they do because of the rating they have. I stand by Pebble being overrated - it is not in the top ten public courses in the US for me - making it (in my mind) at least 10-25 spots too high on most lists. Having said that - if you can play it once. It well worth one visit for sure.



    Now if the question was overrated golf 'experiences' I would actually have pebble as underrated and it is a great place to spend some time.
  • RSinSGRSinSG ClubWRX Posts: 3,061 ClubWRX
    Torrey Pines South. Been there done that for me. And I didn't have to pay much as it was a tournament.



    Wolf Creek in Mesquite. I live 30 minutes from it and it is a "Once a year" type of course for me. It is fun to take people there for the first time though. Not unlike taking them to an Amusement Park.



    PGA West Stadium. I used to play it a couple of times every summer for free when I lived in Palm Springs and there is no way I'd pay the $$ they charge for it.
    Ping G400 Tour AD DI6s
    Ping G30 3 wood, 5 wood
    Ben Hogan VTKR 21* hybrid
    Ping G400 Irons 5-SW, Steel Fiber i95
    Ping Glide 60* LW
    Scotty Cameron Studio Blade (or)
     Scotty CameronFastback
    Gamegolf
    https://www.ledges.com/ Home course
  • sharkiesjsharkiesj Members Posts: 2,992 ✭✭
    jptruck wrote:

    sharkiesj wrote:

    jptruck wrote:


    Easy: SPYGLASS HILLS. Two interesting holes in the dunes and then it's basically Poppy Hills II through the woods. Will never go back.




    Spyglass Hill, not Hills



    I'm sorry to be such a stickler but it is one of my pet peeves when people do not correctly spell the names of golf courses. Especially the one's here in California.




    Spyglass Hill. Thanks for giving me the chance to say it sucks twice.




    Ha! Love it. I happen to agree with you. Of any course on the entire Monterey Peninsula, the most overrated is Spyglass Hill AT THE RACK RATE.. Holes 1-4 define the place then you're playing Poppy Hills but you're paying near Pebble prices. Duke's Club price is easier to justify but really, can anyone here honestly recall a single hole on the back nine that stands out as sheer genius or even half memorable? If you can you're a liar. I've played it 6 times and while nice, I can't wait to finish so I can leave and go eat somewhere. The pro shop is a 2 foot by 3 foot cardboard box. My a$$ sticks out the front door while I'm paying my green fee.
  • golfdummygolfdummy Members Posts: 149 ✭✭
    I'll be interested to see if you still think Sherwood is overrated when we're done with our 20 million dollar course renovation. I can understand why some would feel that it was before.
Sign In or Register to comment.